Candide, Welsh National Opera review - vaut le voyage, just for the visual side

★★★★ CANDIDE, WELSH NATIONAL OPERA Vaut le voyage, just for the visual side

Spectacular staging of a work that doesn't quite measure up musically

If you read the synopsis of Candide - which I strongly advise if you plan a visit to this new WNO production - you may well wonder how it will be possible to get through so much in so short a time. Voltaire’s novella is itself fairly short, but opera takes more time and songs are songs, not action.

Werther, Grange Park Opera review - Italian-American principal singers with strong chemistry

WERTHER, GRANGE PARK OPERA Italian-American principals with strong chemistry

Containment and explosion well balanced in a strong show

Grange Park Opera has been setting a high standard in French opera ever since the company's first proper season in 1999. This Werther is the company's third by Jules Massenet. The first two were rarities, pioneering efforts: a fascinating tussle between lubriciousness and piety in Thais in 2006, and then a poignant and deeply felt portrayal of old age in a splendid Don Quichotte in 2014.

Ariadne auf Naxos, Garsington Opera review - golden thread leads to deep emotion

★★★★★ ARIADNE AUF NAXOS, GARSINGTON OPERA Golden thread leads to deep emotion

Great cast rides on a magic carpet furnished by Mark Wigglesworth and the Philharmonia

When tears well up during stretches of Strauss and Hofmannsthal’s curious hybrid which you never expected to move you, something special's going on. The magic happened last night in an evening which I didn't anticipate equalling “the Carmelites experience” at Glyndebourne. But, in its very different way, it did, in terms of casting, conducting and a production (by Bruno Ravella) that wasn’t too interventionist but had some powerful ideas of its own.

Everest, Barbican review - a powerful operatic debut from Joby Talbot

★★★★ EVEREST, BARBICAN A powerful operatic debut from Joby Talbot

The 1996 Everest disaster supplies the story for a vivid piece of music-theatre

Schubert gave us a winter’s journey for the 19th century: a wandering lover brooding, remembering, fantasising, maybe even dying to the chilly accompanying churn of the hurdy-gurdy man. In Everest, composer Joby Talbot and librettist Gene Scheer recreate it for the 21st.

A journey of the mind becomes as much one of the body. Love remains, along with memories and fantasies, but now the human beloved must share their place with something else: the mountain. Obsessive, deceptive, all-consuming desire takes vivid form in this powerful operatic debut.

Il trovatore, Royal Opera review - heaven and hell

★★★ IL TROVATORE, ROYAL OPERA Cod-medieval heaven and hell showcasing strong cast

Everyone delivers, but one day Verdi's hit-and-miss melodrama will get the right staging

The trouble with Trovatore, Verdi’s sometimes barrel-organish, slightly middle-aged troubadour, isn’t so much the silly shocker of a plot, triggered by a gypsy so crazed with vengeance that she throws her own baby on a bonfire by mistake, as the choppy dramatic line, so hard to thread. Under the circumstance, Adele Thomas’s medieval-hell production could have been a lot worse, and the vocal quality is there throughout under Antonio Pappano’s watchful guidance.

Werther, Royal Opera review - Kaufmann off form in this stiff revival

★★★ WERTHER, ROYAL OPERA Kaufmann disappoints but Aigul Akhmetshina shines

Aigul Akhmetshina steps into the big league with a captivating Charlotte

Benoit Jacquot’s handsome period production of Werther has been quietly putting in the miles for the Royal Opera. Since its premiere in 2004, this unexceptionable staging – “this wall, this fountain, this cool shade” all present and laboriously correct – has supplied a London star vehicle for everyone from Joyce DiDonato and Isabel Leonard to Juan Diego Florez, Rollando Villazon and Vittorio Grigolo. Now it’s the turn of Jonas Kaufmann – or, at least, it was supposed to be.

Hansel and Gretel, Opera Holland Park review - the Great Grimm Bake-Off

A flavourful balance of menace and merriment in Humperdinck's fairy-tale favourite

Like any decent cake (and we saw plenty on the Holland Park stage), a tasty production of Hansel and Gretel needs a careful balance of flavours. Sweet and sharp; light and dark; fantasy and realism; fright and delight. Directed by John Wilkie, Opera Holland Park’s version of Engelbert Humperdinck’s well-preserved “fairy-tale opera” from 1893 skilfully mixes its ingredients into a sort of Great Grimm Bake-Off. It hints at horrors but never really threatens to turn sour.

Dialogues des Carmélites, Glyndebourne review - faith overwhelmed by horror

★★★★★ DIALOGUES DES CARMÉLITES, GLYNDEBOURNE Strongest possible casting, directing and conducting sear the soul

Strongest possible casting, directing and conducting sear the soul

Harrowing and holiness alternate in Poulenc’s unique masterpiece, nominally an opera about nuns during the French revolution, at a deeper level a music-drama about the greatest disturbances in the human condition. Glyndebourne’s cast, conductor and orchestra handle the variety wth total mastery. If Barrie Kosky’s production lets horror overwhelm us, that’s justified too. If you’re not a heap at the end of it, that’s your problem.

Princess Ida, OAE, Wilson, QEH review - musical brilliance undermined by textual botch

★★★ PRINCESS IDA, OAE, WILSON, QEH Complete score, superbly done, but dialogue is axed

A complete score at last, superbly done, but as usual Gilbert's dialogue is mostly axed

Sullivan’s score for his eighth collaboration with Gilbert is vintage work, mostly equal to the splendid sentinels flanking it, Iolanthe and The Mikado. On Wednesday night master animator John Wilson did its buoyancy and occasional pathos full justice. But what of Gilbert’s words? “A woman’s [sic] college! Maddest folly going!” doesn’t promise an operetta for our times.