Best of 2014: Classical Concerts

BEST OF 2014: CLASSICAL CONCERTS A triumphant year for youth and pianism

A triumphant year for youth and pianism

Offshoots of the Venezuelan El Sistema’s worldwide dissemination as well as other youth and music projects continued to bloom and grow in 2014. The morning after what was the orchestral concert of the year for many who caught it, Alexandra Coghlan (see below) and myself included, players of the European Union Youth Orchestra reconvened in the Albert Hall to workshop three classics with musicians from nine British youth orchestras and London schools.

Messiah, OAE, Howarth, Royal Festival Hall

MESSIAH, OAE, HOWARTH, ROYAL FESTIVAL HALL An earthbound Messiah lacks wonder and urgency

An earthbound Messiah lacks wonder and urgency

Goldilocks would not have been a good conductor. There’s a reason why there isn’t a dynamic marking between mezzo forte and mezzo piano. Mezzo on its own would be a pretty bland state of affairs, sat solidly in an inoffensive state of not-too-loud-and-not-too-soft, not swelling to a crescendo or pining away to a decrescendo, but content with a steady sonic compromise. Last night the Orchestra of the Age of Enlightenment gave us a decidedly mezzo Messiah, a performance that couldn’t seem to galvanise itself into any decisive emotion.

Stefanovich, Currie, Queen Elizabeth Hall

STEFANOVICH, CURRIE, QUEEN ELIZABETH HALL Dream team for Birtwistle, while the pianist shines in Ligeti and Messiaen

Dream team for Birtwistle, while the pianist shines in Ligeti and Messiaen

Tamara Stefanovich and Colin Currie – a dream team for Birtwistle’s The Axe Manual. Both are new music specialists with a gift for grace and dexterity, even in the most complex works. The score sets up a range of sophisticated relationships between piano and percussion, from sympathetic resonances to complex interplays of stretto and hocket. Yet none of this fazes the two players, nor ever challenges their close ensemble, seemingly telepathic in its precision.

Aimard, LPO, Jurowski, Royal Festival Hall

AIMARD, LPO, JUROWSKI, ROYAL FESTIVAL HALL Birtwistle’s new Piano Concerto dazzles, but that's only one course in an orchestral feast

Birtwistle’s new Piano Concerto dazzles, but that's only one course in an orchestral feast

In words and music Harrison Birtwistle isn’t always as gruff as he’s been painted. Interviewed over the summer during one of his 80th birthday Prom concerts, the composer tossed off enough humorous remarks to suggest that a new career could almost beckon as a stand-up comedian touring the northern clubs.

Birtwistle 80th Birthday Concert, London Sinfonietta, Atherton, QEH review

BIRTWISTLE 80TH BIRTHDAY CONCERT, LONDON SINFONIETTA, QEH Tribute showcases a master of both the miniature and the monumental

Tribute showcases a master of both the miniature and the monumental

Sir Harrison Birtwistle has never sought to make life easy for his audiences, nor for interviewers, often giving short shrift to both. His music is as uncompromising as his carefully curated public persona. But fortunately last night we were treated to more notes and less chat than the printed programme threatened.

Levit, LPO, Jurowski, Royal Festival Hall

LEVIT, LPO, JUROWSKI, ROYAL FESTIVAL HALL Exhilarating gloom in the young Rachmaninov's First Symphony redeems hazy Scriabin

Exhilarating gloom in the young Rachmaninov's First Symphony redeems hazy Scriabin

If Brahms’s First Symphony has long been dubbed “Beethoven’s Tenth”, then the 23-year-old Rachmaninov’s First merits the label of “Tchaikovsky’s Seventh” (a genuine candidate for that title, incidentally, turns out to be a poor reconstruction from Tchaikovsky’s sketches by one Bogatryryev).

Chung, Kenner, Royal Festival Hall

CHUNG, KENNER, ROYAL FESTIVAL HALL Hit-and-miss comeback for the great South Korean violinist, with stupendous pianist in tow

Hit-and-miss comeback for the great South Korean violinist, with stupendous pianist in tow

In one way, it makes sense to give your London comeback concert in the venue where you made your European debut 44 years ago. Yet the Royal Festival Hall is a mighty big place for a violin-and-piano recital. Kyung Wha Chung had no problem nearly filling it last night with an audience including whole Korean families, but might have wished she hadn’t in the ailment-ridden dead of winter; her look could have killed a coughing child ("go and get a glass of water" is what I think I heard her say, from my very distant seat).

Marianne Faithfull, Royal Festival Hall

MARIANNE FAITHFULL, ROYAL FESTIVAL HALL Rock diva and recovered heroin addict makes a therapist out of her anniversary tour audience

Rock diva and recovered heroin addict makes a therapist out of her anniversary tour audience

“I have quit smoking!” the rock star exclaims to rapturous applause, taking a luxurious drag on an e-cigarette. And the artificial smoke dissipates across the stage, revealing a 67-year-old Marianne Faithfull perched on an antique leather chair, shoulder raised and pouting as if caricaturing her own youth. It is a subtle and triumphant reference to her past of destructive drug abuse and yet tonight quite clearly shows that for Faithfull the stage (alongside nicotine replacement and a wooden walking stick) is now her crucial crutch for rehabilitation.  

Pelléas et Mélisande, Philharmonia, Salonen, RFH

PELLÉAS ET MÉLISANDE, PHILHARMONIA, SALONEN, RFH A Pelléas of echoes and allusions, and a dramatic revelation

A Pelléas of echoes and allusions, and a dramatic revelation

In an operatic world in which the director is an increasingly despotic king, it’s good to be reminded that, sometimes, not staging an opera is the most radical reading of all. No elaborate set or concept dominated David Edwards’s one-off Pelléas et Mélisande at the Royal Festival Hall last night. There were just suggestions, allusions, echoes. And a cast – what a cast – that came close to perfection.

OAE, Tognetti, Queen Elizabeth Hall

Australian live-wire violinist leads classical and romantic string music with varying success

As I sat, engaged and occasionally charmed but not always as impressed as I’d been told I would be, through violinist-animateur Richard Tognetti’s lightish seven-course taster menu of string music with the Orchestra of the Age of Enlightenment, it was worth bearing two things in mind. One was that this happened to be merely the official zenith of a truly enlightened three-part project; on Monday, parts of the programme had been played first to educate all ages and later to grab a young audience in more relaxed mode as part of the OAE’s pioneering Night Shift series.