Bernheim, Finley, LSO, Pappano, Barbican review - top Italians in second gear

Keenly urged playing and singing, but this was Verdi and Puccini lite

Would Verdi and Puccini have composed more non-operatic music, had they thrived in a musical culture different to Italy's? Hard to say. What we do know is that they both became absolute masters of orchestration – Puccini rather quicker than Verdi, living as he did in an entirely post-Wagnerian era.

Total Immersion: Ligeti, Barbican review - exploring a 20th-century master mind

★★★★ TOTAL IMMERSION: LIGETI, BARBICAN Superb interpretations from BBC forces

Superb interpretations from BBC forces in a day dedicated to the great Hungarian

A day devoted entirely to the life and work of György Ligeti celebrated this composer’s remarkable oeuvre through a sequence programme of film, talks and concerts of his music.

Monteverdi Vespers, The Sixteen, Christophers, Cadogan Hall review – majesty on a modest scale

★★★ MONTEVERDI VESPERS, THE SIXTEEN, CHRISTOPHERS Majesty on a modest scale

Well-established team brings a passion for clarity and colour

The Monteverdi Vespers are usually a grand affair, but Harry Christophers showed they can work just as well on a smaller scale. Cadogan Hall has a dry acoustic, at least compared to St Mark’s Basilica, so there is little opportunity for billowing waves of choral declamation, echoing through the galleries. Instead, Christophers aims for focus and clarity, with swift tempos and a modest dynamic range.

La Damnation de Faust, Hallé, Elder, Bridgewater Hall, Manchester review - 'concert opera' indeed

Vivid choral and orchestral sounds in a thrilling account of Berlioz masterpiece

Berlioz called it a "concert opera". His telling of the Faust story is in scenes and highly theatrical, but a bit of a challenge to put on in the theatre, with its marching armies, floating sylphs, dancing will-o’-the-wisps and galloping horses. It seems he expected it to be a kind of giant cantata, and that’s the way the Hallé and Sir Mark Elder perform it.

Bach B minor Mass, BBCSO, Butt, Barbican review - large-scale losses and a few gains

★★★ BACH B MINOR MASS, BBCSO, BUTT, BARBICAN Large-scale losses, a few gains

Stylish principles applied to a big chorus and modern instruments with limited success

Practitioners of musical authenticity and scholarly research, so guarded and protective of their territory in the early days, now like to spread the love around.

Timothy Day: I Saw Eternity the Other Night review - heavenly harmony, earthly discord

★★★★★ TIMOTHY DAY: I SAW ETERNITY THE OTHER NIGHT Making the English choral style

How mavericks and sceptics made the English choral style

In 1955, Sylvia Plath attended the Advent Carol Service at King’s College in Cambridge. Like countless other visitors, listeners and viewers before and since, she was entranced by “the tall chapel, with its cobweb lace of fan-vaulting” lit by “myriads of flickering candles”, and above all by the “clear bell-like” voices of the choristers, with their “utterly pure and crystal notes”. The American poet told her mother in a letter that “I never have been so moved in my life”.

L'enfance du Christ, BBCSO, Gardner, Barbican review - Berlioz's kindest wonder

★★★★★ BERLIOZ'S L'ENFANCE DU CHRIST, BARBICAN Perfect performance now on BBC iPlayer

Grace attained in a musical miracle of restraint and its dedicated performance

Like the fountains that sprang up in the desert during the Holy Family's flight into Egypt - according to a charming episode in the Gospel of Pseudo-Matthew - Berlioz's new-found creativity in the 1850s flowed from a couple of bars of organ music he inscribed in a friend's visitors book.

Epiphoni Consort, Reader, St Paul's Covent Garden review - historical drama with seasonal spirit

★★★★★ EPIPHONI CONSORT, READER, ST PAUL'S Historical drama with seasonal spirit

Musical enactment of the 1914 Christmas Truce showcases superb choral singing

Like a supermarket "Christmas Dinner" sandwich, cramming the delights of a full festive lunch into every bite, Epiphoni Consort’s The Christmas Truce was at once historical play, choral concert and carol service, and so wonderfully enjoyable I didn’t want it to end.

Kolesnikov, BBCSO, Brabbins, Barbican review - rethought masterpiece, stolid rarity

★★★★ KOLESNIKOV, BBCSO, BRABBINS, BARBICAN Rethought masterpiece, stolid rarity

Uninspired Ethel Smyth Mass follows standing ovation for vivacious Tchaikovsky

Forget the latest International Tchaikovsky Competition winner (I almost have; only a dim memory of Dmitry Masleev's playing the notes in the obligatory First Piano Concerto, and nothing else, remains from an Istanbul performance). Had Pavel Kolesnikov been competing and given a performance like the one he did last night, there'd have been a riot had he not won.