HMS Pinafore, Hackney Empire

HMS PINAFORE, HACKNEY EMPIRE All-male Gilbert and Sullivan from Sasha Regan's lively company

All-male G&S has familiar trademark fun, but weak links and big venue mute the pleasure

Showboys will be boys – gym-bunny sailors, in this instance – as well as sisters, cousins, aunts, captain’s daughters and bumboat women. We know the ropes by now for Sasha Regan’s all-male Gilbert and Sullivan: a loving attempt to recreate, she says, the innocence of musical theatre in same-sex schools (mine, for which I played Sir Joseph Porter with a supporting army or navy of recorders, two cellos and piano, was mixed).

DCI Banks, ITV

Dogged detective works well in print, but why don't the stories catch fire on TV?

Mothers and their sons provided the framework for the latest story involving DCI Alan Banks, the character on whom ITV is pinning its hopes to fill the vacancy of the nation’s favourite detective now that Frost and Morse are no more. Peter Robinson’s series of novels has been enjoyed for more than 25 years, selling millions in the UK and translated into more than 20 languages, but it took until 2010 to reach our television screens with Stephen Tompkinson in the starring role.

Royal Cousins at War, BBC Two

ROYAL COUSINS AT WAR, BBC TWO How bombs and bullets proved to be thicker than royal blood

How bombs and bullets proved to be thicker than royal blood

World War One overkill - if you'll pardon the expression - is a clear and present danger as the centenary commemorations gather pace, but this investigation of the roles of the interlinked royal families of Europe in the onrush of hostilities was as good a chunk of TV history as I can remember. Informative and detailed but always keeping an eye on the bigger picture, it made me, at any rate, start to think about the road to 1914 in a different light.

Moonfleet, Sky1

J Meade Falkner's much-loved smuggler's tale doesn't quite feel at home on the telly

They've had Ray Winstone all over Sky this Christmas, gamely plugging this new dramatisation of J Meade Falkner's rumbustious crowd-pleaser, Moonfleet. Ray's theme is that we urgently need more quality drama with broad appeal on TV and shouldn't keep relying on worn-out cliches about drug dealers and murderers.

Winterreise, Gilchrist, Tilbrook, Temple Church

WINTERREISE, GILCHRIST, TILBROOK, TEMPLE CHURCH An insightful interpretation of Schubert's inexhaustibly inspired work 

An insightful interpretation of Schubert's inexhaustibly inspired work

A rare thing indeed. A British singer/pianist duo has had the patience, and also been given the opportunities over a number of years, to own and to inhabit a thoroughly individual and intelligent interpretation of Schubert's Winterreise.

Sifting the Evidence: the Great Train Robbery, 50 Years On

SIFTING THE EVIDENCE: THE GREAT TRAIN ROBBERY, 50 YEARS ON Jim Broadbent stars as DCS Tommy Butler in Chris Chibnall's two-part drama for BBC One

Jim Broadbent stars as DCS Tommy Butler in Chris Chibnall's two-part drama for BBC One

There’s a wonderful moment in Bruce Reynolds’s autobiography when he describes what became of his mate, a fellow train robber who had fled to Canada but was hunted down by the enigmatic Tommy Butler. Four and a half years after the Great Train Robbery in which crooks made off with £2.6million, Detective Chief Superintendent Butler had come to arrest Charlie Wilson and was knocking on his door.

Lucan, ITV

LUCAN, ITV Murder and moral squalor in the playgrounds of the aristocracy

Murder and moral squalor in the playgrounds of the aristocracy

The disappearance of Lord “Lucky” Lucan in 1974 remains one of the most teasing enigmas of recent-ish history. Following the collapse of his marriage and a bitter battle with his wife Veronica for custody of their three children, the gambling addict Lucan is presumed to have battered the children’s nanny to death, attacked his wife, then fled the country by boat from Newhaven. Elvis-like sightings of the disgraced peer have poured in from around the world ever since.

The Silent War, BBC Two

THE SILENT WAR, BBC TWO Strange secrets from the invisible underwater struggle waged by three navies

Strange secrets from the invisible underwater struggle waged by three navies

The cumulative effect of the BBC's Cold War season hasn't been to remind us that truth is stranger than fiction so much as to demonstrate how they swirled together into a miasma of delusion and uncertainty. We've seen Reds under the bed and spies in the ointment and revisited once again notorious episodes of the highest treason.

Lionel Bart: Reviewing the Situation, BBC Four

The maverick musicals-maker, warts and all

These days, it seems you can't move without encountering musicals in some context or another on TV. Series like Smash and Glee trade on the genre to a degree hovering between the loving and the parasitic, while two contrasting documentaries, The Sound of Musicals and The Story of Musicals, have shed varying degrees of light on how shows get actually get to the stage (or not).

Henry V, Noel Coward Theatre

HENRY V, NOEL COWARD THEATRE Jude Law reigns supreme, ending Michael Grandage's star-studded season

Jude Law reigns supreme, ending Michael Grandage's star-studded season

It has been a hard slog, but he's emerging victorious in the end. Essentially, Shakespeare's Henry V tracks a military campaign. In Act One, the eponymous king declares war on France. By Act Five, against the odds, he has won and is sealing an entente cordiale with a kiss – wooing the French princess, Katharine. At the start of Michael Grandage's eagerly awaited West End production, the Chorus (Ashley Zhangazha) darts to the apron stage to address the audience with: "Oh for a Muse of fire, that would ascend/The brightest heaven of invention!"