Best of 2014: Opera

BEST OF 2014: OPERA A vintage year as our reviewers struggle to narrow it down to a Top 10

A vintage year as our reviewers struggle to narrow it down to a Top 10

When everything works – conducting, singing, production, costumes, sets, lighting, choreography where relevant – then there’s nothing like the art of opera. But how often does that happen? In my experience, very seldom, but not this year. It's been of such a vintage that I couldn’t possibly choose the best out of six fully-staged productions – three of them from our only native director of genius, Richard Jones, who as one of his favourite singers, Susan Bullock, put it to me, deserves every gong going – and one concert performance.

The Nutcracker, English National Ballet, London Coliseum

THE NUTCRACKER, ENGLISH NATIONAL BALLET, LONDON COLISEUM Wayne Eagling's production returns for another bout of rodent control

Wayne Eagling's production returns for another bout of rodent control

Unusually, English National Ballet’s Nutcracker finds itself in an empty field this year. Three Decembers ago, the second time out for Wayne Eagling’s production, it had to contend with Matthew Bourne’s version and the Royal Ballet’s, not to mention the fallout from a BBC fly-on-the-wall series that had brutally exposed its difficult conception.

The Gospel According to the Other Mary, English National Opera

THE GOSPEL ACCORDING TO THE OTHER MARY, ENGLISH NATIONAL OPERA Grace and pain stunningly interwoven in Adams's rich score and Sellars's luminous staging

Grace and pain stunningly interwoven in Adams's rich score and Sellars's luminous staging

A great creative partnership like the one between composer John Adams and director Peter Sellars can endure the occasional wobble. In his peerless autobiography Hallelujah Junction Adams is frank about the information overload in Sellars’ premiere production of the millennial opera-oratorio woven around the birth of Christ, El Niño.

La Bohème, English National Opera

LA BOHÈME, ENGLISH NATIONAL OPERA Star-voiced lovers move and soar, but revived Jonathan Miller production does little

Star-voiced lovers move and soar, but revived Jonathan Miller production does little

ENO may not always have matched the Royal Opera in the Great Puccini Voices stakes. But it's served up many of the classiest Mimìs, with Valerie Masterson, Mary Plazas and Elizabeth Llewellyn as top seamstresses. Californian former beauty queen Angel Blue, an acclaimed Musetta in the previous revival, now joins them.

The Girl of the Golden West, English National Opera

THE GIRL OF THE GOLDEN WEST, ENGLISH NATIONAL OPERA, Susan Bullock's Minnie gets her gun, and her man, in Puccini's wackiest melodrama

Susan Bullock's Minnie gets her gun, and her man, in Puccini's wackiest melodrama

So now it’s Minnie Get Your Gun from the director who brought us the gobsmackingly inventive Young Vic Annie (as in sharpshooter Oakley, not Little Orphan). Richard Jones’s subversive but still very human take on Irving Berlin discombobulated its American support and never made Broadway; but there’s little here that would rock the steadily progressive Met (home of La fanciulla del West’s 1910 premiere, with Enrico Caruso as “Dick Johnson” aka quickly repentant bandit Ramerrez).

PUSH, Guillem/Maliphant, London Coliseum

PUSH, GUILLEM / MALIPHANT, LONDON COLISEUM An astonishing evening from three dance world greats

An astonishing evening from three dance world greats

Last night’s performance of PUSH at the London Colisem left me exhilarated and downcast in equal measure. Exhilarated because dancer Sylvie Guillem, dancer/choreographer Russell Maliphant and lighting genius Michael Hulls together create the Holy Grail of dance, a blend of intelligence, talent and charisma so stunning and convincing that it seems to trascend description and become sacramental. And downcast because this run is the last of PUSH in London, and so for most of us the last time we’ll ever see it, or perhaps even see Guillem or Maliphant perform.

Coppélia, English National Ballet, London Coliseum

COPPÉLIA, ENGLISH NATIONAL BALLET, LONDON COLISEUM Good clean fun from bright young things

Good clean fun from bright young things

For all it’s a balmy July here, the litany of appalling news from the world’s conflict zones will have left many of us feeling less than summery at heart. In that frame of mind, you might wonder whether Coppélia, English National Ballet’s latest production, is quite what you want to see. We are speaking, after all, of a frothy 19th-century comic ballet, full of charading silliness, populated by unfeasibly cheerful peasants, and ending happily with the all-too-predictable wedding. Sharp social commentary – or existential comfort – it ain’t.

Diaghilev Festival Gala, London Coliseum

DIAGHILEV FESTIVAL GALA, LONDON COLISEUM First-rate work, high energy and musical glories from a little-known Moscow company

First-rate work, high energy and musical glories from a little-known Moscow company

Bakst’s harem drapes and Roerich’s smoking, steaming Polovtsian camp may not have had the most lavish of recreations. But the rest of this homage to Diaghilev shone with an exuberance and even a precision one would not have thought possible from previous seasons of what had once seemed like Andris Liepa’s Ballets Russes vanity project.

The Golden Cockerel, Diaghilev Festival, London Coliseum

THE GOLDEN COCKEREL, DIAGHILEV FESTIVAL, LONDON COLISEUM Outstanding musical values in tribute to Diaghilev opera-ballet

Musical values outstanding, decor and dance not bad in tribute to Diaghilev opera-ballet

Rimsky-Korsakov’s bizarre final fantasy, puffing up Pushkin's short verse-tale to unorthodox proportions, has done better in Britain than any of his other operatic fairy-tales. That probably has something to do with its appearance in Paris, six years after the composer’s death in 1908, courtesy of a brave new experiment marshalled by that chameleonic impresario Sergei Diaghilev.