BBC Proms: Aldeburgh World Orchestra, Elder

BBC PROMS: ALDEBURGH WORLD ORCHESTRA, ELDER:  A group of young musicians challenge their youthful contemporaries at the Olympics

An orchestra of young musicians challenge their youthful contemporaries at the Olympics

Formed especially for the London 2012 Festival, the Aldeburgh World Orchestra does what it says on the tin: bringing together talented young musicians from across the world in a single youth orchestra. Under the direction of Mark Elder, musicians from 35 countries, including Jordan, Ukraine, Malaysia and Uzbekistan amongst others, joined together to perform a mixed programme of music from Mahler, Britten and Stravinsky, as well as the world premiere of Charlotte Bray’s At The Speed of Stillness.

London Symphony Orchestra, Tilson Thomas, Barbican Hall

The American conductor is as subtle as ever in Mahler's Titan symphony

Right, notebooks out everyone. Michael Tilson Thomas began this Berg/Mahler double-header with a lengthy analysis of what we were about to hear in the former’s Chamber Concerto. Whether it was informative or not (and it was), it was a bit of a spoiler. It was nice to know exactly which themes are attributed to which dedicatee, but you couldn’t help but feel the surprises in the work have been somewhat spiked by this little lecture. Still, selected LSO folk and the effective duo of Yefim Bronfman on piano and Gil Shaham on violin were on hand to try and surprise us anyway.

Mahler Eighth, Mariinsky Orchestra/Gergiev, Wales Millennium Centre

Russian and Welsh forces brought together in a thrilling if shorthanded Symphony of a Thousand

Gergiev’s second Cardiff concert was thematically linked to his first. Mahler’s Eighth Symphony shares with Parsifal a certain kind of solipsistic religiosity that talks about God in the way some people talk about their ancestors. We don’t really need them any more, but they make us feel important. One approaches both works with mixed feelings (some, with actual distaste). But in the end one usually has to admit: art conquers, and God is not (altogether) mocked.

Kaufmann, CBSO, Nelsons, Symphony Hall, Birmingham

Sultry Strauss from the German tenor and salty Debussy from the Latvian

There was a lovely narrative to last night's CBSO concert. The muggy oppressiveness of Britten's Four Sea Interludes (and Passacaglia) appeared somehow explained by Mahler's Kindertotenlieder, then dissolved by the love letters that were the Strauss songs and then finally set free - psychologically and orchestrally - in Debussy's La Mer. Parallel to this, the great German tenor Jonas Kaufmann was being washed out to sea; his Mahler and Strauss songs were being lapped at from both directions by Debussy and Britten's portraits of the salty waters. 

New York Philharmonic, Gilbert, Barbican

NEW YORK PHILHARMONIC, GILBERT: A safe Mahler Nine from the new chief conductor

A safe Mahler Nine from the new chief conductor

The problem with being the closest major European capital to the United States is that touring American orchestras always visit us first or last. When they hit London, they're exhausted. This was very noticeable the first time the New York Philharmonic dropped by with their new chief conductor Alan Gilbert a few years back. They were a pale and baggy-eyed lot compared to the alert team I'd seen and heard just a few months before in New York. 

The Dream/ Song of the Earth, Royal Ballet

THE DREAM/SONG OF THE EARTH: Alina Cojocaru and Tamara Rojo dazzle in two British masterpieces

Alina Cojocaru and Tamara Rojo dazzle in two British masterpieces

Oberon in Frederick Ashton’s The Dream was the hurdle at which the ferociously promising young Sergei Polunin refused when he quit the Royal Ballet last week, and whether it was the deceptive complexity and difficulty of it that caused his sudden exit, last night’s opening gave his replacement, the brilliant Steven McRae, such a run for his money that it wouldn’t be surprising if the role had indeed left Polunin in a blue funk.

2011: Schoolroom Fairies and a Cross-Dressing Mezzo

DAVID NICE'S 2011: More standout performances than total works of musical art but two British school fantasies excel

More standout performances than total works of art on the music scene, but two British school fantasies excel

Two precisely imagined dream-visions bookend a cornucopia on the musical front. I’ll start with the deadly but save the apparently frivolous for the top slot. Christopher Alden’s pitiless exiling of Britten’s A Midsummer Night’s Dream from Elizabethan wood to 1960s school block was to opera what Lars von Trier’s Melancholia was to film: audience-sundering, often alienating, sometimes enticing, but very much its own consistent world. Its splendid cast and conductor Leo Hussain worked as one to enhance the paradoxes of its terrible beauty.

DVDs for Christmas: Classical

CLASSICAL DVDS FOR CHRISTMAS: A broad sweep of the year's most memorable releases

A broad sweep of the year's most memorable releases

Unlike audio recordings, classical DVDs can only be properly taken in if you're sitting down for 80 minutes, ideally in the same seat. So they have to be pretty special to warrant repeated viewings. So much depends on the production and direction; how to make interesting the sight of a middle-aged bloke waving a stick at a sea of other middle-aged blokes, many of them looking as if they'd rather be somewhere else. Here's a selection of things which have lodged in my conciousness over the past year, including a couple of seasonal discs.

Anne Schwanewilms, Charles Spencer, Wigmore Hall

Humour and metaphysics in this bewitching soprano's consummate song recital

Now that Margaret Price is no more and Kiri's well past her heyday, whose is the most limpid soprano of them all? "The beautiful voice" was a label slapped by PR on Renée Fleming, but that fitfully engaging diva is all curdled artifice alongside Anne Schwanewilms, the German soprano who shines in Strauss and should be an example to any singer for ease, charm and what to do with the hands in the exposed light of song recital.