Peter Grimes, Royal Opera review - impressive, not quite devastating

★★★★ PETER GRIMES, ROYAL OPERA Impressive, not quite devastating

Handsomely sung, played and staged, this production just misses the heart of darkness

"Why does he have to sentimentalise this piece?", Britten is reported by former Royal Opera director John Tooley to have said of Jon Vickers as Peter Grimes the tormented fisherman, so very different from the composer's life partner and creator of the role Peter Pears. Britten didn't qualify his disappointment by stating what for most of us is obvious: Vickers was one of the great tenor voices, and his latest successor in the role, Allan Clayton, is heading for that kind of status too.

The Telephone / Miss Fortune, Guildhall School review - brilliantly-executed double bill

★★★★ THE TELEPHONE / MISS FORTUNE, GUILDHALL SCHOOL Brilliantly-executed double bill

Gian Carlo Menotti and Judith Weir conjoined by superlative young talent

Serendipity, rather than the fate which clings to the protagonist of Judith Weir’s Miss Fortune, led me to catch the last night of a double-cast spectacular at the Guildhall School of Music and Drama. What a tonic to find a top-notch young cast and orchestra working their disciplined socks off for conductor Dominic Wheeler and director Martin Lloyd-Evans after the dog’s dinner of English Touring Opera’s Rimsky-Korsakov on Saturday.

The Golden Cockerel, English Touring Opera review - no crowing over this henhouse

★★ THE GOLDEN COCKEREL, ETO It’s a turkey, but Rimsky-Korsakov is not to blame

It’s a turkey, but Rimsky-Korsakov is not to blame

A plea to anyone who was seeing Rimsky-Korsakov’s last opera for the first time at the Hackney Empire: please don’t give up on ever seeing or listening to it again, as some I spoke to afterwards said they just had. I promise you, the fault lies in this production, though not for the most part in the singing.

Rigoletto, Royal Opera review - second time lucky

Oliver Mears’ production, new in September, now has a compelling jester and master

Two Royal Opera staples, Verdi's La traviata and Puccini’s Tosca, now come round with too much frequency for critical coverage. It looks like Director of Opera Oliver Mears’ Rigoletto will do the same. Yet the production’s September 2021 debut was clouded by routine performances from its protagonist baritone and tenor Duke of Mantua, so a second visit was due to see if fresh casting might make a difference.

The Cunning Little Vixen, English National Opera review - half-realised men and beasts

★★★ THE CUNNING LITTLE VIXEN, ENGLISH NATIONAL OPERA Lack of pace and focus can’t sink Janáček’s paean to the natural order

Lack of pace and focus can’t sink Janáček’s paean to the natural order

Nature in the form of Storm Eunice stopped this Cunning Little Vixen in her tracks on Friday evening. ENO shrugged off the cancellation and rescheduled for Sunday afternoon. And here we were, getting the essential message that humans must reach an accommodation with the natural world or die in despair. So much for a cute animal fable.

Alcina, Opera North review - flat update redeemed by excellent vocal performances

★★★ ALCINA, OPERA NORTH Flat update redeemed by excellent vocal performances

Musically enjoyable but visually prosaic staging, low on magic

This new production of Handel’s Alcina opens well, with no preamble, the protagonists’ arrival on the island inhabited by the titular sorceress suggested by footage of rushing water projected onto the backdrop. This is billed as Opera North’s first sustainable production, the costumes, furniture and props all second-hand.