Hold the Sunset, BBC One, review - this is an ex-sitcom

★★ HOLD THE SUNSET, BBC ONE John Cleese, Alison Steadman star in exhumation of sitcom genre

John Cleese and Alison Steadman star in the exhumation of long-lost genre

You need to be of a certain vintage to have any memory of the traditional suburban family sitcom. Like the Raleigh Chopper and the Betamax video, like amateur athletics and glamrock and key parties, it is an extinct cultural artefact. What did for it? The internet, mainly, and the kids not watching scheduled telly any more, and maybe the rise of stand-up.

Troy: Fall of a City, BBC One review - soapification of the Trojan War

★★ TROY: FALL OF A CITY, BBC ONE Soapification of the Trojan War

Classical myth reborn as low-voltage melodrama

The plan to bring drama back to Saturday nights on BBC One enjoyed mixed success with Hard Sun, but now threatens to slide over a cliff with this trip back to the Homeric era. In the era of Game of Thrones and now Britannia, you can see why somebody fancied having a go at the swords-sandals-and-sorcery of the Trojan War. The question is, how?

McMafia, Series finale, BBC One review - the last bite is the cruellest

★★★ MCMAFIA, SERIES FINALE, BBC ONE The last bite is the cruellest

Credibility stretched? Empathy lost? James Norton goes back to his Russian roots, bloodily

McMafia has taught us to recognise one thing – you might call it the “Norton stride”. As the charismatic Alex Godman, James Norton has been advancing, confidently at screen centre, towards one challenge after another, and they have been coming (mildly put) from all sorts of unexpected quarters. He’s dealt with everything by pressing onwards, ignoring advice from all and sundry.

Requiem, BBC One review – everything but the scares

New horror series hits familiar notes, but struggles to leave a mark

Despite horror’s omnipresence in cinema, British television has been somewhat deprived of jump scares. Every couple of years there’s an anomaly, such as Sky’s The Enfield Haunting or ITV’s Marchlands, but nothing has caught the public’s imagination – not since the innovative but controversial one-off Ghostwatch.

Big Cats, BBC One review - how cats conquered the world

★★★★ BIG CATS, BBC ONE Felines from the fastest to the strongest, the smallest to the biggest

Felines from the fastest to the strongest, the smallest to the biggest

Accepted wisdom seemed to be that in the animal world rats and cockroaches were the most adaptable and the most widely geographically distributed, followed by those pesky humans. But think again: the premise in this new three-part series is that the big cats have also done a terrific job of spreading worldwide, each a different species within the genus.

Hard Sun, BBC One review - cops versus the end of the world

★★★★ HARD SUN, BBC ONE Sizzling start for Neil Cross's pre-apocalyptic thriller

Sizzling start for Neil Cross's pre-apocalyptic thriller

Fans of Luther will be familiar with writer Neil Cross’s fondness for hideous violence, shocking plot-twists and macabre humour, as well as characterful London locations, and happily they’re all present and correct in this new sci-fi thriller.

McMafia, BBC One review - James Norton looks promising in a murky le Carré world

★★★★ MCMAFIA, BBC ONE James Norton looks promising in a murky le Carré world

Crime - and punishment? Gangster capitalism, à la Russe, set to challenge integrity

It’s not the first time that James Norton has kicked off BBC One’s New Year primetime celebrations in Russian style. Two years ago, he was costumed up as the courageous Prince Andrei, in illustrious ensemble company for Andrew Davies and Tom Harper’s War and Peace.

The Miniaturist, BBC One review - a lovely supernatural soap

★★★★ THE MINIATURIST, BBC ONE Jessie Burton's novel is ravishingly visualised with 21st century highlights

Jessie Burton's novel is ravishingly visualised with 21st century highlights

Simon Schama called the Netherlands’ century of success an "embarrassment of riches". The thrust of Jessie Burton’s lavishly hyped debut novel The Miniaturist is that the Dutch felt guilty about their good fortune, and denied themselves the right to enjoy sugar, spice, and all things nice. The money went on surface things, on finery and furniture.

Little Women, BBC One review - life during wartime with the March sisters

★★★ LITTLE WOMEN, BBC ONE Agreeable yet soporific adaptation of Louisa May Alcott's novel

Agreeable yet soporific adaptation of Louisa May Alcott's enduring novel

One of the much-hyped jewels in the crown of the family-friendly BBC holiday season is this new three-episode adaptation of Louisa May Alcott's much loved novel by Heidi Thomas, the writer of Call the Midwife.

Doctor Who: Twice Upon a Time, BBC One review – a defiantly small and personal goodbye

★★★ DOCTOR WHO: TWICE UPON A TIME, BBC ONE Capaldi and Moffat traded thrills for laughter and tears in their flawed but touching finale

Capaldi and Moffat traded thrills for laughter and tears in their flawed but touching finale

And so, with one last speech on the importance of kindness, Peter Capaldi and Steven Moffat bid farewell to the TARDIS. In their final Doctor Who episode, Twice Upon a Time subverted expectations with a small, sweet adventure which valued character above plot.