Gerhardt, BBC Philharmonic, Gernon, Bridgewater Hall, Manchester review - calm and clear conducting

★★★★ GERHARDT, BBC PHILHARMONIC, GERNON, MANCHESTER Calm & clear conducting

Maybe not perfect, but when things worked, they worked beautifully

Ben Gernon’s calm and clear way of conducting an orchestra (something he once told me he’d observed in the work of his mentor, Colin Davis) is good to watch and, I would guess, welcomed by those he directs. Since his time with the BBC Philharmonic as principal guest conductor (2017-2020) he’s been a welcome visitor to them in Manchester and Salford, and this programme pulled a good crowd and was indeed very rewarding.

Benedetti, Hallé, Elder, Bridgewater Hall, Manchester review - essays in transparency

★★★★ BENEDETTI, HALLE, ELDER, BRIDGEWATER HALL Essays in transparency

Taking Szymanowski's Second Violin Concerto to a near-capacity house

Nicola Benedetti and Sir Mark Elder are both in the enviable position of being able to take audiences with them into music territory that might scare some away. So it was a gratifyingly near-capacity house that heard Szymanowski’s Second Violin Concerto last night as – on the first occasion they have worked together – they presented it to the Hallé audience.

The Pale Blue Eye review - telltale hearts

Christian Bale's detective and a young Edgar Allan Poe investigate a haunted whodunnit in early America

Edgar Allan Poe fathered the detective genre as well as a school of Gothic horror, and Scott Cooper’s adaptation of Louis Bayard’s 1830-set novel acts as an origin story for the author and the whodunnit.

Newsies, Troubadour Wembley Park Theatre review - bombastic musical let down by its songs

★★★ NEWSIES, TROUBADOUR WEMBLEY PARK Bombastic musical let down by its songs

Backflipping newsboys take on press barons in this hyper-energised UK premiere of the Broadway hit

What do you mean you haven’t heard of the newsboys’ strike of 1899? It’s a classic David and Goliath story: a group of New York kids selling newspapers for Joseph Pulitzer (him of the prize), who take a stand when their boss tries to charge them 20% extra to buy their “papes”.

1899, Netflix review - Atlantic voyage turns into cosmic nightmare

Another mind-bending trip from the creators of 'Dark'

Baran bo Odar and Jantje Friese won delirious acclaim for their previous Netflix series Dark, a labyrinthine and fantastical account of children vanishing from a small German town. Anyone familiar with its baffling events and leaps across different timelines will probably feel at home with 1899, the duo’s similarly mind-bending follow-up.

A Christmas Carol, RSC, Stratford review - family show eases back the terror and winds up the politics

 A CHRISTMAS CAROL, RSC Old favourite finds contemporary relevance in sanitised staging

The RSC Christmas show delivers exactly what it promises

Life is full of coincidences and contradictions. As I was walking to the Royal Shakespeare Theatre, the Chancellor of the Exchequer was on his feet in the House of Commons delivering yet another rebalancing of individual and collective resources. On reading a couple of fine essays in the excellent programme, I saw the acknowledgement of the production’s sponsor, Pragnell.

The English, BBC Two review - Emily Blunt's date with destiny on the prairies

★★★ THE ENGLISH, BBC TWO Emily Blunt's date with destiny on the prairies

Hugo Blick takes on the untamed West

Writer and director Hugo Blick isn’t afraid of getting stuck into some knotty and morally complicated issues, whether it’s Middle Eastern politics (The Honourable Woman) or the Rwandan genocide (Black Earth Rising), but perhaps he wouldn’t be your automatic go-to guy for Westerns. Nevertheless, here he is, giving it some high-plains-drifter in a baleful tale of revenge, violence and twists of fate.

William Boyd: The Romantic review - historical soap opera, anyone?

★★★ WILLIAM BOYD - THE ROMANTIC The author's cradle-to-grave formula wears a little thin

The author's cradle-to-grave formula wears a little thin

Writing in the Edinburgh Review in 1814, Francis Jeffrey began his review of Wordsworth’s The Excursion with a provocative denunciation of romanticism: “This will never do,” he complained. “It bears no doubt the stamp of the author’s heart and fancy; but unfortunately not half so visibly as that of his peculiar system.”