Bob Dylan, Royal Albert Hall review - cracked ritual from rock elder

★★★ BOB DYLAN, ROYAL ALBERT HALL Cracked ritual from rock elder

A glorious mixture of mask and authenticity

Will Bob Dylan’s Never Ending Tour ever come to an end? Two years on from the last UK tour, he’s returned, with substantially the same band, once again mostly featuring material from his brilliant album Rough and Rowdy Ways (2020). He’s a little less steady on his feet, but remains as present as ever, clearly enjoying being on stage and contact with an audience that welcomes him with love as well as uncritical adulation.

Prom 71, Seong-Jin Cho review - refined Romantic journeys

★★★ PROM 71, SEONG-JIN CHO Refined journeys in Ravel and Liszr

Taste and grace from the Korean prize-winner in Ravel and Liszt

Out of emergencies may come revelations. Sir András Schiff has broken his leg, and we wish him a super-speedy recovery. At the Proms, his promised Art of Fugue will have to wait. Korean pianist Seong-Jin Cho, a past winner of the Chopin Prize, stepped in yesterday with a late-night recital programme that at first glance could hardly have looked more alien to the austere grandeur of Bach’s contrapuntal epic.

Proms 63-65, Choral Day review - from Harris to Handel/Mozart via Alabama, with love

★★★★★ PROMS 63-65, CHORAL DAY From Harris to Handel/Mozart via Alabama, with love

British and American beauties crowned by a cornucopial 'Messiah'

The Proms’ Indian summer of big visiting orchestras is over – and what a parade it’s been – but renewal hit on the last Saturday before the Last Night with a rainbow of choral concerts, from the 26 voices of The Sixteen (yes, counter-intuitive, I know) and the 33 of the Jason Max Ferdinand Singers to 250 from six choirs as crisp as a small ensemble under John Butt in a Messiah with a difference.

Prom 62, Mahler's Sixth Symphony, Bavarian RSO, Rattle review - sound over momentum

★★★ PROM 62, MAHLER 6, BAVARIAN RSO, RATTLE Sound over momentum

Near-perfect playing, but something missing in the overall drama

Mahler’s Sixth is one of those apocalyptic megaliths that shouldn’t be approached too often by audiences or conductors. It’s been a constant in Simon Rattle’s treasury since 1989, when he first recorded it with his City of Birmingham Symphony Orchestra (they performed it together at the Proms in 1995) to now, when the second of the Bavarian Radio Symphony Orchestra concerts followed a recording. Sophisticated, yes, but where was the feral intensity?

Prom 61, Bavarian Radio Symphony Orchestra, Rattle review - Bruckner without tears

★★★★★ PROM 61, BAVARIAN RSO, RATTLE Bruckner without tears

A lithe, smooth journey around a craggy masterpiece

Hot on the glittering heels of the Berlin Philharmonic and Kirill Petrenko, Sir Simon Rattle brought another stellar German outfit to the Proms, bearing the gift of a Bruckner symphony in the composer’s 200th birthday year. With his (relatively) new team at the Bavarian Radio Symphony Orchestra, Rattle served a polished, sophisticated and superbly played Fourth.

Prom 58, Orchestre de Paris, Mäkelä review - risky reinvention pays off in part

★★★★ PROM 58, ORCHESTRE DE PARIS, MAKELA Risky reinvention pays off in part

Berlioz fares better than Stravinsky in a master conductor’s fresh takes

Never mind the Last Night, it’s always the preceding Proms weeks which lead us through different rooms of a dream palace as visiting orchestras succeed one another. This year has taken on an almost hallucinatory quality as three great conductors – Jakub Hrůša, Kirill Petrenko and Klaus Mäkelä – appeared in close succession. If the Orchestre de Paris isn’t quite on the level with the Czech or Berlin Philharmonics, its love-in with its chief conductor was still electrfying at times.

Prom 55, Ólafsson, Berlin Philharmonic, Petrenko review - stealth and sweep from the greatest

Smetana’s national epic has abundant operatic drama and orchestral beauties

Is it because the British are wary of national sentiment from a genius that this performance of Má vlast (My Homeland) is the only major London offering in Smetana’s 200th anniversary year? Supple movement, emotional range and unerring climaxes from Kirill Petrenko and his Berlin Phllharmonic might encourage more interest in great operas Libuše and Dalibor (which Jakub Hrůša hopes for in his Royal Opera tenure).

Prom 54, Ma, Ax, Kavakos review - exquisite display of humility and communication

Three musicians at the top of their game tease out the subtleties of the repertoire

In their lyrical, often intensely moving afternoon concert at the Proms, Yo-Yo Ma, Emanuel Ax and Leonidas Kavakos demonstrated such seamless communication that at points it was tempting to imagine that even their heartbeats were in sync. It’s an obvious statement to say that brilliant music making is as much about listening as playing, yet these three musicians took it to another level, deftly negotiating the Brahms and Beethoven with the elegance of bats finding their way by echolocation.

Prom 52, Carmen, Glyndebourne Festival review - fine-tuning a masterpiece

★★★★★ PROM 52, CARMEN, GLYNDEBOURNE No loss of vivid focus as the Albert Hall becomes Bar Lillas Pastia

No loss of vivid focus as the Albert Hall becomes Bar Lillas Pastia

If you ever doubted that Bizet’s Carmen, 150 years young next year, is one of the greatest operas of all time, this performance would have changed your mind. Among the four principals only Rihab Chaieb’s utterly convincing, consistent protagonist was the same as on first night 22 performances ago, and as ringleader we had the vivacious conductor of the second run, Anja Bihlmaier.

Prom 50, Fujita, Czech Philharmonic, Hrůša review - revelations where least expected

★★★★ PROM 50, FUJITA, CZECH PHILHARMONIC, HRUSA Revelations where least expected

Fresh-faced, unpredictable Dvořák, majestic if not entirely visceral Janáček

Namedrop first: it was Charles Mackerras who introduced me to the music of Vítězslava Kaprálová, lending me a CD with her Military Sinfonietta leading the way. It piqued interest, but more as a sense of promise cut short: this abundantly gifted young woman, first female conductor of the Czech Philiharmonic at the age of 22 when she premiered the work, died three years later before fulfilling her genius.