The Return of Ulysses, Royal Opera, Roundhouse review - musical drama trumps dodgy stagecraft

★★★★ THE RETURN OF ULYSSES, ROYAL OPERA, ROUNDHOUSE Monteverdi magic from peerless performers, triumphing over a messy production

Monteverdi magic from peerless performers, triumphing over a messy production

The power of music solves every problem, at least when as bewitchingly performed as it was here. With the great mezzo Christine Rice voiceless for at least a night, and rising star Caitlin Hulcup singing for her from the midst of the instruments in the pit right at the centre of the Roundhouse, how could faithful Penelope's final acceptance of her long-lost husband Ulysses (Roderick Williams) achieve transcendence?

Breaking the Rules, LSO St Luke's review – music and murder with Gesualdo

★★★★ BREAKING THE RULES, LSO ST LUKE'S Music and murder with Gesualdo

Clare Norburn's concert drama receives a welcome London premiere

The “concert drama” is on the up, offering audiences a mingled-genre means to experience music and its context simultaneously. The author and singer Clare Norburn has an absolute peach of a story to tell in the "imagined testimony of Carlo Gesualdo, composer and murderer," the legendary musician who knifed to death his wife and her lover upon catching them in flagrante.

The Miniaturist, BBC One review - a lovely supernatural soap

★★★★ THE MINIATURIST, BBC ONE Jessie Burton's novel is ravishingly visualised with 21st century highlights

Jessie Burton's novel is ravishingly visualised with 21st century highlights

Simon Schama called the Netherlands’ century of success an "embarrassment of riches". The thrust of Jessie Burton’s lavishly hyped debut novel The Miniaturist is that the Dutch felt guilty about their good fortune, and denied themselves the right to enjoy sugar, spice, and all things nice. The money went on surface things, on finery and furniture.

Mother Courage, Southwark Playhouse review - this production is not one for our times

★★ MOTHER COURAGE, SOUTHWARK PLAYHOUSE A production not for our times

Uninspired treatment of Brecht's 1939 antiwar tract

One of the questions that can be asked of Brecht is whether for a modern audience his Verfremdungseffekt — or alienation effect — still works as intended, provoking genuine reflections on justice by distancing audiences from emotional entanglement with the characters. At a time when verbatim and community theatre is accomplishing just that with exactitude and force, it appears that inducing audiences to think morally is most effective when delivered in unexpected ways.

Gunpowder, BBC One review – death, horror, treason and a hint of farce

★★★★ GUNPOWDER, BBC ONE Dark and Gothicky treatment of the plot to blow up Parliament 

Dark and Gothicky treatment of the plot to blow up Parliament

Much is being made of the fact that Kit Harington is not only playing the Gunpowder Plot mastermind Robert Catesby, but is genuinely descended from him (and his middle name is Catesby). However, despite its factual underpinnings and screenwriter Ronan Bennett’s flowery 17th-century dialogue, Gunpowder is drama in a historical vein, rather than nailed-down fact.

The Encounter, National Portrait Gallery review - dazzlingly evocative drawings

An unexpected glimpse inside the artists' studios of the past

As a line flows or falters, registering each slight change in pressure, pause, or occasional reworking, it seems to offer a glimpse into the mind of the artist at work. The line is the instrument of the artist’s eye, the often unpolished, provisional nature of a drawing offering a spark and freshness that tends to gradually lessen as a composition is rethought and worked up in paint.

Queen Anne, Theatre Royal Haymarket review - slow, long and dull

★★ QUEEN ANNE, THEATRE ROYAL HAYMARKET Helen Edmundson's new history play gets bogged down in period detail

Helen Edmundson's new history play gets bogged down in period detail

How well do you know your British history? Fancy explaining the causes and origins of the Glorious Revolution or listing the members of the Grand Alliance? What about the terms of the 1701 Act of Settlement or the Occasional Confirmity Bill of 1702? I ask not because Helen Edmundson’s Queen Anne will require you to know any of this, but rather precisely because it won’t.

The Tempest, Barbican Theatre review - sound and fury at the expense of sense

★★★ THE TEMPEST, BARBICAN THEATRE Tech-powered RSC production suffers from transfer to proscenium stage

The RSC's tech-powered production of Shakespeare's island play suffers badly after transfer from thrust to proscenium

Can The Tempest open on stage without a tempest – of crashing, shrieking and torment – and thus without what can become five minutes-plus of inaudibility? In Gregory Doran’s 2016 Stratford production for the RSC, revived at the Barbican Theatre, the answer is, as so often, no. Joe Shire, Darren Raymond and Caleb Frederick, playing mariners, have lines to deliver but against giant-wave effects and the supersonic demolition of a ship, they might as well stay mute.