BBC Proms 2022 - silence after Mass

BBC PROMS 2022 No official Last Night, for the first time ever, but it's been an extraordinary season

No official Last Night, for the first time ever, but it's been an extraordinary season

So John Eliot Gardiner’s fire- and-air way with Beethoven’s Missa Solemnis turned out to be the last night of the Proms. Just as I was about to cycle to the Royal Albert Hall for the first of the Philadelphia Orchestra’s two Proms the following evening, a notice came through: following the news of the Queen’s death at 6pm, the evening’s event had been cancelled.

Prom 69, Beethoven's Missa Solemnis, Monteverdi Choir, ORR, Gardiner review - shock, fervour and total focus

★★★★★ PROM 69, BEETHOVEN'S MISSA SOLEMNIS, MONTEVERDI CHOIR, ORR, GARDINER A crazy masterpiece cuts like a knife through Albert Hall haze

A crazy masterpiece cuts like a knife through Albert Hall haze

Back in 1990, John Eliot Gardiner with his Monteverdi Choir, English Baroque Soloists and world-class singers set the South Bank alight with revelatory concert performances of Mozart’s Idomeneo and La clemenza di Tito. Now he's done it again for an even quirkier masterpiece, burning away any Albert Hall mists with the best possible voices and an “Orchestre” which can be called “Révolutionnaire” but decidedly not “Romantique” when it comes to the Missa Solemnis.

Prom 64, Beethoven's Last Three Piano Sonatas, Schiff review - morning glory

★★★★★ PROM 64, BEETHOVEN'S LAST THREE PIANO SONATAS, SCHIFF Morning glory

A tasteful but forceful journey

In more ways than one, Beethoven’s last piano sonatas can make the listener lose track of time. It’s not just the delirious freedom with rhythm, accents, signatures and note-values that the ageing, afflicted composer of Op. 109, 110 and 111 unleashes in these epoch-shifting works. Played with as much consummate, fuss-free art as Sir András Schiff brings to them, the unfolding drama of this revolutionary trio can truly seem to stop the clock.

Prom 62, Mahler's Seventh Symphony, Berlin Philharmonic, Petrenko review - hallucinogenic night's journey into day

★★★★★ PROM 62, MAHLER'S SEVENTH SYMPHONY, BERLIN PHILHARMONIC, PETRENKO Orchestral playing and winged conducting simply don't get better than this

Orchestral playing and winged conducting simply don't get better than this

Match the most multi-timbred, flexible orchestra in the world with the iridescent peak of symphonic mastery, and you have an assured winner of a Prom. Yet not even Kirill Petrenko’s previous London performance of Mahler’s Seventh with the Bavarian State Orchestra, nor the brilliance of his two previous Proms with the Berlin Philharmonic, had prepared me for the miracle he achieved last night with players who will clearly do anything for him.

Prom 61, Cabell, Chineke! Voices and Orchestra, Edusei review - a thrilling, fiercely rational Beethoven 9

★★★★ PROM 61, CABELL, CHINEKE!, EDUSEI A thrilling, fiercely rational Beethoven 9

Crystalline clarity, and ravishing vocals from BBC Cardiff Singer of the World

Last night’s riveting, meticulous account of Beethoven’s Ninth from the Chineke! Orchestra was as daring in its restraint as it was thrillingly revelatory. Right from the subtle shimmer of the first movement’s opening cascades it was clear that this interpretation had put each bar under the microscope and found it teeming with new life.

Prom 59, The Dream of Gerontius, Clayton, Barton, Platt, LPO, Gardner review - most sure in all its ways

★★★★ PROM 59, THE DREAM OF GERONTIUS, CLAYTON, BARTON, PLATT, LPO, GARDNER Elgar’s time-become-space odyssey floats and soars in the perfect venue

Elgar’s time-become-space odyssey floats and soars in the perfect venue

Asked which work suits capricious Albert Hall acoustics best, I’d say Elgar’s The Dream of Gerontius, partly due to the choral billows – this year there’s been an extra thrill about massed choirs – but also because the Kensington colosseum haloes this spiritual journey of a soul. Best singer in the space? Based on years of Proms experience, surely the palm should go to tenor Allan Clayton, ringing of tone and so clear in diction that you can hear every word.

Prom 57, Bach Mass in B Minor, OAE, Butt review - passion and precision

Period accents combine with vocal splendour in Bach's late-career epic

A strong team of musical chefs can blend and spice Bach’s mighty Mass in B Minor in a variety of different ways, and still prepare a feast to savour. We don’t know exactly why Bach felt compelled to bundle his decades of genius into this late portmanteau showcase, only that he did – and that its credible interpretations can span contrasting views.

Prom 49, Mahler's 'Resurrection' Symphony, Connolly, Alder, LSO, Rattle review - a long and grand goodbye

★★★★★ PROM 49, MAHLER'S 'RESURRECTION' SYMPHONY, CONNOLLY, ALDER, LSO, RATTLE A long and grand goodbye

A great Mahlerian marks his signature work with a thrilling flourish

Long goodbyes don’t get grander, warmer or more passionate than this. Sir Simon Rattle began his farewell season with the London Symphony Orchestra with a Proms performance of Mahler’s Second, “Resurrection” Symphony – the mighty work that has waymarked the major moves of his career.

Prom 43, Solomon, The English Concert, Jeannin review - a Handelian box of delights

★★★★ PROM 43, SOLOMON, THE ENGLISH CONCERT, JEANNIN A Handelian box of delights

Unexpected drama, and tenderness, amid a grand pageant

Like many people, I grew up with cut-and-paste Handel. It could take decades before you found out where that shiny snippet of a childhood earworm truly belonged.

Prom 42, Lisiecki, BBC Scottish SO, Dausgaard review - concerto partnership made in heaven

★★★★ PROM 42, LISIECKI, BBCSSO, DAUSGAARD Concerto partnership made in heaven

Lisiecki electrifies in Beethoven, but well-prepared Nielsen doesn’t quite storm the heights

Sibelius or Nielsen symphonies? Last night, with the Finn’s Seventh in the first half and the Dane’s “Inextinguishable” (No. 4) in the second, choice should have been impossible. Francesco Piemontesi or Jan Lisiecki? I’d have been equally happy with either pianist, but there we had no option: PIemontesi was unwell and the Canadian took over. The Beethoven Fourth Piano Concerto we heard as a result was fresh and electifying.