The Brightening Air, Old Vic review - Chekhov jostles Conor McPherson in writer-director's latest

★★★ THE BRIGHTENING AIR, OLD VIC Chekhov jostles Conor McPherson in writer's latest

The Irishman's first new play in over a decade is engaging but overstuffed

It's one thing to be indebted to a playwright, as Tom Stoppard and Harold Pinter have been at different times to Beckett, or Sondheim's latest musical is to Sartre. But Conor McPherson's The Brightening Air – the title itself is derived from Yeats – comes so fully steeped in Chekhov that you may wonder whether this portrait of rural Ireland in 1980s County Sligo hasn't bled into provincial Russia from nearly a century before, or vice-versa.

Oedipus, Old Vic review - disappointing leads in a production of two halves

OEDIPUS, OLD VIC Disappointing leads in a production of two halves

Is it a dance piece with added text, or a stripped down play with excess choreography?

The opening scene of the Old Vic’s Oedipus is dominated by a giant backdrop of a skull-like face, eyes shut and rock-like. It belongs to the actor playing Oedipus, presumably, Rami Malek. This is as near to a close-up of the title character as we get.

A Christmas Carol, Old Vic review - tidings of discomfort and noise

★★★ A CHRISTMAS CAROL, OLD VIC Tidings of discomfort and noise

This venue’s annual festive classic is joyous, but its writing is frankly patronising

This Dickens classic is an annual treat, or a Christmas trial – depending on your point of view. At the Old Vic, it was adapted by Jack Thorne in 2017, and like the holly and the ivy has been a hardy perennial ever since. Here Scrooge has been played by stars such as Rhys Ifans, Paterson Joseph, Stephen Mangan and Christopher Eccleston. This time it’s the turn of John Simm.

The Real Thing, Old Vic review - Stoppard classic keeps on giving

★★★★ THE REAL THING, OLD VIC James McArdle is immense as Stoppard’s true romantic

James McArdle is immense as Stoppard’s true romantic

When it was first produced in 1982, The Real Thing was a turning point for Tom Stoppard, the play that added to the existing perception of him as an immensely witty, intelligent, very theatrical crafter of dazzling conceits, albeit perhaps a little cold, as someone who could also touch people’s emotions: clever, still, but cutting to the heart. 

The difference was simple, really: Stoppard had always been driven by the desire to explore ideas; this time his idea was love. 

Machinal, The Old Vic review - note-perfect pity and terror

★★★★★ MACHINAL, THE OLD VIC Note-perfect pity and terror 

Sophie Treadwell's 1928 hard hitter gets full musical and choreographic treatment

Virtuosity and a wildly beating heart are compatible in Richard Jones’s finely calibrated production of Renaissance woman Sophie Treadwell’s Machinal. It hits hard as a 1920s mechanical symphony with a lyrical slow movement and words/cliches used like musical refrains. There’s an army of generals at work in the team of 16 actors, led by fearless Rosie Sheehy, and in the genius lighting, movement, sound, design. You rarely see such meticulous, detailed work in the theatre.

Just For One Day, The Old Vic review - clunky scenes and self-conscious exposition between great songs

★★ JUST FOR ONE DAY, THE OLD VIC Clunky scenes and self-conscious exposition between great songs

Saint Bob, Mrs T and a whole lot of feelgood. Oh, and mass starvation

So, a jukebox musical celebrating the apotheosis of the White Saviour, the ultimate carnival of rock stars’ self-aggrandisement and the Boomers’ biggest bonanza of feelgood posturing? One is tempted to stand opposite The Old Vic, point at the punters going in and tell anyone within earshot, “Tonight Thank God it’s them instead of you”. 

A Christmas Carol, The Old Vic review - older, wiser, and yet more moving

★★★★★ A CHRISTMAS CAROL, THE OLD VIC Older, wiser, and yet more moving

Christopher Eccleston is a Scrooge for the ages

Familiarity has bred something quite fantastic with the Old Vic Christmas Carol, which is back for a seventh season and merits ringing all available bells - those and a lost love called Belle being crucial to the show. Matthew Warchus's staging at this point seems a seasonal imperative, and in a wild-haired Christopher Eccleston, Jack Thorne's adaptation of Dickens's 1843 call to empathic arms has its most emotionally piercing and resonant leading man yet. 

Pygmalion, Old Vic review - zappy wit and emotional intelligence

★★★★★ PYGMALION, OLD VIC Zappy wit and emotional intelligence

Patsy Ferran's vibrant Eliza Doolittle sparks Bertie Carvel's Henry Higgins into human life

Many of us have perhaps grown too accustomed to the friendly face of My Fair Lady. George Bernard Shaw’s very original play is sharper, less sentimental yet ultimately more profoundly human. Its wit and wisdom zip along in Richard Jones’s symmetrical, perfectly calibrated production, with three astonishing performances and two climactic scenes, one in each half, which respectively make you (me) cry with laughter and bring a tear to the eye at choice moments.

Groundhog Day, Old Vic review - Tim Minchin’s musical returns in full-on style

★★★★ GROUNDHOG DAY, OLD VIC Tim Minchin’s musical returns in full-on style

A bravura turn from Andy Karl propels a tricky piece over its self-created speed bumps

Groundhog Day, appropriately, is back where it started. The hit film about a TV weatherman’s endlessly reiterated day in small-town USA moved to the Old Vic stage in 2016; but then its progress became bumpy, despite the awards showered on it and its lead, Andy Karl, on both sides of the Atlantic. Karl was injured during a Broadway preview and the show's US tour didn't happen.

Sylvia, Old Vic review - great leads, rambling story

 SYLVIA, THE OLD VIC Beverley Knight is compelling and complex in suffragette musical

Sylvia Pankhurst suffers for her commitment to votes for women and to socialism

For many years, I would ask groups of students to vote in elections because “it’s important to honour those who gave up so much to ensure that the likes of us can”. Some would nod, others would shrug, a few might have inwardly scoffed – too cool for school, innit?