Classical CDs Weekly: Beethoven, Liszt, Sibelius

Osmo Vänskä's accounts of Sibelius's published symphonies are regarded by many as definitive

Symphonic box sets from Czech and Finnish bands, and Rubinstein's Liszt

This week’s reviews include a generous Liszt anthology played by one of the 20th century’s most fondly remembered pianists. There’s a reissued box of Beethoven symphonies performed on modern instruments by one of the classiest European orchestras. Heading further north, we've a repackaged set of Sibelius symphonies with some essential extras.

 

London Schools Symphony Orchestra, Segerstam, Barbican Hall

Charismatic Finn raises the game of a fine youth orchestra in deep-vein Britten

With regional youth orchestras dropping from a thousand short-sighted, wholesale cuts - flagship Leicestershire the latest under threat - it should be enough just to celebrate 60 seasons of the LSSO, safe for now under the City of London's munificent wing. But last night was more than just another fun concert. No one ought to miss any appearance of the, ahem, enormously charismatic Leif Segerstam, composer of 244 symphonies to date and master orchestral trainer, who always goes for depth of sound rather than surface glitter.

Bryant, BBC Symphony Orchestra, Robertson, Barbican Hall

David Robertson: Urgent, sensuous Sibelius

Jungly new music for violin and orchestra catches the ear, but it's Sibelius who sweeps the board

Never envy a relatively new voice in music his or her place in a concert shared with Sibelius. Invariably the economical Finnish master will triumph with his ideas and how he streams them in a forward-moving adventure. You sit staring at all the percussion Sibelius never needs, and wonder whether the newcomer will engage it more imaginatively than most of his peers. Which fortunately turned out to be the case with Detlev Glanert's 15-year-old Music for Violin and Orchestra, fearlessly taken on by one of the BBC Symphony Orchestra's two world-class leaders, Stephen Bryant. But given Principal Guest Conductor David Robertson's urgent, sensuous way with Sibelius, the German's flickering homage to the Orpheus of Rilke's sonnets still hovered in the shadows.

BBC National Orchestra of Wales, St David's Hall, Cardiff

Piero di Cosimo: 'The Fight Between the Lapiths and the Centaurs'

Centaurs with brains as well as brawn attract Simon Holt in new concerto

How much do you know about centaurs? Probably you know they are horses below the withers, human above. But did you know they were heavy drinkers who once got out of hand at the wedding of the King of the Lapiths, tried to rape the bride and got beaten up for their pains?

Tetzlaff Quartet, Queen Elizabeth Hall

Strange meeting: Viola-player Hanna Weinmeister, violinists Elisabeth Kufferath and Christian Tetzlaff, and cellist Tanja Tetzlaff

Strange refinement, culminating in an overshadowed Sibelius masterpiece

Their oaky, cultured and selectively scary-wild playing seemed to cast long autumn shadows over a sparse but intent audience. This is the kind of rare programme top violinist Christian Tetzlaff, his cellist sister Tanja and friends like to work on when they get time to play together. There was Haydn for starters, but not the kind of jolly curtainraiser we're usually given; Dvořák, but not the blithe American; and Sibelius's Voces Intimae, the only great quartet of the 20th century yet to be widely acclaimed as such, with strange, authentic ideas in every bar and a slow movement to match any in Beethoven's late masterpieces.

Grimaud, Philharmonia, Salonen, Royal Festival Hall

From foursquare heroism in Beethoven to a dazzlingly original epic by Sibelius

Esa-Pekka Salonen and his dauntless band of Philharmonia players have been wrestling with heroes. After a celebration of Wagner's Tristan, the legend-making shifted further north last night. Here was Sibelius first as the plain-singing, well-loved bard of Finnish endurance and then as the startlingly original creator of a musical alter ego in the shape of mythical adventurer Lemminkäinen. Salonen's edge-of-seat interpretation made two things startlingly clear: that the four movements of the misnamed Lemminkäinen Suite can constitute as radical a symphony as any of Sibelius's numbered seven, and that this surging orchestral tidal wave is as iconoclastic a work in its own rugged way as Wagner's opera.

Shaham, BBC Symphony Orchestra, Robertson, Royal Albert Hall

Gil Shaham: Big-hearted and inquisitive playing

Turnage turns 50 while Shaham wows us with Barber

When Mark-Anthony Turnage presents a piece called Hammered Out, that’s pretty much what you expect to hear. Prior to starting work on this co-commission between BBC Radio 3 and the Los Angeles Philharmonic, Turnage was quoted as saying, “I don’t want to write an old man’s piece.” The trouble is that this 15-minute juggernaut for large orchestra sounds like an elder statesman – ie the symphony orchestra – masquerading as a mover and shaker: or to be brutally frank, an old swinger in urgent need of a hip replacement. As a seasoned Turnage fan, I hesitate to say that there’s more than a hint of clapped-out about Hammered Out.

theartsdesk in Helsinki: Sunflowers By the Frozen Baltic

Education, star players and a modest sense of national pride in Finland's amiable capital

Venezuela's joyful musical education programme known as El Sistema is the phenomenon of the age, the success story that many western countries now seek to replicate. And that's great. But Britain, for a start, might re-engage its own back-to-basics in music quicker by looking closer to home and seeing how Finland does it. In a small population, every child has free access to an instrument until secondary school.