Fleming, BBCSO, Oramo, Barbican

RENÉE FLEMING, BARBICAN Star soprano shines in adventurous new works

Star soprano shines in adventurous new works

Renée Fleming recently announced her imminent retirement from the opera stage. But she has no plans to stop performing, and will instead devote her time to recitals and concerts. Yesterday’s excellent performance with the BBC Symphony Orchestra bodes well for her new career focus. And she’s not one to rest on her laurels, here giving UK premieres of two new works written for her voice, ever the adventurous artist, always playing to her strengths.

The Return, Circa, Barbican

THE RETURN, CIRCA, BARBICAN Exile-themed circus show is rather too serious

Exile-themed circus show is rather too serious

If you thought circus acrobats and Shostakovich were a daring combination, try circus acrobats and Monteverdi. While the spiky harmonies and vivd dynamics of 20th-century Russian string quartets sit pretty nicely with circus show-offery, surely Baroque music, with its steady continuo basses, its measured rise and fall, is a world away from tumbling tricks and strongman stunts?

Roméo et Juliette, BBCSO, Davis, Barbican

ROMEO ET JULIETTE, BBCSO, DAVIS, BARBICAN Berlioz's fantastical invention superbly realised by Sir Andrew and company

Berlioz's fantastical invention superbly realised by Sir Andrew and company

It was another Davis, the late Colin rather than the very alive Andrew, who used to be master of Berlioz's phenomenally inventive opera for orchestra with its novel explanatory prologue and epilogue. I like to think he'd have been looking down fascinated by last night's very different miracle of pace, clarity and ideal blend of instrumental and vocal song.

Kavakos, Bullock, LSO, Rattle, Barbican

KAVAKOS, BULLOCK, LSO, RATTLE, BARBICAN Unabashed freedom and sensuality in an all-French affair

Unabashed freedom and sensuality in an all-French affair

If the London Symphony Orchestra sounded simply magnificent in this programme of 20th century French music, it was their restraint that caught the ear rather than the demonstration of an orchestral engine at full throttle for which they are justly renowned. Tonal refinement and fastidious attention to detail were the key signatures of the evening, as they had been for Debussy's Pelléas et Melisande at the weekend.

Watkins, BBCSO, Bychkov, Barbican

WATKINS, BBCSO, BYCHKOV, BARBICAN An impressive programme, offering elegant Haydn and dynamic Brahms

An impressive programme, offering elegant Haydn and dynamic Brahms

We don’t often hear Semyon Bychkov in the core Austro-German repertoire. That’s a great shame, because the qualities that make his Russian music performances so special are just as valuable here: the dynamism and immediacy, the supple but propulsive phrasing, and, above all, the firm, guiding hand, exerting control without imposing restraint.

Pelléas et Mélisande, LSO, Rattle, Barbican

A stripped-back staging marks a starry return for Rattle and Sellars

Debussy’s Pelléas et Mélisande is a drama played out in shadow. Shine too bright, too unyielding a directorial light on it, and the delicate dramatic fabric – all unspokens and unspeakables – frays into air. Just over a year ago, director David Edwards and the Philharmonia Orchestra gave us a semi-staging of exquisitely allusive simplicity, leaving the music to fill the gaps between symbol and emotion.

Opinion: The new London hall - 10 Questions we need to ask

OPINION: THE NEW LONDON HALL – 10 QUESTIONS WE NEED TO ASK What a new concert venue for London should be – and what it must avoid

What a new concert venue for London should be – and what it must avoid

So the feasibility study for the new concert hall – The Centre for Music – has finally surfaced, a little later than planned. It’s being greeted, generally speaking, as if it’s to be the next London Olympics. “A global beacon,” declares the Evening Standard... Nicholas Hytner (he who said that building the Southbank Centre extension would spoil the view from his National Theatre) compares it to Tate Modern, which he says enlarged audiences for other visual arts rather than taking them away. This should, he says, be “a Tate Modern for music”.

Murray, National Youth Orchestra of Great Britain, Collon, Leeds Town Hall

MURRAY, NATIONAL YOUTH ORCHESTRA OF GB, COLLON, LEEDS TOWN HALL Youthful conductor meets vast teenage orchestra

Youthful conductor meets vast teenage orchestra

The National Youth Orchestra of Great Britain’s standard of playing is consistently impressive, so much so that it’s easy to forget that the ensemble is effectively reconstituted from scratch each autumn. Last night’s fresh incarnation, deftly conducted by Nicholas Collon, sounded as if they’d been playing together for decades, though without any sense of complacency which that might bring. When you’ve 163 teenagers squeezed onto a stage, the worry is that the details will get lost in a blurry soup of sound. But no; this account of Prokofiev’s Fifth Symphony was immaculate.

Christmas Oratorio, AAM, Egarr, Barbican

CHRISTMAS ORATORIO, ACADEMY OF ANCIENT MUSIC, BARBICAN Only one vocal star shines over Bach's Bethlehem, but it's good to hear all six cantatas

Only one vocal star shines over Bach's Bethlehem, but it's good to hear all six cantatas

Relatively recent tweaks to the abundant London concert scene have resulted in top-end events right up to Christmas. We have in part to thank the seasonal festival at St John’s Smith Square, postponing the Orchestra of the Age of Enlightenment’s holidays, putting them together with superb soloists and choirs, and serving up major Handel and Bach. One snag: their Christmas Oratorio when I last went to hear it turned out to be only four cantatas out of the sequence of six.

Pires, LSO, Harding, Barbican

Bruckner's completed Ninth Symphony: well worth the wait

Imagine knowing Hamlet as a four-act play, or The Ambassadors without its bottom third. Imagine  Mozart’s Requiem as a torso that halts eight bars into the Lacrymosa, or Mahler’s Tenth as the lone Adagio (as, indeed it too often appears). We might admire them all the more for what we ached to feel whole as their creators intended.