The Mastersingers of Nuremberg, English National Opera

THE MASTERSINGERS OF NUREMBERG, ENGLISH NATIONAL OPERA Focused joy, and a great philosopher-hero, as Richard Jones's Wagner reaches London

Focused joy, and a great philosopher-hero, as Richard Jones's Wagner reaches London

After seven glorious Welsh National Opera performances in the summer of 2010, it looked like curtains for Richard Jones’s Mastersingers (or Meistersinger, as it then was, sung in German): no DVD, no co-productions. The director seemed happy with that, as philosophical as Wagner's operatic characterisation of 16th-century cobbler-mastersinger Hans Sachs. Such, he implied, was the ephemeral nature of the true theatrical experience, rare at a time when nearly everything gets documented.

Best of 2014: Opera

BEST OF 2014: OPERA A vintage year as our reviewers struggle to narrow it down to a Top 10

A vintage year as our reviewers struggle to narrow it down to a Top 10

When everything works – conducting, singing, production, costumes, sets, lighting, choreography where relevant – then there’s nothing like the art of opera. But how often does that happen? In my experience, very seldom, but not this year. It's been of such a vintage that I couldn’t possibly choose the best out of six fully-staged productions – three of them from our only native director of genius, Richard Jones, who as one of his favourite singers, Susan Bullock, put it to me, deserves every gong going – and one concert performance.

The Way Back Home, ENO, Young Vic

THE WAY BACK HOME, ENO, YOUNG VIC A colourful children's show that's got Christmas written all over it

A colourful children's show that's got Christmas written all over it

A Martian, a Spitfire and a flatulent penguin are the unlikely ingredients for The Way Back Home, English National Opera’s first foray into the colourful world of children’s opera. And if those don’t sound like enticement enough, be reassured, at only 45 minutes long this really is a child-friendly taster of a genre that doesn’t always get the best press when it comes to accessibility.

The Gospel According to the Other Mary, English National Opera

THE GOSPEL ACCORDING TO THE OTHER MARY, ENGLISH NATIONAL OPERA Grace and pain stunningly interwoven in Adams's rich score and Sellars's luminous staging

Grace and pain stunningly interwoven in Adams's rich score and Sellars's luminous staging

A great creative partnership like the one between composer John Adams and director Peter Sellars can endure the occasional wobble. In his peerless autobiography Hallelujah Junction Adams is frank about the information overload in Sellars’ premiere production of the millennial opera-oratorio woven around the birth of Christ, El Niño.

La Bohème, English National Opera

LA BOHÈME, ENGLISH NATIONAL OPERA Star-voiced lovers move and soar, but revived Jonathan Miller production does little

Star-voiced lovers move and soar, but revived Jonathan Miller production does little

ENO may not always have matched the Royal Opera in the Great Puccini Voices stakes. But it's served up many of the classiest Mimìs, with Valerie Masterson, Mary Plazas and Elizabeth Llewellyn as top seamstresses. Californian former beauty queen Angel Blue, an acclaimed Musetta in the previous revival, now joins them.

The Marriage of Figaro, English National Opera

THE MARRIAGE OF FIGARO, ENGLISH NATIONAL OPERA Fiona Shaw's Mozart makes a joyous return to the Coliseum

Fiona Shaw's Mozart makes a joyous return to the Coliseum

To take Figaro – the ultimate operatic assault on class distinctions and social hierarchies – and set it on a giant revolve is a gesture as wilful as it is elegant. Not only are divisions of above and below-stairs dissolved in this steadily circling world, but also those of background and foreground, onstage and offstage. By the time the set’s rotations revealed two young valets with their trousers down, relieving themselves up against a palace wall, some few minutes into the Overture, Fiona Shaw had already won her audience and her case.

The Girl of the Golden West, English National Opera

THE GIRL OF THE GOLDEN WEST, ENGLISH NATIONAL OPERA, Susan Bullock's Minnie gets her gun, and her man, in Puccini's wackiest melodrama

Susan Bullock's Minnie gets her gun, and her man, in Puccini's wackiest melodrama

So now it’s Minnie Get Your Gun from the director who brought us the gobsmackingly inventive Young Vic Annie (as in sharpshooter Oakley, not Little Orphan). Richard Jones’s subversive but still very human take on Irving Berlin discombobulated its American support and never made Broadway; but there’s little here that would rock the steadily progressive Met (home of La fanciulla del West’s 1910 premiere, with Enrico Caruso as “Dick Johnson” aka quickly repentant bandit Ramerrez).

Xerxes, English National Opera

XERXES, ENGLISH NATIONAL OPERA Alice Coote shines in pretty and witty vintage Handel

This vintage Handel is pretty, witty and more youthful than ever

Nicholas Hytner’s 1988 Magic Flute may have trilled its last at English National Opera, but judging by the wit, the joy and the energy on display last night it would be absolutely criminal to put the director’s even more elderly Xerxes out to pasture – the show that brought Handel back into fashion when it premiered in 1985.

Otello, English National Opera

OTELLO, ENGLISH NATIONAL OPERA A dark, potent Otello: David Alden at his best

A dark and potent version of Verdi is David Alden at his best

From one great operatic storm to another. 2014 opened at English National Opera with David Alden’s Peter Grimes, gale-tossed and wet with sea-spray, and now the director turns his attention to Verdi’s Otello. Restlessly urgent, Edward Gardner’s opening assaulted us with timpani thunderclaps, stabbing into the silent auditorium as Otello himself would do just a few hours later. Tragedy is written into the musical fabric of Verdi’s opera, and in Alden’s new production we have a pervasive emotional horror that matches it blow for blow.

The Pearl Fishers, English National Opera

THE PEARL FISHERS, ENGLISH NATIONAL OPERA Second-tier opera in visually impressive and dramatically improved revival

Second-tier opera in visually impressive and dramatically improved revival

Before curtain-up on the opening night of this revival of Penny Woolcock’s production of The Pearl Fishers, ENO's head of casting arrived on stage with a microphone. No doubt delightful company in person, he was an unwelcome sight here. Sophie Bevan had a stomach bug, he explained – the disappointment was palpable. But she'd be bravely singing anyway – grateful applause broke out. In the end, our goodwill was not called upon in the least, since Bevan's voice in her debut as Leïla was as strong and agile as ever.