Prom 58: Salome, Deutsche Oper Berlin, Runnicles

PROM 58: SALOME, DEUTSCHE OPER BERLIN Nina Stemme stuns in a giddying account of Strauss's incredible score

Nina Stemme stuns in a giddying account of Strauss's incredible score

So here’s where I join the ranks of Old Opera Bores by declaring this Salome, Nina Stemme, the best I’ve seen since Hildegard Behrens in 1978, and this Salome as in Richard Strauss’s Wilde opera from Donald Runnicles and his Deutsche Oper Berlin ensemble categorically the most near-perfect. It’s also the first time I’ve had a group of very loud, rude people behind me shouting “sit down” when I stood at the end (and John the Baptist’s God knows I don’t do that often).

Prom 53: Brahms Symphonies, Budapest Festival Orchestra, Fischer

PROM 53: BRAHMS SYMPHONIES, BUDAPEST FESTIVAL ORCHESTRA, FISCHER Exceptional control and finesse allow Brahms’s masterpieces to shine supreme

Exceptional control and finesse allow Brahms’s masterpieces to shine supreme

About 10 minutes into the Brahms Third Symphony I wanted to check a name in the Budapest Festival Orchestra’s programme. I dared to turn a page. Bad idea. Such preternatural stillness had settled over the sold-out Royal Albert Hall that the gesture could probably have been spotted from the balcony. A motionless, virtually breathless audience is a rarity even at the Proms, where quality of listening is venerated; still, to hold around 6000 people quite so rapt with attention is an extraordinary skill in orchestra and conductor.

Prom 52: Budapest Festival Orchestra, Fischer

PROM 52: BUDAPEST FESTIVAL ORCHESTRA, FISCHER Whole string sections with the ability to phrase cleverly and subtly as one

Whole string sections with the ability to phrase cleverly and subtly as one

The first of this year's two Proms by the Budapest Festival Orchestra had looked like a rather strange confection, on paper at least. With eleven scheduled contributions, and only two of them destined to make it into double figures, its timings had even given it a passing resemblance to a short but eventful cricket innings (there were also three unprogrammed extra items, but more of those later). 

Prom 50: Weilerstein, Czech Philharmonic Orchestra, Bělohlávek

PROM 50: WEILERSTEIN, CZECH PHILHARMONIC ORCHESTRA, BELOHLAVEK An overly impulsive Dvořák, and a disappointing Beethoven from distinguished visitors

An overly impulsive Dvořák, and a disappointing Beethoven from distinguished visitors

Even as orchestras began to sound more and more alike, there was the Czech Philharmonic. And many of its notable characteristics remain to this day: a modest, homespun quality, warm and engaging and full of bright-eyed distinction in the woodwinds.

Prom 46: West-Eastern Divan Orchestra, Barenboim

PROM 46: WEST-EASTERN DIVAN ORCHESTRA, BARENBOIM Subtle touches but too little passionate abandon in this fine team's lopsided programme

Subtle touches but too little passionate abandon in this fine team's lopsided programme

By the time we got to the end of this Prom, with four of the five encores – the whole of Bizet’s Carmen Suite – cannily crafted to bolster the short official programme, most of the rightly euphoric audience had forgotten the most unsatisfying first half so far this season. Perhaps I start from an ungenerous standpoint.

Prom 34: Piemontesi, BBCNOW, Søndergård

PROM 34: PIEMONTESI, BBCNOW, SØNDERGÅRD Feathery jewels from the pianist, but mixed fortunes for Nielsen’s battle-scarred symphony 

 

Feathery jewels from the pianist, but mixed fortunes for Nielsen’s battle-scarred symphony

Some things that spread like wildfire, like ebola and wildfire itself, are not good news at all. But performing Nielsen’s symphonies? That’s another matter entirely. In the next concert season, the BBC Symphony Orchestra and the Philharmonia both begin Nielsen symphony programmes, while the LSO several years ago cycled through one of their own with Sir Colin Davis. Yesterday, the BBC National Symphony of Wales and their current Danish conductor – will it ever be someone Welsh? – bit off one of the mightiest in the set, the battle-scarred Fifth, with its disruptive side-drum.

Prom 33: Schwizgebel, National Youth Orchestra of Great Britain, Gardner

PROMS 33: SCHWIZGEBEL, NATIONAL YOUTH ORCHESTRA OF GREAT BRITAIN, GARDNER 20th century orchestral concertos in a riot of sophisticated colour from terrific teenagers

20th century orchestral concertos in a riot of sophisticated colour from terrific teenagers

After the European Union Youth Orchestra hit unsurpassable heights last week, the Proms plateau of excellence remained available to another youth carnival of weird and wonderful 20th century monsters.

Prom 29: Grosvenor, Goode, BBC Philharmonic, Noseda

Disappointing Chopin, but an Italian rarity and the Royal Albert Hall organ offer honey and fire

“That,” she said, “is what it must be like when you enter heaven.” And I knew just what my wife meant. The organ was in full regalia, revelling in the marshmallow glory of the chorale theme in Saint-Saëns’ Third Symphony, with the orchestra trumpeting behind. The Royal Albert Hall itself proved pretty impressive, even when the gentleman in the row in front spent most of Franck’s Symphonic Variations eating a tub of ice cream.

Prom 28: D'Orazio, Clayton, BBCSO, Oramo

A great Stravinskyan king and queen surpass mood music for electric violin and strings

All kinds of narratives were at play in this Prom from the BBC Symphony Orchestra and its Principal Conductor Sakari Oramo - and perhaps the truly adventurous programmer might have double-deployed Rory Kinnear, dispassionately chronicling Stravinsky’s Oedipus rex, and taken us beyond the Overture and into the melodramas of Beethoven’s Incidental Music to Egmont.

Prom 27: Trusler, BBCNOW, Wigglesworth/Inspire Workshop, Royal Albert Hall

PROM 27: TRUSLER, BBCNOW, WIGGLESWORTH/INSPIRE WORKSHOP Youth and experience take turns in lighting up Elgar

Youth and experience take turns in lighting up Elgar, while a violinist dazzles in a lesser work

A full day began and ended with Elgar the European, or rather the citizen of the world. After all, the Pomp and Circumstance March No.