Classical Music CDs Round-Up 3
The pick of the latest Classical CDs
Imogen Cooper, QEH
Cooper horrifies in the best possible way
Wolfgang Holzmair, Andreas Haefliger, Wigmore Hall
Wolfgang Holzmair and Andreas Haefliger for all their artistry don't make the pain burn
There’s something beyond detailed and attentive musicianship that’s needed in Schubert’s last, most desolate song-cycle, Winterreise (“Winter’s journey”). It’s a dramatic arc that unites these 24 songs into a journey, the number of breaths in time and miles in distance that elapse from the first poem to the 24th, and bring you a sense of contact with the person undergoing this terrible suffering. Someone who is not Schubert, the composer, or Müller, the poet, but a third person.
LSO/Tilson Thomas, Goerne, Barbican Hall
Viennese night with Schubert, Mahler and Berg shows off the jewels of the LSO
Michael Tilson Thomas’s association with the London Symphony Orchestra runs deep - he was its principal conductor for eight years, and for his latest return to his old band last night the American programmed works that, while they had a Viennese theme, also seemed vividly designed to show off the jewels of this great orchestra, its wonderful wind players.
Tread Softly/ Carnival of the Animals/ Comedy of Change, Rambert Dance, Sadler's Wells
Three of Britain's finest choreographers and great music on a triumphant mixed bill
At its best (ie when it’s not trying to be gimmicky and snare so-called “new audiences”), Rambert is unique in Britain in providing music and dance as theatre. No other company matches it in commitment to this, not even the Royal Ballet, which long ago adopted cloth ears when it comes to new ballet music. Last night at Sadler’s Wells Rambert’s newest triple bill was a fine sample of this kind of evening, a delight to anyone with musical interests, and parading three unbeatable British choreographic talents.
Matthias Goerne, Alexander Schmalcz, Wigmore Hall
Velvet-voiced baritone makes journeys of his own through Schubert's songs
When you go to a Schubert recital, you’re plunged into a whirlpool of emotional ambivalence, heat and chill running together, music and lyrics not always playing the same tune. When Schubert seizes on a poem, it’s not because he’s interested in Mickey-Mousing that poet’s sentiments - on the contrary, he may see a purple passage of words and set it simply, as if deflating it, or he may take a plain statement of action (looking out of a window, say) and fill that phrase with complex music containing a world of dark feeling.