The Apostles, BBCSO, Davis, Barbican

THE APOSTLES, BBCSO, DAVIS, BARBICAN Sir Andrew finds the soul of Elgar's visionary oratorio

Sir Andrew Davis finds the soul of Elgar's visionary oratorio

Sir Adrian Boult laid the foundations for its revival, more recently Sir Mark Elder found astonishing illumination within it, and now a third knight of the realm - Sir Andrew Davis (the latest recipient of the Elgar Medal) - chivalrously stamps his authority on it and brings it in from the cold.

theartsdesk Q&A: Soprano Nicole Cabell

Q&A WITH SOPRANO NICOLE CABELL The outstanding American singer on winning Cardiff, crying in performance and Kate Bush

The outstanding American singer on winning Cardiff, crying in performance and Kate Bush

Last year a DVD appeared featuring the 15 winning performances from the start of the BBC Cardiff Singer of the World Competition up to 2011. I watched them all, skimming if any seemed a notch below par but staying with most. You could see the star quality and the promise in many who have since become great artists, including Karita Mattila, Anja Harteros and Ekaterina Shcherbachenko.

Donose, Philharmonia, Gardner, RFH

DONOSE, PHILHARMONIA, GARDNER Only the visionary gleam is lacking in a well-sculpted Elgar First Symphony

Only the visionary gleam is lacking in a well-sculpted Elgar First Symphony

Arise, Sir Edward – Gardner, not Elgar, whose First Symphony the former conducted last night. Well, maybe a knighthood’s too premature; although the daft honours system has rewarded others in the operatic world for less, and Gardner has already served two brilliant terms at Glyndebourne Touring Opera and ENO, there was just one aspect of the symphony that he didn’t seem quite to get last night.

Gerstein, LPO, Petrenko, RFH

A Russian with Elgarian sympathies is slow to kindle in a great symphony

Vasily Petrenko used his baton like a piratical rapier to galvanise the London Philharmonic violins in their flourishes of derring-do at the start of Berlioz’s Overture Le Corsaire. And the brilliance was in the quicksilver contrasts, the lightness and wit of inflection which lent a piquancy to the panache of this great concert opener. The arrival of the main theme - tantalisingly delayed - was almost balletic in its vivacity and even the final trumpet-led assault suggested a Byronic hero as French as he was feral.

Stott, Orchestra of Opera North, Farnes, Leeds Town Hall

STOTT, ORCHESTRA OF OPERA NORTH, FARNES, LEEDS TOWN HALL Dazzling early Britten paired with incandescent, urgent Elgar

Dazzling early Britten paired with incandescent, urgent Elgar

When you're young, you think that liking Elgar is a habit you'll grow into later in life, like buying a set of golf clubs or following The Archers in detail. As I shuffle into middle age, I find that I'm beginning to love this music more and more. I've given up making excuses to younger, hipper friends. Richard Farnes' intense account of Elgar's disconcerting Second Symphony was a great performance, one in which intense dynamism served to accentuate the score's lingering, fin de siècle nostalgia.

Hough, BBC Philharmonic, Mena, Bridgewater Hall, Manchester

HOUGH, BBC PHILHARMONIC, MENA, BRIDGEWATER HALL, MANCHESTER The Mancunian Way season opens with Hough and Brahms, plus a rarity from Anthony Burgess

The Mancunian Way season opens with Hough and Brahms, plus a rarity from Anthony Burgess

They did it, and continue to do it, their way. Under the self-confident title of The Mancunian Way, the BBC Philharmonic’s new season aims to celebrate the story of music-making in the city through works, composers and performers with special links to Manchester. There is much to celebrate, not least nowadays the spirit of collaboration between the musical strongholds in the city, where it is entirely possible to carve out a total career from childhood to professional fulfilment.

Milton Court Opening, GSMD

Large forces overwhelm a modest new hall, but Guildhall students and graduates dazzle

Night life in the Square Mile, at least from the perspective of my evening routes around the Barbican, is dominated by booze and sportiness. The way to last Thursday’s concert was blocked by a Bloomberg relay marathon, and cycling through the tunnel towards Milton Court yesterday evening, I encountered the bizarre spectacle of carnival-style trucks pedalled by a dozen drinkers apiece, sitting at a central "bar" and already well oiled.

Prom 52: Batiashvili, BBC Symphony Orchestra, Oramo

Elgar and Sibelius trump a BBC commission and a hazily pleasant slice of Celtic twilight

Concert programmes are designed to make the mind flexible with constant contrasts. More often, though, the great is the enemy of the good-ish. Last night an Elgar masterpiece was always going to overshadow its second-half predecessor, a hazily pleasant piece for strings and – novelty value – six harps by the colleague Elgar called “dear old Gran”, candidate for this Proms season's resuscitation attempt Granville Bantock. And earlier, Sibelius bopped a BBC commission on the head with supernatural noises that could have been conjured yesterday.

Prom 39: Khan, BBC National Orchestra of Wales, Atherton

Eastern promise is never quite fulfilled in a new fusion concerto for sitar and orchestra

The fascination of the East has been a constant in classical music’s history, from the jangling sounds of the Janissary bands to Mozart’s Seraglio, Sheherazade’s dreamy tales to Britten’s seductive gamelan. Last night’s Prom gave the East a chance to answer back, setting Nishat Khan’s new Sitar Concerto in dialogue with Vaughan Williams’s London Symphony – a musical portrait of a landscape rather closer to home.