Best of 2016: Opera

BEST OF 2016: OPERA A complex, giddying 'Lulu' is queen of a year rich in new operas

A complex, giddying 'Lulu' is queen of a year rich in new operas

It was the best and worst of years for English National Opera. Best, because principals, chorus and orchestra seem united in acclaiming their Music Director of 14 months, Mark Wigglesworth, for his work at a level most had only dreamed of (“from the bottom up,” said a cellist, contrasting it with the top-down approach of predecessor Edward Gardner). Worst, because he stayed true to his principle of only working with a full-time company, and when the chorus unexpectedly accepted a nine-month contract, announced his departure.

William Kentridge: Thick Time, Whitechapel Gallery

WILLIAM KENTRIDGE: THICK TIME, WHITECHAPEL GALLERY A parallel universe revealed in immersive installations and monumental tapestries

A parallel universe revealed in immersive installations and monumental tapestries

Of all the mesmerising images in William Kentridge’s major Whitechapel show, the one that lingers most, perhaps, is that of the artist himself, now turned 60, hunched and thoughtful, wandering through the studio in Johannesburg where he lives and works. He paces, meditates over a "magical" cup of coffee, imagines, draws, tears paper, works, adjusts, observes, directs – all in the gentle manner of a Buster Keaton-style silent film star. Time in this metaphoric space is thick with possibilities, under-stated humour and conundrums.

Corin Sworn: Max Mara Art Prize for Women, Whitechapel Gallery

CORIN SWORN: MAX MARA ART PRIZE FOR WOMEN, WHITECHAPEL GALLERY Impostors and stolen identities explored in an installation inspired by the Commedia dell’Arte

Impostors and stolen identities explored in an installation inspired by the Commedia dell’Arte

Glasgow-based Corin Sworn is the fifth winner of the Max Mara Art Prize for Women. Every two years a British artist is chosen on the basis of a proposal, rather than existing work. The fashion house then supports the project with funding, a bespoke, six-month residency in Italy and, following the Whitechapel Gallery show, an exhibition at the Collezione Maramotti in Reggio Emilia, where the HQ of the family-run business is located.

Adventures of the Black Square: Abstract Art and Society 1915-2015, Whitechapel Gallery

An exhibition about how geometric abstraction took over the world loses the plot

From an apparently simple idea stems a very confusing exhibition. Here’s the idea: taking the seminal black square painted by Russian artist Kazimir Malevich as its starting point – in fact, a rectangle, with the small and undated Black Quadrilateral the first of three Malevich paintings – we are invited, over the span of a century and across a number of continents, to explore the evolution of geometric abstraction and its relation to “ideas of utopia”.  

Richard Tuttle, Tate Modern / Whitechapel Gallery

RICHARD TUTTLE, TATE MODERN / WHITECHAPEL GALLERY Renowned American artist revisits old themes in his biggest sculpture yet

Renowned American artist revisits old themes in his biggest sculpture yet

It could be an aircraft, hastily covered with some very inadequate wrappings and squeezed into the great hangar of the Turbine Hall. Or perhaps an eccentric sort of bird, its bedraggled wings missing chunks of orange plumage, in contrast to its plush, red body. Or perhaps it is part of a stage set with extravagant swags of red fabric carefully arranged to look, fleetingly, like theatre curtains, or pieces of scenery either under construction or partially wrapped, ready to be put away.

Chris Marker: A Grin Without A Cat, Whitechapel Gallery

CHRIS MARKER: A GRIN WITHOUT A CAT, WHITECHAPEL GALLERY A survey of the influential French filmmaker proves a difficult introduction to his work

A survey of the influential French filmmaker proves a difficult introduction to his work

If you’re not already familiar with at least some aspects of Chris Marker’s work, this exhibition will feel overwhelming, if not confusing. You may have to pay a second visit to get the most out of it, or even make sense of it. It’s certainly a demanding retrospective of the influential French filmmaker, and an immersive "surround-screen" gallery survey probably isn’t the best introduction.

Hannah Höch, Whitechapel Gallery

A rich survey of the Berlin Dada artist may also make you recoil over some of its imagery

What once appeared daring and transgressive will often barely raise an eyebrow given time. This much is obvious – or at least up to a point, since much avant-garde art continues to challenge and/or bemuse well into the 21st century. But the reverse can also be true. What was once produced as a work typical of its time can now make us feel very uncomfortable. 

Sarah Lucas: Situation, Whitechapel Gallery

TAD AT 5 - ON VISUAL ART: SARAH LUCAS, WHITECHAPEL GALLERY Bodily functions, toilet humour, saucy root vegetables - but it's not all laughs and good, clean fun

Bodily functions, toilet humour, saucy root vegetables - but it's not all laughs and good, clean fun

I read someone recently describe Sarah Lucas’s sculptures as “aggressive”. Perhaps being greeted by a roomful of huge plaster cocks, mechanised wanking arms and greasy doner kebabs with two fried eggs in an abject arrangement of the female sex can feel a little confrontational, but aggressive? There’s surely something deflecting and bluntly one-note when it comes to the merely aggressive. “Aggressive” rarely lets other emotions in, and Lucas’s work is a many shaded affair.

The Spirit of Utopia, Whitechapel Gallery

Utopian visions morph into muddle-headed dreaming

Some artists seem to need a reality check. The Spirit of Utopia is billed as a show of artists “who speculate on alternative futures for society, the economy and the environment”; but anyone anticipating cogent analysis or visionary ideas will be disappointed. The exhibition consists of a bunch of dreamers who imagine that an art context gives social significance to weak or wacky ideas. It doesn’t.

Gillian Wearing, Whitechapel Gallery

Playing with notions of truth and deception, raw emotions are revealed in compelling works

The first major retrospective of the videos, photographs and sculptures of Gillian Wearing is a deeply disturbing experience. Her videos can be just a few minutes, or as long as an hour, but are not sequential narratives. They can be dipped in and out of - unlike many video artists you do not have to acquiesce to her time scale. But take a lot of time: they are more than worth it, and repay repeated viewings.