Prom 13 review: Rana, BBCSO, Davis – Malcolm Sargent tribute lacks punch

★★★ PROM 13: RANA, BBCSO, DAVIS Historical recreation of 500th Prom short of sparkle until Britten finale

Historical recreation of 500th Prom short of sparkle until Britten finale

Ten days ago I reviewed the First Night of the 2017 Proms. Last night I was back at the Royal Albert Hall to hear the First Night of the 1966 Proms. This time-capsule experience was courtesy of a re-enactment of Sir Malcolm Sargent’s 500th Prom, in what turned out to be his final season. It gave an idea of Sargent’s musical tastes – middle-of-the-road classics and English music – and, in places, of his famously audience-pleasing conducting style.

Prom 7 review: Weilerstein, BBCSO, Weilerstein - new cello concerto enthrals

Controlled performances struggle to find their release in this striking programme

It’s at times like this that I give thanks for the Proms. Who else would (or could) have put together a programme pairing Berlioz’s Symphonie Fantastique with an 18th-century sonic fantasy, or topped it off with a substantial UK premiere? A bit bonkers on the page, it remained so in performance.

Prom 1 review: Levit, BBCSO, Gardner - fizzing Adams finally ignites mixed First Night

★★★★ PROM 1: LEVIT, BBCSO, GARDNER Fizzing Adams finally ignites mixed First Night

Controlled premiere and subdued Beethoven redeemed by a choral blockbuster

The ideal First Night of the Proms sets the tone for the season, perhaps flagging up some of the themes to be followed up later, offering a blend of novelty and familiarity, and preferably ending with a roof-raising choral blockbuster. This programme successfully ticked those boxes, but took until the second half to really catch light.

Gurrelieder, Hallé, BBCPO, Elder, Bridgewater Hall, Manchester

★★★★★ GURRELIEDER, HALLE, BBCPO, ELDER, BRIDGEWATER HALL, MANCHESTER Super-orchestra and choirs deliver Schoenberg's affirmation of the victory of love

Super-orchestra and choirs deliver Schoenberg's affirmation of the victory of love

It may not have had the symbolism of the Ariana Grande concert just down the road, but in its own way the joint Hallé/BBC Philharmonic performance of Schoenberg’s Gurrelieder said as much about Manchester as the rock jamboree did.

Total Immersion: Edgard Varèse, Barbican

★★★★ TOTAL IMMERSION: EDGAR VARESE, BARBICAN Patriarch of the avant-garde still packs a punch

Patriarch of the avant-garde still packs a punch

Made from girders, say the brewers of an infamous Scottish fizzy drink. If you could siphon the music of Edgard Varèse into a can, that’s what it would taste like. Blunt, acrid, inimitable, fizzing with closely guarded, possibly unpleasant ingredients. The danger was that exposure to his entire output in one day would prove no more palatable than chugging through a two-litre bottle of Irn-Bru.

Doctor Atomic, BBCSO, Adams, Barbican

★★★★ DOCTOR ATOMIC, BBCSO, ADAMS, BARBICAN Gerald Finley reprises his tormented nuclear scientist in electrifying company

Gerald Finley reprises his tormented nuclear scientist in electrifying company

Bomb-dropping is the new black again in Trump's dysfunctional America. Awareness of that contributed to the crackling cloud of dynamic dread hanging over last night's concert staging of John Adams's opera-oratorio - my description, not his - about the July 1945 desert testing of the plutonium bomb under the supervision of self-divided Robert Oppenheimer, an American Faust.

Dvořák Requiem, BBC Symphony Chorus and Orchestra, Bělohlávek, Barbican

★★★★ DVORAK REQUIEM, BBC SYMPHONY CHORUS AND ORCHESTRA, BELOHLAVEK, BARBICAN Fascinating, desolate, fragmentary at first, this setting eventually hits the heights

Fascinating, desolate, fragmentary at first, this setting eventually hits the heights

Not your usual blockbuster for Holy Week, this. In other words, neither of the Bach Passions but a Requiem, and not  these days, at any rate  one of the more often-performed ones (it's not among the 79 works listed in The BBC Proms Guide to Great Choral Works).

BBC Singers, BBCSO, Oramo, Barbican

Electrifying Sibelius, sea journeys with crazy dancing by Nielsen and Glanert

It's official: if you want to be guaranteed an infallible musical adrenalin boost in London, you can always be sure to find it with Finnish conductor Sakari Oramo and his BBC Symphony Orchestra. And it's not just a question of splashy excitement: Oramo is a rigorous rehearser. Detlev Glanert's fiendish new tone poem Megaris would not have been half as vivid or pleasurable without extraordinary preparation.