Rusalka, Edinburgh International Festival 2022 review - sumptuous rendition of a watery fable

★★★★ RUSALKA, EIF 2022 Total triumph for replacement water-nymph Elin Pritchard

Total triumph for replacement water-nymph Elin Pritchard

The last-minute indisposition of your leading lady is enough to give festival directors palpitations, let alone their audiences, now forewarned by the dreaded email thudding into inboxes. And so it was that Andrew Moore, Head of Music at the Edinburgh International Festival, had to poke his nose through the stage curtain and announce that Natalya Romaniw was unable to sing the title role of Rusalka, which would instead be sung by fellow Welsh soprano Elin Pritchard.

theartsdesk at the Bayreuth Festival Ring 2022 - a jumbled mess of ideas, some of them compelling

A Tarantino-style Ring cycle offers many inspired scenes, but little coherence or depth

It is mid-way through the new Ring cycle, and we are taking lunch outside the old town hall on the high street in Bayreuth. Discussion at neighbouring tables is intense: “The Ring is a child!”, “Why does Wotan have no spear?”, “The pyramid in the box – what is that all about?”

Utopia, Limited, National Gilbert & Sullivan Opera Company review - bounded rapture

★★★★ UTOPIA, LIMITED, NATIONAL GILBERT & SULLIVAN OPERA Bounded rapture

Savoy turkey almost flies, in a spirited new staging

Joseph Heller grew tired of being told that he’d never written anything as good as Catch 22. ‘Who has?’, he'd retort. In the same spirit, it’s futile to compare Gilbert and Sullivan’s late flop Utopia, Limited to The Mikado, The Gondoliers, Iolanthe or The Pirates of Penzance.

Spell Book/La liberazione di Ruggiero dell'isola di Alcina, Longborough Festival review - the pitfalls of diversity

Music of charm or character not always trusted in its presentation

Diversity is a great idea, but it can sometimes contain the seeds of its own downfall. Positive discrimination is an obvious, frequent example. But there are two different cases in Longborough’s double bill of Freya Waley-Cohen’s Spell Book and Francesca Caccini’s La liberazione di Ruggiero dall’isola di Alcina, the one case to do with the character of the work itself, the other to do mainly with the philosophy behind its performance here. 

Prom 13, The Wreckers, Glyndebourne review - an overloaded ship steered with pride

★★★ PROM 13, THE WRECKERS, GLYNDEBOURNE An overloaded ship steered with pride

Ethel Smyth's grand melodrama stays seaworthy - in parts

Uncut, lovingly restored, and with two intervals in the antique manner, Ethel Smyth’s The Wreckers invites its audience to embark on an epic voyage as well as a momentous one. This summer’s Glyndebourne Festival visit to the Proms brought us the rediscovered opera about a pious, paranoid community of Cornish ship-scavengers that the trail-blazing Smyth – who judged it her signature work – laboured over for several years before its premiere in Leipzig in 1906.

Margot La Rouge/Le Villi, Opera Holland Park review – Parisian fancies and Black Forest gâteau

★★★★ MARGOT LA ROUGE / LE VILLI, OPERA HOLLAND PARK Parisian fancies and Black Forest gâteau

A double helping of rarities makes for an enjoyable, outlandish menu

Take an opera newbie along to Opera Holland Park’s double bill of rarities and they may have both their worst fears and their highest hopes confirmed. Outlandish plotting, overwrought melodrama and preposterous, supernatural stage business abounds. At the same time, some gorgeous music, memorable singing and dramatic coups make the whole fanciful spectacle soar and glow. Ecstasy and absurdity join clammy hands.

Prom 7, Dido and Aeneas, La Nuova Musica review - bold and original from the start

★★★★ PROM 7, DIDO AND AENEAS, LA NUOVA MUSICA Bold and original from the start

Levity as well as sadness from David Bates' ensemble, searing intensity from Alice Coote

How do you celebrate one of epic poetry’s richest female characters, a queen renowned across the Middle East and North Africa for being as politically powerful as she was magnetic? For Nahum Tate, the librettist for Dido and Aeneas, the curious answer is to push aside Dido’s achievements as a ruler and city builder and replace Virgil’s stirring metaphor for her plight with something, well, a little tamer.

La donna del lago, Buxton International Festival 2022 review - Rossini’s romanticism for today

★★★★ LA DONNA DEL LAGO, BUXTON FESTIVAL 2022 Rossini’s romanticism for today

A taut and tension-filled presentation with classy casting

Buxton International Festival’s opera scene is clearly back on track for 2022, and its most substantial production a taut and tension-filled presentation of Rossini’s La Donna del Lago.

The Turn of the Screw, Garsington Opera review - terrors and tragedy

★★★★★ THE TURN OF THE SCREW, GARSINGTON OPERA Terrors and tragedy

All-round intensity in Britten’s suppurating take on Henry James's ghost story

After the long interval, as darkness falls, the screw turns in this Garsington revival more woundingly than any I can remember for Britten's most concentrated masterpiece. Evil chords, trills, cadenzas and silences from the 13 superb Philharmonia players conducted by Mark Wigglesworth duly terrorise; Verity Wingate as the Governess to two orphaned children in a house which seems haunted by their former elders really does seem possessed.

Alcina, Glyndebourne review - Handel on the strand

★★★★ ALCINA, GLYNDEBOURNE High quality singing and playing on a dubiously coloured stage

High quality singing and playing on a dubiously coloured stage

Reviewing the Grange Festival production of Tamerlano the other day, I noted the difficulty Handel poses the modern director with his byzantine plots and often ludicrous love tangles, expressed through music of surpassing brilliance but mostly stereotyped forms. But at least Tamerlano is a comprehensible story with its feet planted firmly in a sort of reality.