Edinburgh Festival and Fringe 2017 reviews round-up
theartsdesk recommends the shows to catch this August
Wondering what on earth to choose between as you tramp the streets of the festival? These are our highlights so far.
STANDUP
Athenu Kugblenu, Underbelly Med Quad ★★★ Strong debut hour of political and identity comedy
Edinburgh Fringe 2017 reviews: Ingrid Oliver / Darren Harriott / Jayde Adams
An excellent mimic, a strong debut, and a dynamic entertainer
Ingrid Oliver ★★★★
Ingrid Oliver is an old Edinburgh hand as one half of the sketch duo Watson and Oliver, but this is her debut solo show, and a very fine one it is. The set-up in Speech! is that she plays various characters giving speeches – among them a nervous TED-talker, a man leading an improv class, and a boorish student-union activist who wants to no-platform everybody ("As students we shouldn't have to engage with other people's opinions").
Edinburgh Festival 2017 reviews: Meet Me at Dawn / The Shape of the Pain / Wild Bore
Grief, loss, unending pain - and critics talking out of their backsides
Meet Me at Dawn ★★★★★
Edinburgh Fringe 2017 reviews: Hannah Gadsby / Suzi Ruffell / Ivo Graham / Athena Kugblenu
A possible valediction, class concerns, feeling the privilege, and millennial politics
Hannah Gadsby ★★★★
This is Hannah Gadsby's last show, she tells us. Not because she has stopped being funny (she most definitely hasn't, as the laugh count in this show attests), but because making comedy out of her life experience has become toxic for her.
Edinburgh Fringe 2017 reviews: Pike St / Box Clever / Sugar Baby
Comedy, tragedy and a whole lot more at Paines Plough's pop-up Roundabout
Pike St ★★★★
Edinburgh Fringe 2017 reviews: Tom Allen / Cally Beaton / Lauren Pattison / Trumpageddon
A happy anniversary, neural pathways, an assured debut, and a deflated Trump
Tom Allen ★★★★
Tom Allen is celebrating his 10th year at the Fringe, and he appears to be having a ball – and so do we. He bounds on stage full of energy and does a fantastically strong 10 minutes' interaction with the audience, and when he finds comedy gold in the front row with a management consultant, a nurse on a liver ward and a judge, he dextrously weaves details of their lives into the show.
Edinburgh Fringe 2017 reviews: Kiri Pritchard-McLean / Dad's Army Radio Hour / Elliot Steel
Unlikely subject matter for gags, an old favourite revived, and one for the millennials
Kiri Pritchard-McLean ★★★★
Appropriate Adult has an unlikely subject for comedy – Kiri Pritchard-McLean's work with vulnerable teenagers. But it proves rich territory as she recounts her relationship with one in particular, 15-year-old “Harriet”. Don't worry, it doesn't pose an ethical issue, as the comic, rather than the child, is the butt of the jokes – of which there are plenty.
Edinburgh Fringe 2017 reviews: Tiff Stevenson / Jarlath Regan / Urzila Carlson
The politics of beauty, the comedy of organ donation and big laughs from the southern hemisphere
Tiff Stevenson ★★★★
“I identify as a 10!” Tiff Stevenson tells us in Bombshell. It’s a strong opener, particularly as she follows with: “And if you don’t agree you’re beauty-phobic.” It’s not to boast, though, more marking her territory in a show about the shifting sands of modern sexual politics. Why should women identify with a male view of the world?
Edinburgh Fringe 2017 reviews: Adam / Eve / Nassim
Three compelling shows on identity - gender and otherwise - at the Traverse Theatre
Eve ★★★★
Transgender issues are high on the agenda at this year’s Fringe, with the energetic Testosterone at the Pleasance and the breezy You’ve Changed from Northern Stage at Summerhall among the stand-outs. In addition, the National Theatre of Scotland brings two trans-themed shows to the Traverse Theatre.