Black Lake, Series 2 Finale, BBC Four review - Swedish chiller fails to thrill

★★  BLACK LAKE, SERIES 2 FINALE BBC Four's Swedish chiller fails to thrill

After an intriguing start, spooky sequel goes nowhere fast

A bunch of young-ish people stuck in a rambling house in the middle of nowhere, a hatchet-faced senior citizen guarding a hoard of murky secrets, assorted missing persons, a derelict sanatorium, lots of creepy noises and no telephones… hang on, isn’t that exactly the same formula as in the first series of Black Lake?

The Dead Room, BBC Four review - ghosts at the microphone

★★★★ THE DEAD ROOM, BBC FOUR Simon Callow shines in Mark Gatiss's supernatural tale

Simon Callow shines in Mark Gatiss's supernatural tale

Fired by the spirit of the MR James ghost stories which used to be a Christmas staple on the BBC, Mark Gatiss conceived this amusing bonne bouche as both a seasonal chiller and a nod to the ghost of broadcasting past. In passing, he also managed to shoehorn in a survey of changes in social and sexual mores which have occurred over the last 40 years.

Barbra Streisand: Becoming an Icon 1942-1984, BBC Four review - the way she was

BARBRA STREISAND: BECOMING AN ICON 1942-1984, BBC FOUR The diva's journey from Brooklyn to Broadway and beyond

The diva's journey from Brooklyn to Broadway and beyond

Perhaps belatedly prompted by the release of Barbra Streisand’s new album Walls, the worst-selling disc in her 55 years with Columbia Records, this documentary was an uncritical celebration of Babs’s brilliant career from her first stage appearances in the late Fifties to the joys of Hello, Dolly!, The Way We Were and Yentl.

WW1: The Last Tommies, BBC Four review - Great War stories

★★★★★ WW1: THE LAST TOMMIES, BBC FOUR Remarkable oral history

Centrepiece of the BBC's World War One season makes for remarkable oral history

“Why should I go out and kill somebody I never knew? There was no reason at all in it in my way of thinking.” Britain’s very last Tommy was Harry Patch, born in 1898, conscripted in 1916 and still alive on his 111th birthday in 2009. He was one of the witnesses in The Last Tommies, BBC Four’s remarkable work of oral history.

Barneys, Books and Bust Ups, BBC Four review - the Booker Prize at 50

The award's half-century has brought scandals aplenty, welcome publicity pay-offs, too

You had to keep your eyes skinned. Was that Iris Murdoch or AS Byatt, Kingsley Amis or John Banville, Margaret Atwood or Val McDermid – maybe, even, Joanna Lumley? Tables as far as the eye can see, dressed with white tablecloths and crowded with wine glasses. A glittering banquet with oceans of booze, it seems, mostly champagne, lots of hugging, kissing, shouting and clouds of gossip, all accompanied by television cameras.

Classic Albums: Amy Winehouse - Back to Black, BBC Four review - suffering turned into song

★★★★ CLASSIC ALBUMS: AMY WINEHOUSE – BACK TO BLACK, BBC FOUR How the singer's second album made musical gold out of the blues

How the singer's second album made musical gold out of the blues

Formats are second nature to TV: the BBC and Eagle Rock’s Classic Albums will run and run. Like all formats, there’s always the risk that the medium becomes the message, and content suffers under the weight of form. But Classic Albums at least avoids the BBC’s slavish reliance on presenters, and makes possible programmes that draw the viewer in closer than when everything is mediated by the wall-to wall ego of an expert or celeb.

Murder in Soho: Who Killed Freddie Mills?, BBC Four review - cold case solved?

★★★ MURDER IN SOHO: WHO KILLED FREDDIE MILLS? BBC FOUR Feature-length enquiry attempts to clear up an infamous mystery

Feature-length enquiry attempts to clear up an infamous mystery

They don’t make boxers like Freddie Mills any more. A granite lump of grinning charisma, he had a brow and jawline straight from a kids’ cartoon and, despite his humble origins and thuggish contours, a charmingly well-to-do voice. Mills was light heavyweight world champ for a time, then drifted into showbiz and, eventually, running a nightclub in Soho. Then he died in sudden and mysterious circumstances.