Prom 17, Murray, BBC NOW, Brabbyns review – pastoral vistas, with dark shadows
Hubert Parry celebrated as symphonist, choral composer and teacher
Two of the major themes in this year’s Proms season are the hundredth anniversaries of the death of Hubert Parry and the end of the First World War. This programme brought those two ideas together, with two works by Parry himself, along with pieces influenced by the war and written in its aftermath by Parry’s pupils Holst and Vaughan Williams.
Prom 16, Elder, Hallé – reason yoked to magic on one enchanted evening
Manchester's finest bring control as well as passion to spellbinding scores
Beguiling echoes, patterns and symmetries accompanied the Hallé on this Proms journey through the enchanted forests of orchestral sound.
Prom 15, Lewis, BBC Philharmonic, Gernon - a masterful Emperor took the musical laurels
A thoughtful programme on the page didn't quite come into focus in performance
There’s a particular quality to light seen from shadow. Think of the surface of the water glimpsed, hazy and haloed, as you swim upwards after a deep dive, or the smudged edges of city lights seen from a night flight. This concert by Ben Gernon and the BBC Philharmonic was an exercise in adjusted perspective.
Prom 12, Weilerstein, BBCSO, Canellakis review - energetic 20th century classics
American cellist and conductor combine effectively in concerto but new work disappoints
Shostakovich’s First Cello Concerto combines the composer’s usual angst and nerviness with a sardonic humour, right from the opening bars, where the cello and orchestra seem to be playing in contradictory keys. At last night’s Prom, cellist Alisa Weilerstein played the opening motto not as a challenge, but as the continuation of a conversation already in progress. It was also very fast, which issued a different kind of challenge to the orchestra.
Proms at...Roundhouse / Proms 9 & 11 review - rituals from Messiaen to Mahler
Out-of-sync Beethoven 9 the only blip on a journey from the trenches to the heavens
Once the Proms season is under way, you soon regret dissing the prospectus.
Prom 5, Pelléas et Mélisande, Glyndebourne review - for the ears, not the eyes
Semi-staged Debussy is visually confused, musically mostly excellent
What a fabulous score Pelléas et Mélisande is, and what a joy to be able to hear it in a concert performance without the distraction of some over-sophisticated director’s self-communings. Well, if only.
Prom 4, Simpson, BBCPO, Mena review - terrific Lindberg, brooding Shostakovich
High-spirited clarinet concerto set against dark symphonic drama
The fourth Prom of this season featured only two contrasting pieces, pitching the unabashed joyfulness and good humour of Lindberg’s Clarinet Concerto against the angst and defiance of Shostakovich’s “Leningrad” Symphony. It was the former that left the greater impression.
Prom 3, BBC Young Musician at 40 review - multi-layered birthday cake
Fabulous foursomes, five Gershwinistas and tziganery offer three-quarters perfection
How do you go about co-ordinating a spectacular like this, the first ever BBC Young Musicians' Prom? With 23 brilliant soloists from clarinettist Michael Collins, not even the winner of the first event 40 years ago, to 16-year-old Lauren Zhang, who stunned us all with her fleet interpretation of Prokofiev's monster Second Piano Concerto this year, commissions or reworkings dealing with batches were the best idea. And all of them worked superbly.
Prom 1, BBCSO, Oramo review – spectacular First Night of the Proms
Dynamic but sensitive Holst, multi-media show high on spectacle but low on substance
The First Night of the Proms is always a tricky one to programme, bringing together themes of the season, perhaps a new work and, most importantly, a grand finale. This year’s Prom No. 1 ticked all the boxes, and without feeling like pick-n-mix.