Listed: Essential Operas 2015-16

LISTED: ESSENTIAL OPERAS 2015-16 Our classical/opera writers choose 12 highlights of the coming season

Our classical/opera writers choose 12 highlights of the coming season

September is upon us and it’s nearly time for the new season. English National Opera’s Artistic Director John Berry may have left the building but his enterprising legacy lives on in a 2015-16 season that looks on paper as good as any in the past 20 years; what happens after that is anyone's guess. Still, there shouldn’t be too much grief that ENO Music Director Edward Gardner has moved on, since his successor Mark Wigglesworth already has a fine track record with the company.

The Magic Flute, Komische Oper Berlin, Edinburgh Festival Theatre

THE MAGIC FLUTE, KOMISCHE OPER BERLIN, EDINBURGH FESTIVAL THEATRE A magical Flute, but an insufficiently human one

A magical Flute, but an insufficiently human one

In 2007, a tiny British theatre company called 1927 staged their first ever show at the Edinburgh Fringe – the darkly reimagined collection of fairytales and fables Between the Devil and the Deep Blue Sea. Now, almost a decade on, they are back where it all began – not at the Fringe but the Edinburgh International Festival, with their acclaimed Komische Oper production of The Magic Flute.

Entanglement/ That Man Stephen Ward, Presteigne Festival

ENTANGLEMENT / THAT MAN STEPHEN WARD, PRESTEIGNE FESTIVAL An arresting new psychodrama from Charlotte Bray, and Thomas Hyde revival

An arresting new psychodrama from Charlotte Bray, and Thomas Hyde revival

Two dramas of sex, sleaze and death in the postwar London underworld: to outsiders, this double bill of chamber operas by Charlotte Bray and Thomas Hyde might look like an unlikely opening night for the annual Presteigne Festival. That would be to overlook the artistic direction of George Vass, whose commitment to new music has made this short, spirited festival just a couple of valleys over from Hay-on-Wye a chamber-sized successor-in-spirit to Cheltenham.

Prom Chamber Music 6: Jeremy Denk/ Prom 53: Fray, Philharmonia, Salonen

PROM CHAMBER MUSIC 6: JEREMY DENK / PROM 53: FRAY, PHILHARMONIA, SALONEN Blocks of Bartók hit hard, but an orchestrated slab of earlyish Shostakovich falls flat

Blocks of Bartók hit hard, but an orchestrated slab of earlyish Shostakovich falls flat

There were two reasons why I didn’t return to the Albert Hall late on Friday night to hear Andras Schiff play Bach’s Goldberg Variations. The first was that one epic, Mahler’s Sixth in the stunning performance by Andris Nelsons and the Boston Symphony Orchestra, needed properly digesting. The other was that at Easter I’d heard Jeremy Denk play the Goldbergs in Weimar, and I wanted that approach to resonate, too – dynamic, continuous, revelatory, in a very different way from how I know Schiff approaches Bach.

The Last Hotel, Royal Lyceum, Edinburgh

THE LAST HOTEL, ROYAL LYCEUM, EDINBURGH Provocative new opera on assisted suicide from Enda Walsh and Donnacha Dennehy

Provocative new opera on assisted suicide from Enda Walsh and Donnacha Dennehy

Irish playwright Enda Walsh has been a regular presence at recent Edinburgh festivals – or, to be more precise, at the Fringe, with provocative works of rich linguistic lyricism including The Walworth Farce in 2007 and The New Electric Ballroom in 2008. This year marks his first foray into the Edinburgh International Festival, and it’s with a very different work. The Last Hotel, receiving its world premiere there, is Walsh’s first opera libretto, a collaboration with Irish composer Donnacha Dennehy.

HMS Pinafore, National Gilbert & Sullivan Opera Company

HMS PINAFORE, NATIONAL GILBERT & SULLIVAN COMPANY Fresh and funny G&S, with operatic weight

Fresh and funny G&S, with operatic weight

At the beginning of Act Two of John Savournin’s production of HMS Pinafore, the quarterdeck is in darkness. Kevin Greenlaw’s Captain Corcoran steps out of his cabin, downs a brandy stiffener, and launches into his melancholy lament to the moon. Woodwinds echo the ends of sighing phrases as the strings pluck their accompaniment: something about this sounds familiar.

Ravel Double Bill, Glyndebourne

RAVEL DOUBLE BILL, GLYNDEBOURNE Titters for a Spanish farce, but Laurent Pelly's adventures of a naughty boy are heartbreaking

Titters for a Spanish farce, but Laurent Pelly's adventures of a naughty boy are heartbreaking

Ask opera-lovers to name their favourite one-acter and chances are the choice will be L’enfant et les sortilèges. Colette’s typically off-kilter fable of a destructive kid confronted with the objects and animals he’s damaged is set by Maurice Ravel to music of a depth which must have taken even that unshockable author by surprise. Ravel’s earlier L’heure espagnole, on the other hand, is much less likely to be top of the list.

Prom 25: Orfeo, EBS, Gardiner

PROM 25: ORFEO, EBS, GARDINER An operatic paean to the power of music

An operatic paean to the power of music

English choirs and early music ensembles have a bad reputation for stiffness, formality – nothing wrong with the music, just the presentation. But with this dramatic and Italianate Orfeo, John Eliot Gardiner, his English Baroque Soloists and Monteverdi Choir, reminded us just what is possible when you combine English musicianship with a looser, more instinctive presentation.

Bakkhai, Almeida Theatre

BAKKHAI, ALMEIDA THEATRE Ben Whishaw's ambiguous Dionysos and operatic chorus serve superb Euripides translation

Ben Whishaw's ambiguous Dionysos and operatic chorus serve superb Euripides translation

This is the real Greek, bloody-fantastical thing. After the fascinating but flawed attempt to bring Aeschylus’s Oresteia into the 21st century, the Almeida has turned to a more tradition-conscious kind of experiment with Euripides’ last and greatest masterpiece.

Prom 11: Fiddler on the Roof, Grange Park Opera

PROM 11: FIDDLER ON THE ROOF, GRANGE PARK OPERA Bryn Terfel's effortless Tevye hampered by amplification as the shtetl musical hits the Proms

Bryn Terfel's effortless Tevye hampered by amplification as the shtetl musical hits the Proms

Stop miking Bryn Terfel. Stop over-miking musicals; the show voices in a hybrid cast don’t need much. Too much ruined English National Opera’s recent Sweeney Todd, and in this Proms adaptation of Grange Park Opera’s summer crowd-pleaser it sent the voices ricocheting around the Albert Hall, making mush of the words and stridency of the few belt-it-out moments.