Connolly, BBC Philharmonic, Storgårds, Bridgewater Hall, Manchester review - beginning with a fanfare

★★★★ CONNOLLY, BBC PHILHARMONIC, STORGARDS, BRIDGEWATER HALL Beginning with a fanfare

Things both rich and rare in the season opener

The opening concert of a new season often tends to be a statement of intent, and this was John Storgårds’ opener of the first full season since he was appointed chief conductor of the BBC Philharmonic. He’s hardly a newcomer to them, though, since he has been principal guest conductor (latterly chief guest) for nearly 12 years now. The mutual respect and trust are clear.

This programme, however, began with a fanfare and continued with something rich and something rare (not in that order).

Falstaff, Opera North review - going green and having fun

★★★★★ FALSTAFF, OPERA NORTH Going green and having fun

Verdi’s comic masterpiece with a retro feel of its own

There’s a charmingly retro feel to Opera North’s new Falstaff, which comes from it being done as part of their new “green”, i.e. ecologically conscious, season.

Leslie Travers’ set is made of bits from other productions and – most notably – shows Falstaff’s home as a worn-out little 1970s caravan, actually found unwanted in the grounds of a pub on the north side of Leeds by resourceful operatic bargain hunters.

Zadie Smith: The Fraud review - the trials we inherit

★★★★ ZADIE SMITH: THE FRAUD In her first foray into historical fiction, Smith pens a prescient and well-researched retelling

In her first foray into historical fiction, Smith pens a prescient and well-researched retelling

Zadie Smith’s latest novel, The Fraud, is her first venture into historical fiction – a fiction based on a factual trial and a real, forgotten Victorian author. While the premise is interesting and the story is engaging in itself, this book perhaps doesn’t quite feel as readable as her past novels – though, admittedly, that is a high bar.

theartsdesk at the Buxton International Festival - bel canto in the High Peak

★★★★ BUXTON INTERNATIONAL FESTIVAL Bel canto in the High Peak

Re-thought story in Bellini comedy is the festival highspot

Bellini’s La Sonnambula is the highspot of a four-show lyric theatre bill at the Buxton International Festival this year, and demonstrates again how beautifully suited the small Matcham opera house in the High Peak is to mid-19th century bel canto repertoire.

Modest, Kiln Theatre review - tale of Victorian would-be trailblazer fails and succeeds

★★ MODEST, KILN THEATRE A trans and queer celebration, but not a very good play 

Art, songs and a cabaret (indeed, Cabaret) vibe, but the story goes nowhere

Whether you believe that Ellen Brammar’s play, Modest, newly arrived in London from Hull Truck Theatre, succeeds or not, rather depends on your criteria for evaluating theatre.

Don Carlo, Royal Opera review - Lise Davidsen soars above routine

★★★ DON CARLO, ROYAL OPERA Lise Davidsen soars above routine

Fine voices aren't quite enough in Verdi's epic royal tragedy

Not a good start. The tenor (Brian Jagde) walks downstage and sings loudly, if securely, to the audience: hardly a characterisation of an idealistic young Infante meditating on love. The next voice, the Page’s, is barely heard (Ella Taylor gets better). Then we have The Presence: Lise Davidsen, who you know is Elisabeth de Valois in the only carefree mode she’s to experience throughout the opera.

Il trovatore, Royal Opera review - heaven and hell

★★★ IL TROVATORE, ROYAL OPERA Cod-medieval heaven and hell showcasing strong cast

Everyone delivers, but one day Verdi's hit-and-miss melodrama will get the right staging

The trouble with Trovatore, Verdi’s sometimes barrel-organish, slightly middle-aged troubadour, isn’t so much the silly shocker of a plot, triggered by a gypsy so crazed with vengeance that she throws her own baby on a bonfire by mistake, as the choppy dramatic line, so hard to thread. Under the circumstance, Adele Thomas’s medieval-hell production could have been a lot worse, and the vocal quality is there throughout under Antonio Pappano’s watchful guidance.

Götterdämmerung, Longborough Festival review - from the hieratic to the mundane and back

★★★★ GÖTTERDÄMMERUNG, LONGBOROUGH From the hieratic to the mundane and back

Wagner's gallon in a pint pot with mixed results

Götterdämmerung is not only the grandest of Wagner’s Ring operas, it is also the most varied. Siegfried’s journey down the Rhine transports him in a short quarter-hour from the hieratic world of the Norns and the World Ash to the soap-opera of the Gibichungs and their anxieties about marriage and political standing (opinion polls?).

The Pearl Fishers, Opera North review - focus on the mystery

★★★★ THE PEARL FISHERS, OPERA NORTH ‘Concert staging’ of Bizet’s essay in exoticism

‘Concert staging’ of Bizet’s essay in exoticism has its advantages

The Pearl Fishers is very much a mid-19th century Romantic opera, with a plot that’s basically a love triangle set in an exotic location. Its writers, Michel Carré and Eugène Cormon, were not the greatest of plot inventors, and after hearing the opening scene alone, you might think much the same about the inspiration of the music, beautifully crafted though it is.

Ghosts, Abbey Theatre, Dublin review - creating tension from desolation

★★★★ GHOSTS, ABBEY THEATRE, DUBLIN Creating tension from desolation

Cathy Belton’s devastating economy steers Mark O’Rowe’s quietly stunning Ibsen

Church and law are enemies of promise in Ibsen’s tragedy-without-catharis. You can see why this devastating attack on, among other things, the syphilitic sins of the fathers being visited on the hopeful young created a ruckus in the 1880s. It’s still potent thanks to the characters’ complex reactions to social constraints. Mark O’Rowe’s new version for Landmark Productons at the Abbey is faithful to the essence, while sets and costumes only reinforce modernity in period dress.