Best of 2014: TV

BEST OF 2014: TV Prog Rock, detectives, two world wars and the young Batman were among 2014's highlights

Prog Rock, detectives, two world wars and the young Batman were among 2014's highlights

Apologies in advance to fans of The Missing, The Honourable Woman, The Fall, Game of Thrones or House of Cards, none of which feature in the list below, but might well have done. So might The Good Wife, Ripper Street and Peaky Blinders. The fact is, in our teeming everything-everywhere world now boosted by Netflix, Amazon Instant Video, iTunes, Now TV and many more, whittling a whole year down to a handful of nuggets requires the wisdom of Solomon, the patience of Job, and the devious brain of a superhacker.

Last Tango in Halifax, Series 3, BBC One / Homeland, Series 4 Finale, Channel 4

The past bites back in Halifax, and there's still trouble ahead in 'Homeland'

Back for its third series [***], Sally Wainwright's saga of Yorkshire folk continues to tread a precarious line between syrupy soapfulness and a family drama with sharp little teeth. Its excellent cast helps to carry it over the worst of the soggy bits, and its best moments have a way of catching you unawares. You'd have to guess that it also scores strongly by not being crammed with serial killers, paedophiles and corrupt cops.

Call the Midwife: 2014 Christmas Special, BBC One

CALL THE MIDWIFE: 2014 CHRISTMAS SPECIAL, BBC ONE How Jennifer Worth's midwifery memoirs became embedded in the national psyche

How Jennifer Worth's midwifery memoirs became embedded in the national psyche

The Christmas scoop was the first appearance of the authorial voice, Vanessa Redgrave, playing Jennifer Worth, writing Christmas cards, looking at the photographs of herself with her two midwife friends and plunging us into memory from 2005 to 1959. She tells her husband Philip (Ronald Pickup) with tender affection how different it was, but "once a nurse, always a nurse," he responds. Bookending this episode were her words as she and Philip finished Christmas preparations, that if we are lucky we find love, and even its meaning.

Olive Kitteridge, Sky Atlantic

OLIVE KITTERIDGE, SKY ATLANTIC Frances McDormand excels in superlative four-hour adaptation of small-town American life

Frances McDormand excels in superlative four-hour adaptation of small-town American life

Some of the best films this year have been the longest. The one most likely to be remembered is Richard Linklater’s Boyhood, at a modest enough 165 minutes, followed soon after by Nuri Bilge Ceylan’s Turkish masterpiece Winter Sleep, at a weightier 196. Now, close to year end, along comes Lisa Cholodenko’s Olive Kitteridge, bringing with it a considerable tinge of regret that outside a single theatrical outing at this year’s Venice Film Festival, this HBO miniseries is coming to us only on the small screen. At 232 minutes, no less.

The Fall, BBC Two / Babylon, Channel 4

THE FALL, BBC TWO / BABYLON, CHANNEL FOUR Dark and chilling return of the Belfast killer thriller  

Dark and chilling return of the Belfast killer thriller

The first series of this creepy Belfast-set crime thriller generated a mixture of critical enthusiasm and revulsion for its voyeuristic scenes of the sadistic murder of women. This season two opener [****] didn't give us any more of the latter, but successfully re-established the show's atmosphere of claustrophobic menace. It also probed further into the psychological battle between Gillian Anderson's DS Stella Gibson and Jamie Dornan's low-key but intensely deranged killer, Paul Spector.

The Passing Bells, BBC One

THE PASSING BELLS, BBC ONE The Great War reduced to banal platitudes

The Great War reduced to banal platitudes

We seem to have spent most of 2014 examining the social, political, historical, geographical and military ramifications of the First World War. You would have thought, therefore, that the upcoming Remembrance Sunday commemorations could have been allowed to stand alone, uncluttered by further efforts to explain or dramatise the events of 1914.

Intruders, BBC Two

INTRUDERS, BBC TWO Some of it looks familiar, but there's enough weirdness to keep you watching

Some of it looks familiar, but there's enough weirdness to keep you watching

"Baffling paranormal thriller" is your drive-thru soundbite to describe Intruders, but despite a lingering threat of genre-cliché, it holds your attention with a very capable cast and some stylish cinematography. The action is set in Washington State and Oregon in the American Northwest (though it was apparently shot over the border in British Columbia), and the chilly, metallic light has a distinctly Scandinavian air.

Homeland, Series 4, Channel 4 / The Code, BBC Four

HOMELAND, SERIES 4, CHANNEL 4 / THE CODE, BBC FOUR Maybe the post-Brody 'Homeland' might succeed after all

Maybe the post-Brody 'Homeland' might succeed after all

It was tempting to assume that Homeland [****] had died along with Damian Lewis's Brody, last seen dangling gruesomely from a crane in Tehran at the end of series three, but this tense and uncomfortable season-opener suggested that all may not be lost. Carrie Mathison (Claire Danes) has been promoted to CIA station chief in Kabul, but she's finding that the personal price of professional success is growing exorbitantly high.

Downton Abbey, Series 5, ITV

DOWNTON ABBEY, SERIES 5, ITV On this evidence, there's still plenty of life in Lord Fellowes's beloved national institution

On this evidence, there's still plenty of life in Lord Fellowes's beloved national institution

As unavoidable as death and taxes, as inevitable as the rotation of the seasons, Downton Abbey has created the illusion of time-hallowed permanence in a mere four years. It is often asked how long Julian Fellowes can keep up his script-writing heroics (if it was an American show he'd be marshalling a writing team of dozens), but this opener to series five was so playfully deft and thunderously enjoyable that you'd have to conclude that Downton has become Fellowes's personal fountain of youth.

Common, BBC One

COMMON, BBC ONE Jimmy McGovern shines a light on both the humanity and legality of joint enterprise

Jimmy McGovern shines a light on both the humanity and legality of joint enterprise

Common, Jimmy McGovern’s new BBC One drama about the effects of the joint enterprise law, seems at first sight to lack the topical horsepower of projects like Hillsborough. McGovern doesn’t disappoint, however, crafting from the apparent obscurity of an eighteenth-century statute intended to discourage aristocratic duels by implicating both parties a riveting, corkscrew-plotted narrative that brings to overdue public notice an easily abused and abusive regulation that today targets the opposite end of society.