Aida, Royal Opera review - dour but disciplined

★★★ AIDA, ROYAL OPERA Uniformly good cast, idiomatic conducting, production in rigid khaki

Uniformly good cast, idiomatic conducting, production rigidly consistent in khaki

No gods, ancient Egyptian or otherwise; no sinister priest along the lines of Russia’s antichrist Patriarch Kiriil, sending soldiers to their deaths with the promise of heaven. Military ritual under what looks like a Russian/Chinese flag prevails in Robert Carsen’s severe take on Aida, more rigid than Verdi’s surprisingly unified late score - a musical masterpiece if not a dramatic one.

The Makropulos Affair, Welsh National Opera review - complexity realised brilliantly on the stage

★★★★★ THE MAKROPULOS AFFAIR, WNO Complexity realised brilliantly on the stage

Janáček’s collisions spark an evening of powerful conflict

What, anyway, is The Makropulos Case all about? Is it simply about the horrors of unnatural longevity; or does it expose the limitations of the rational mind confronted by the irrational; is it about love of a distorted ideal, like some updated Hoffmann tale? Or is it simply a well-made play disrupted by theatre of the absurd and turned for good measure into a tragic music drama?

La rondine, If Opera review - a bold opening gambit from a company changing the business of opera

★★★ LA RONDINE, IF OPERA Bold opening gambit from a company changing the business of opera

Puccini's tearjerker is served up fresh by a young cast

Covid has been devastating for all the arts, but especially opera – the riskiest and most expensive gamble of the lot. And it doesn’t seem to be anywhere near done yet. On one memorable night this summer the number of covers stepping into principal roles across the various country-house opera companies hit double figures. And not small ones. So what do we do? Crash on as before and hope for the best? Scale back and build in safeguards, both human and financial? Or throw out the whole setup and start afresh?

Saul, The English Concert, Butt, Edinburgh International Festival 2022 review - properly exciting music drama

★★★★★ SAUL, THE ENGLISH CONCERT, BUTT, EDINBURGH Properly exciting music drama

Master Handelian directs a marvellously colourful performance with outstanding singers

It’s not an opera, of course, but of all Handel’s oratorios, Saul is probably the one that is best suited to being presented as an actual drama. Several productions, most notably Barrie Kosky's at Glyndebourne, have shown how it can work on stage, but this performance at the Edinburgh International Festival proved that you can have a great evening’s drama with nary a prop or costume in sight.

Patience, Charles Court Opera, Wilton's Music Hall review - bar room bliss

★★★PATIENCE, CHARLES COURT OPERA, WILTON'S MUSIC HALL Perfect cast of nine delivers big laughs and fair share of vocal glamour

Perfect cast of nine delivers big laughs and fair share of vocal glamour

“Twenty lovesick maidens we,” pining in stained-glass attitudes for florid poet Reginald Bunthorne, usually kick off Gilbert and Sullivan’s delicious mockery of the high (or cod) aesthetical. That might have been a problem for Charles Court Opera’s total cast of nine. Not so: the lights go up on three “melancholy”, Goth-sh maybe not-quite-“maidens", knocking it back at the bar of the Castle Inn, and we know we’re in the best of hands. The delight is unmodified over the next two hours.

Sir John in Love, British Youth Opera review - a delicious end-of-summer treat

★★★SIR JOHN IN LOVE, BRITISH YOUTH OPERA A rare operatic staging marks Vaughan Williams' 150th anniversary

A rare operatic staging marks Vaughan Williams' 150th anniversary

You’d be forgiven for forgetting that 2022 marks a rather significant classical milestone. Vaughan Williams’ 150th anniversary has scarcely troubled the Proms season beyond the odd symphony, and while most orchestras are doing their bit in the autumn, it takes predictable form. Larks will ascend, Thomas Tallis will be hymned, and Scott will make his doomed journey to the Antarctic to live symphonic accompaniment up and down the country. But not at British Youth Opera.

First Persons: Glyndebourne's sustainability advisers Sara and Jeremy Eppel on creating eco-friendly opera

Foraging for costumes and beach combing for set dressing: Glyndebourne's sustainability advisers Sara and Jeremy Eppel on creating eco-friendly opera

This season's production of 'The Wreckers' leads the way towards net zero

Like the beacons saving ships from the Cornish rocks in Ethel Smyth’s opera, The Wreckers, which opened this year’s Glyndebourne Festival, the Sussex opera house has itself become a beacon of more environmentally sustainable opera. In 2021, with the COP 26 Climate Change Conference raising the profile of businesses’ efforts to cut their carbon emissions, Glyndebourne was a pioneer among opera houses and joined the global Race to Zero.

First Person: Michael Volpe on the utopian thinking behind his new If Opera company

FIRST PERSON Michael Volpe on the utopian thinking behind his new If Opera company

Bold aims for country-house opera with a difference

“But what’s in it for you?”. It was a simple enough question, asked by an accomplished opera singer. It stemmed from hearing that the new version of the Iford Arts opera company I was running was aiming for a different kind of guiding philosophy: it would have a repertory ensemble, who would be paid weekly wages and would work under a clearly defined code of conduct that placed them front and centre of our organisation, attempting to return agency to them.

Salome, Bergen Philharmonic Orchestra, Gardner, Edinburgh International Festival 2022 review - orchestral majesty triumphs

★★★★ SALOME, BERGEN PHILHARMONIC ORCHESTRA, GARDNER, EIF 2022 Malin Byström offers presence and power as Strauss and Wilde's sex-crazed princess

Malin Byström offers presence and power as Strauss and Wilde's sex-crazed princess

It is quite some years, if not decades, since the Edinburgh International Festival had any claim to be a festival of staged opera. This year we have had just one – Garsington Opera’s bewitching Rusalka – surrounded by a handful of concert performances: Beethoven’s Fidelio with the Philharmonia under Donald Runnicles, Handel’s Saul (yet to come), and Sunday evening’s Salome.

La Voix humaine/Les Mamelles de Tirésias, Glyndebourne review - phantasmagorical wonders

★★★★★ LA VOIX HUMAINE / LES MAMELLES DE TIRESIAS, GLYNDEBOURNE Visual and aural beauty, strong performances, in a stunning double-bill from Laurent Pelly

Visual and aural beauty, strong performances, in a stunning double-bill from Laurent Pelly

“Variety is the spice of life! Vive la difference!,” chirrups the ensemble at the end of this giddying double bill. And there could hardly be more singular variety acts than a potential suicide at the end of a phone line, a woman who lets her breasts fly away and grows a beard, and a husband who breeds 40,049 children on his own.