Messiah, Dunedin Consort, Butt, Queen's Hall, Edinburgh - period clarity infused with love

★★★★ MESSIAH, DUNEDIN CONSORT, BUTT, QUEEN'S HALL, EDINBURGH Period clarity infused with love

A seasonal fixture returns to its home two years on

This time last year, the moment I knew things were really bad was when the Dunedin Consort cancelled Messiah. All performances since the summer of 2020 had been online films, but Dunedin cancelled even their online Messiah because it would involve performers travelling from all corners of the UK to do it. Sure enough, a couple of days later, what we then called the “Kent variant” appeared, and the grim winter lockdown began.

Iestyn Davies, Aurora Orchestra, Collon, Kings Place review - Elizabethans and extraterrestrials

★★★★ IESTYN DAVIES, AURORA ORCHESTRA, COLLON, KINGS PLACE Four centuries of London's musical life anchored by a star counter-tenor

Four centuries of London's musical life anchored by a star counter-tenor

Music in London has faced down plagues, puritans, philistines and planners over the four centuries spanned by the Aurora Orchestra’s season-opener at Kings Place on Saturday. This concert in the venue’s “London Unwrapped” strand filled its main hall without distancing for the first time since the capital’s (and the world’s) latest pandemic struck.

Hallenberg, Monteverdi Choir, English Baroque Soloists, Gardiner, BBC Proms review - a vindication of voices

★★★★★ HALLENBERG, MONTEVERDIS, EBS, GARDINER, BBC PROMS A vindication of voices

Choral singing at its finest roars back to the Proms

Choral singers have suffered more than most from erratic and irrational Covid prohibitions while riskier mass pursuits have gone ahead. So when one of the world’s great choirs returned to the Proms with the conductor who has guided them for over half a century, the sense of occasion was palpable. Last night the Monteverdi Choir numbered 30 – not huge by Royal Albert Hall standards – but the joyfully exultant music that they made filled the dome with a boundless grandeur.

Amadigi, Garsington Opera review – geometries of enchantment

★★★★ AMADIGI, GARSINGTON OPERA A bold abstract setting for Handel's gloriously human score

A bold abstract setting for Handel's gloriously human score

In Handel’s operas (as, indeed, elsewhere in art and life) the worst witch may turn out to have the best character. Without the sorceress Melissa, splendidly full of evil ruses yet endowed with a generous measure of tragic pathos, Amadigi di Gaula might freeze into a static amorous stand-off between pasteboard nobles contending with a harsh – then, suddenly, kindly – fate.

Messiah highlights, English National Opera, BBC Two review – short-cut sorrow and redemption

★★★★ MESSIAH , ENO, BBC TWO Fine performances, but why this brutally truncated Handel?

Fine performances: but why this brutally truncated Handel?

Well, it wasn’t quite Messiah, but it was a source of joy. In ENO’s end-of-lockdown staging, BBC Two’s transmission of Handel’s resurrection song delivered a scant 54 minutes of music from the Coliseum on Easter Saturday. In contrast, two ancient Poirot movies, staples of Bank Holiday line-ups roughly since the Pleistocene Era, had hogged fully four hours of the channel’s afternoon schedule.

Iestyn Davies, Arcangelo, Wigmore Hall review - heavenly Handel as the lights dim again

★★★★ IESTYN DAVIES, ARCANGELO, WIGMORE HALL Heavenly Handel as the lights dim again

The star counter-tenor unlocks a box of lesser-known treasures

Just before the doors closed again on live audiences at the Wigmore Hall, Iestyn Davies and members of the Arcangelo ensemble celebrated the private side of a very public composer. The peerless counter-tenor, whose powerfully polished command of phrase and line makes this music feel as natural and necessary as breathing, sang Handel’s nine German-language arias to pious texts by Bartold Heinrich Brockes (who also wrote the words to the “Brockes Passion”).

Ariodante, Royal Opera online review – stylish, but confined

★★★ ARIODANTE, ROYAL OPERA ONLINE Stylish, but confined

Accomplished ensemble tries its best to cross the footlights in livestream-only Handel

“After black and gloomy night, the sun shines all the brighter,” sings hero Ariodante after a life-threatening bout of jealousy nearly scuppers a royal wedding. There’s a snag in Handel’s dramaturgy: all that sunshine in preparation for the nuptials in Act One isn’t really earned.

Susanna, Royal Opera/London Handel Festival review - fitful shinings

★★★ SUSANNA, ROYAL OPERA/LONDON HANDEL FESTIVAL Fitful shinings and a new star

UnHandelian star quality from Masabane Cecilia Rangwanasha saves this endurance test

That virtue can be fascinating and prayers to a just God dramatic have been proved in riveting productions of two late Handel oratorios, Theodora and Jephtha. Whether Susanna can ever be reclaimed for the stage as powerfully seems unlikely, but this showcase for the Royal Opera's Jette Parker Young Artists Programme may just have bungled it.

Acis and Galatea, The Sixteen, Christophers, Cadogan Hall review – pocket-sized pastoral pleasures

★★★★ ACIS AND GALATEA, THE SIXTEEN, CHRISTOPHERS, CADOGAN HALL Pocket-sized pastoral pleasures

Charm and wit as we come away with Handel's nymphs and shepherds

Nymphs and shepherds – go away? In music, as in art or literature, the pastoral fripperies of the Baroque age can feel utterly alien to modern tastes. Those dalliances, seductions and abductions in the Arcadian landscapes of myth may cease to entice in an era that takes sexual violence seriously, while we scorn play-acting toffs who ape the lifestyle of some idealised peasantry, Marie Antoinette-style.