Phaedra, Linbury Theatre review - from confusing passion to blazing afterlife

★★★★ PHAEDRA, LINBURY THEATRE From confusing passion to blazing afterlife

Henze's near-death experience gives this skewed mythology extraordinary life

Leaving a revival performance of Harrison Birtwistle's The Minotaur, a friend asked Hans Werner Henze, also in the audience, that dreaded question: "what did you think?" "Very competent and extremely well performed," came the answer.

Semele, Monteverdi Choir, EBS, Gardiner, Alexandra Palace review - Handel's cornucopia lavishly served

★★★★ SEMELE, GARDINER, ALEXANDRA PALACE Handel's cornucopia lavishly served

No 'secular oratorio' in these hands, but an ultimately electrifying opera

Louise Alder, lyric soprano of the moment and vivacity incarnate, had yet to be born when John Eliot Gardiner made his first recording of Handel's Semele with the Monteverdi Choir and English Baroque Soloists in 1981.

Aida, Opera North review - militarism soundly subverted

★★★★ AIDA, OPERA NORTH Militarism soundly subverted

Annabel Arden’s vision and Richard Armstrong’s conducting make a powerful mix

Opera North created something approaching a new art form when they performed Wagner’s Ring in "concert stagings", putting their large orchestra in full view, with singers symbolically dressed and given limited front-of-stage space, and a continuous projected screen backdrop.

'The orchestra becomes the landscape': Annabel Arden on Opera North's concert staging of Aida

'THE ORCHESTRA BECOMES THE LANDSCAPE': Annabel Arden on Opera North's concert staging of Aida

The director on Verdi's late masterpiece in a war-torn contemporary setting

This will be the latest in Opera North’s acclaimed concert stagings of large-scale works, which have previously included Wagner’s Ring cycle, Puccini’s Turandot and Strauss’s Salome.

Billy Budd, Royal Opera review - Britten's drama of good and evil too much at sea

★★★ BILLY BUDD, ROYAL OPERA Britten's drama of good and evil too much at sea

Peerless protagonist among a crew sometimes lost on an infinite stage

On one level, it's about Biblically informed good and evil at sea, in both the literal and the metaphorical sense. On another, the love that dared not speak its name when Britten and E M Forster adapted Hermann Melville's novella is either repressed or (putatively) liberated. The conflicts can make for lacerating music theatre, as they did in Orpha Phelan's production for Opera North.

SS Mendi: Dancing the Death Drill, Isango Ensemble, Linbury Theatre - evocative and essential lyric theatre

★★★★ SS MENDI: DANCING THE DEATH DRILL, LINBURY Evocative, essential lyric theatre

Compelling fantasia about black South Africans drowned in a World War One disaster

While Bach's and Handel's Passions have been driving thousands to contemplate suffering, mortality and grace, this elegy for black lives lost over a century ago also chimes movingly with pre-Easter offerings.

Faust, Royal Opera review - fusty Gounod still dances

★★★ FAUST, ROYAL OPERA Lively conducting and last-minute replacement enliven hellish cabaret

Lively conducting and a last-minute replacement keep this hellish cabaret on its toes

Goethe's cosmic Faust becomes Gounod's operatic fust in what, somewhat surprisingly, remains a repertoire staple. You go for the tunes, hoping for the world-class voices to do them justice and prepared for a pallid quarter-of-an-hour or two.

Franco Fagioli, Il Pomo d’Oro, Birmingham Town Hall review - flair and flamboyance

★★★★ FRANCO FAGIOLI, IL POMO D'ORO, BIRMINGHAM TOWN HALL Virtuoso countertenor shines in music from Handel and his contemporaries

Virtuoso countertenor shines in music from Handel and his contemporaries

For the final, and only UK, date of his Vinci Arias tour, virtuoso countertenor Franco Fagioli gave an animated and arresting recital of baroque arias at Birmingham Town Hall on Sunday afternoon with the Italian period instrument group Il pomo d’oro.

The Pilgrim’s Progress, RNCM, Manchester review – a theatrical triumph

★★★★ THE PILGRIM'S PROGRESS, RNCM A Theatrical triumph

Re-imagining Bunyan’s story as a parable of the First World War

The Royal Northern College of Music’s spring opera is a theatrical triumph and musically very, very good. It’s 27 years since they last presented what Vaughan Williams called his "morality" – that was a triumph too, and they made a CD of it which I still have. They may not be issuing a sound recording this time, but as an experience in the theatre, it is even more compelling.

Jack the Ripper: The Women of Whitechapel, English National Opera review - powerful ensemble, wrong subject

★★★ JACK THE RIPPER: THE WOMEN OF WHITECHAPEL, ENGLISH NATIONAL OPERA Six strong sopranos and a promising composer lost in a pointless labyrinth

Six strong sopranos and a still promising composer lost in a pointless labyrinth

If you can’t put a name to any of Jack the Ripper’s victims – and spin it however you please, victims they remain – then you shouldn’t buy the publicity about this new opera "bringing dignity back" to the murdered women in question. Isn’t it time to stop feeding the troll/killer, much as Jacinda Ardern did so swiftly and movingly under different circumstances last week, and let the five eviscerated corpses return to dust in peace? Composer Iain Bell, disturbed by their fates from an early age, sincerely thought otherwise.