Prom 60: Ax, Vienna Philharmonic, Haitink review - moving mountains at 90

RIP BERNARD HAITINK (1929-2021) The last UK concert, a Prom with the Vienna Philharmonic

Time becomes perfectly-managed space in a great conductor's official UK finale

His movements are minimal (perhaps they always were). A more intense flick of the baton, a sudden wider sweep of the expressive left hand, can help quicken a tempo, draw extra firepower from the players, but Bernard Haitink's conducting is still the most unforced and, well, musicianly, in the world.

Prom 59: Benvenuto Cellini, Monteverdi Choir, ORR, Gardiner review - don't stop the carnival

★★★★★ PROM 59: BENVENUTO CELLINI, ORR, GARDINER  Don't stop the carnival

The best and sharpest possible celebration of the Berlioz anniversary year

So we never got the ultimate Proms spectacular, the four brass bands at the points of the Albert Hall compass for Berlioz's Grande Messe des Morts, in the composer's 150th anniversary year.

Prom 55: Jephtha, SCO & Chorus, Egarr review - shock of the new in sacrificial oratorio

★★★★ PROM 55: JEPHTHA, SCO & CHORUS, EGARR Shock of the new in sacrificial oratorio

Handel's searing response to Old Testament horror strikes afresh

Human sacrifice has a disconcerting and wonderful effect upon great composers, above all when it involves the supremely queasy issue of a father vowing to offer up his child: think of Britten with Abraham and Isaac, Mozart with Idomeneo and Idamante, Gluck with Agamemnon and Iphigenia, and here Handel with Jephtha and Iphis in his last oratorio.

Prom 53: Connolly, Gregory, Tappan, BBCSO & Chorus, Davis review - citizens of the world unite

★★★★ PROM 53: CONNOLLY, GREGORY, TAPPAN, BBCSO, DAVIS Citizens of the world unite

Elgar, Vaughan Williams and Hugh Wood transcend national boundaries

Let's be clear: this was a Prom of world-class works by English composers, not a conservative concert of English music. Politically speaking, Elgar was one of the few on the right, but how different inwardly, speaking through the poet Arthur O’Shaughnessy and singing with his own reminiscences in The Music Makers of timeless art that outlives the fall of empires and individual fates.

Prom 51: Die Zauberflöte, Glyndebourne review - smooth classic without depth

★★★★ PROM 51: DIE ZAUBERFLÖTE, GLYNDEBOURNE Smooth classic without depth

Imported gags work when comedy's intended but get in the way of seriously good singing

Can we go back to an older Glyndebourne-at-the-Proms vintage, where the chosen production was merely sketched out with variations suited to the venue, and performed in whatever evening dress might be appropriate?

Prom 47: Schönheit, Leipzig Gewandhaus, Nelsons review - Bruckner doesn’t quite take flight

★★★★ PROM 47: SCHONHEIT, LEIPZIG GEWANDHAUS, NELSONS Bruckner doesn’t quite take flight

Ravishing sounds from thoroughbred Germans, undermined by sluggish tempos

After Thursday night’s concert I celebrated the Proms’ exploration of unfamiliar repertoire via the CBSO. The following evening saw the festival diving back into mainstream repertoire – as it must also do – conducted by the CBSO’s previous music director.

Edinburgh International Festival 2019: Bach's Multiple Concertos/ Manon Lescaut reviews - dancing harpsichords, perfect Puccini

EDINBURGH INTERNATIONAL FESTIVAL 2019: BACH'S MULTIPLE CONCERTOS / MANON LESCAUT Dancing harpsichords, perfect Puccini

A day of pleasure and pain crowned by Sondra Radvanovsky and Donald Runnicles

Puccini's and Abbé Prévost's glitter-seduced Manon Lescaut might have been inclined to linger longer in the salon of dirty old man Geronte if he'd served her up not his own madrigals but Bach's music for various harpsichords and ensemble.

Prom 46: Kanneh-Mason, CBSO, Gražinytė-Tyla review - brilliant programme, brilliant playing

★★★★★ PROM 46: KANNEH-MASON, CBSO, GRAŽINYTĖ-TYLA Brilliant programme, brilliant playing

Blend of familiar Elgar with undervalued Weinberg shows the Proms at its best

Let us never tire of singing the praises of the Proms, nor ever take them for granted. For two months concerts, many of which would be the highlight of any ‘normal’ week, keep coming night after night. And for all that it is a critic’s job to comment in detail and find fault where necessary, it is also helpful sometimes to step back and say: the Proms is an astonishing festival which we should be grateful to have.

Prom 44: Finley, LSO & Chorus, Orfeó Català, Rattle review - lurid inter-war triptych

★★★★ PROM 44: FINLEY, LSO & CHORUS, ORFEÓ CATALÀ, RATTLE Lurid inter-war triptych

Less could sometimes have been more in blockbusters by Varèse and Walton

So the Proms ignored the Berlioz anniversary challenge to perform his Requiem and serve up four brass bands at the points of the Albert Hall compass.

Prom 43: Haefliger, BBCSO & Chorus, Oramo review – the frisson of the new

Two exciting premieres and a valuable old chestnut in an uplifting evening

Time was, not long ago, when the very word “premiere” was enough to ensure a sizeable smattering of red plush holes in the Royal Albert Hall audience. It seemed people did not want to risk attending new works for fear they would sound ghastly. Any artform depends for its lifeblood on strong new creations and an audience for them; so it is excellent that this concert was the second in a matter of days in which the place was packed out for a Prom including brand-new pieces.