Carmen, Opera North review - humanity and no bull

★★★ CARMEN, OPERA NORTH Humanity and no bull

Lavish comeback to the live stage with a director’s show

Is Bizet’s Carmen all about Carmen? Or Don José and his obsession with her? Or the society that made her what she is? Or all of the above? Inevitably it’s an opera that almost never escapes some Regietheater treatment these days. Director Edward Dick’s take on it is definitely one of those, and tries to tackle as many of the issues as it can.

The Electrical Life of Louis Wain review - visually arresting biopic

★★★ THE ELECTRICAL LIFE OF LOUIS WAIN Visually arresting biopic 

Will Sharpe’s portrayal of the fin-de-siècle cat painter, starring Benedict Cumberbatch, offers a visual spectacle

On its surface, a biopic of a late-Victorian artist starring big British talents including Benedict Cumberbatch, Andrea Riseborough and Claire Foy, sounds like typical awards fare for this time of year. Will Sharpe, best-known for directing the dark TV comedy Flowers (starring Olivia Coleman who is on narrating duties for this film), and drama series Giri/Haji, offers just that.

Rigoletto, Royal Opera review - routine clouds the best in this season opener

★★★ RIGOLETTO, ROYAL OPERA Routine clouds the best in this season opener

Orchestra and chorus pass with flying colours, but tradition weighs heavy elsewhere

Another season, another new production of Verdi’s nastiest masterpiece. For which we should be profoundly grateful after the tribulations of the last 18 months. Yet how quickly elements of the routine can corrode the soul of the spectator, just as fresh, urgent communication can set it alight.

The North Water, BBC Two review - a terrible voyage into the great beyond

★★★★ THE NORTH WATER, BBC TWO A terrible voyage into the great beyond

Director Andrew Haigh brings cinematic heft to this bloody whaling odyssey

It’s perhaps unfortunate that The North Water arrives on BBC Two only a few months after The Terror, since it’s impossible to avoid the parallels between them. They’re set only a few years apart (1859 for The North Water, 1845 for The Terror), both involve doomed voyages into Arctic waters, and each of them gets darker and bloodier as it depicts man’s inhumanity to man (and not just man) and the encroaching horror of a heart of darkness.

The Barber of Seville, Welsh National Opera review - back to work in an old banger

★★★ THE BARBER OF SEVILLE, WELSH NATIONAL OPERA Back to work in an old banger

Some excellent singing struggling with a weary production and an unhelpful translation

Welcome back, WNO! Yes, emphatically, and with a loud hurrah, which is precisely what the company received, and rightly received, from the somewhat arbitrarily scattered first night Millennium Centre audience for their opening revival of The Barber of Seville.

Luisa Miller, Glyndebourne review – small-scale tragedy, big emotions

★★★★★ LUISA MILLER, GLYNDEBOURNE Small-scale tragedy, big emotions 

Bold casting includes a sensational main-season debut from soprano Mané Galoyan

“Time-travelling” is how Enrique Mazzola, the superb first conductor of Glyndebourne’s last new production of the main season, described the slow-burn trajectory of Verdi’s semi-masterpiece Luisa Miller in his First Person here on theartsdesk.

Mr and Mrs Nobody, Jermyn Street Theatre review – as comfortable as afternoon tea with jam puffs

★★★ MR AND MRS NOBODY, JERMYN STREET THEATRE As comfortable as afternoon tea with jam puffs

Edward Baker-Duly seems to have sprung fully formed from the pages of 'Punch'

If you’re looking for a distraction from the apocalyptic headlines that seem to be the norm right now, then it may appeal to descend into the pleasantly air-conditioned surroundings of Jermyn Street Theatre and take a trip to 1888.

The Barber of Seville, Clonter Opera Theatre review - youthful enthusiasm triumphs

★★★★ THE BARBER OF SEVILLE, CLONTER OPERA Youthful enthusiasm triumphs

Cheshire opera farm proves its resourcefulness again

Harnessing the enthusiasm of youth has always been what Clonter Opera, on a farm in Cheshire, is about with its summer productions. The house is relatively small (there’s always a reduced orchestration as accompaniment), and the idea is that promising young voices can get a chance to try their luck with an audience and learn in the process.

Blu-ray: Flowers of Shanghai

★★★★ FLOWERS OF SHANGHAI Taiwanese director Hsiao-hsien at his most dazzling

Hsiao-hsien's period piece is the director at his most dazzling

Rounding out a decade of personal success – beginning with his Cannes Jury Prize-winning The Puppetmaster (1993), followed by a best director award for Good Men, Good Women (1995) – the Taiwanese director Hou Hsiao-hsien travelled to the Japanese harbour city of Hirado as part of his research for Flowers of Shanghai (1998).