Hard Sun, BBC One review - cops versus the end of the world

★★★★ HARD SUN, BBC ONE Sizzling start for Neil Cross's pre-apocalyptic thriller

Sizzling start for Neil Cross's pre-apocalyptic thriller

Fans of Luther will be familiar with writer Neil Cross’s fondness for hideous violence, shocking plot-twists and macabre humour, as well as characterful London locations, and happily they’re all present and correct in this new sci-fi thriller.

Girlfriends, ITV review - Kay Mellor helps the middle-aged

★★★ GIRLFRIENDS, ITV Cheerful new drama high-fives women refusing to be left on the shelf

Cheerful new drama high-fives women refusing to be left on the shelf

You know where you are with Kay Mellor. Somewhere in the north, among a group of people brought together by pregnancy or prison, weight or, as in the case of the recent Love, Lies and Records, work. With Girlfriends (ITV), the common denominator is encroaching age. The drama's three protagonists are all knocking on a bit and wondering if life can possibly be so resoundingly over.

Best of 2017: TV

BEST OF 2017: TV We pick the ones that did and the ones that didn't

The ones that did and the ones that didn't - we pick the good, the bad and the ugly from 2017

Young people will laugh incredulously when you tell them that once upon a time, there was only one television channel in Britain. Now we've lost count, and as even the Queen pointed out in her Christmas broadcast, many of her subjects would now be watching her (no doubt hoping for a walk-on by Meghan Markle) on phones or iPads.

Spiral, Series 6, BBC Four review - grime pays in the City of Light

★★★★ SPIRAL, SERIES 6, BBC FOUR Welcome return of the superior French police drama

Welcome return of the superior French police drama

We’ve seen some “interesting” series filling BBC Four’s celebrated Saturday evening slot recently, which if nothing else have prompted plenty of below-the-line discussion. Happily, we can now turn our backs on all that and hail the return of the ace Paris-based French cop show Spiral.

Eric, Ernie and Me, BBC Four review - he brought them sunshine

★★★★ ERIC, ERNIE AND ME, BBC FOUR The moving story of Morecambe and Wise's scriptwriter Eddie Braben

The moving story of Morecambe and Wise's scriptwriter Eddie Braben, plus a gentle hour with Eric & Ernie's Home Movies

To misquote Marx (Karl, not Groucho), comedy repeats itself, the first time as farce, the second time as a tragedy. The early days of broadcasting bred comedians whose work lives on in the nation’s marrow. But being Frankie Howerd or Kenneth Williams or the Steptoe actors was no laughing matter.

The Miniaturist, BBC One review - a lovely supernatural soap

★★★★ THE MINIATURIST, BBC ONE Jessie Burton's novel is ravishingly visualised with 21st century highlights

Jessie Burton's novel is ravishingly visualised with 21st century highlights

Simon Schama called the Netherlands’ century of success an "embarrassment of riches". The thrust of Jessie Burton’s lavishly hyped debut novel The Miniaturist is that the Dutch felt guilty about their good fortune, and denied themselves the right to enjoy sugar, spice, and all things nice. The money went on surface things, on finery and furniture.

Little Women, BBC One review - life during wartime with the March sisters

★★★ LITTLE WOMEN, BBC ONE Agreeable yet soporific adaptation of Louisa May Alcott's novel

Agreeable yet soporific adaptation of Louisa May Alcott's enduring novel

One of the much-hyped jewels in the crown of the family-friendly BBC holiday season is this new three-episode adaptation of Louisa May Alcott's much loved novel by Heidi Thomas, the writer of Call the Midwife.

Doctor Who: Twice Upon a Time, BBC One review – a defiantly small and personal goodbye

★★★ DOCTOR WHO: TWICE UPON A TIME, BBC ONE Capaldi and Moffat traded thrills for laughter and tears in their flawed but touching finale

Capaldi and Moffat traded thrills for laughter and tears in their flawed but touching finale

And so, with one last speech on the importance of kindness, Peter Capaldi and Steven Moffat bid farewell to the TARDIS. In their final Doctor Who episode, Twice Upon a Time subverted expectations with a small, sweet adventure which valued character above plot.

Maigret in Montmartre, ITV review - dirty deeds in clubland

★★★★ MAIGRET IN MONTMARTRE, ITV Dirty deeds in clubland

The hangdog 'tec returns to the Parisian heart of darkness

Whatever the Waitrose and Morrisons commercials are telling you, as far as TV schedulers are concerned ‘tis the season for murder. Thus a Christmas Maigret has become an instant tradition, with Rowan Atkinson reprising his performance as Georges Simenon’s dolorous detective.

Peaky Blinders, Series 4 Finale, BBC Two review – Tommy faces his reckoning

★★★★ PEAKY BLINDERS, SERIES 4 FINALE, BBC TWO Tommy faces his reckoning

Series four closes with breakneck twists and surprising reflections

Luca Changretta got his just desserts, Alfie Solomons made a last gasp for the quiet life, and Thomas Shelby revealed his true enemy – Peaky Blinders wrapped up another exciting series in a high-octane and neat finale.