Prom 62: Barton, OAE, Alsop

PROM 62: BARTON, OAE, ALSOP Great mezzo and bright young choir fly up, orchestra and conductor remain below

Great mezzo and bright young choir fly up, orchestra and conductor remain below

A concert of Brahms chamber music I could understand, especially given a balance between early and late. An evening of orchestral Brahms, with or without voices, needs much more special pleading. It didn’t get nearly enough last night. An expanded Orchestra of the Age of Enlightenment, including nine very vigorous double basses – where did the extra players come from?

Prom 46: Znaider, Danish NSO, Luisi

PROM 46: ZNAIDER, DANISH NSO, LUISI Legendary Brahms playing flanked by a cornucopia of 150th birthday Nielseniana

Legendary Brahms playing flanked by a cornucopia of 150th birthday Nielseniana

Praise be to Carl Nielsen. Praise always, of course, to one of the greatest symphonists, and happy 150th birthday (again), but gratitude on this occasion is due to a programme mostly lining up Nielsen works rare and familiar, for getting me to the Albert Hall to witness a surely unsurpassable performance of the Brahms Violin Concerto.

Vogt, LPO, Nézet-Séguin, Royal Festival Hall

Shapeliness and soul-searching in Brahms, Schubert and Strauss

Music lovers invariably divide into two factions over the Brahms piano concertos: those who thrill to the elemental D minor and those who prefer to bask in the more reflective charms of the sumptuous B flat Second Concerto. I’m a D minor man myself, secretly convinced that the four-movement Second would prove a far more startling piece if it began with the second movement. But then again it depends who plays it and Lars Vogt with Yannick Nézet-Séguin and the London Philharmonic Orchestra seemed to find new dimensions in its extravagant elaborations.

Leonskaja, SCO, Kamu, Usher Hall, Edinburgh

LEONSKAJA, SCO, KAMU, USHER HALL, EDINBURGH Magisterial partnership triumphantly encompasses two Brahms concertos in one concert

Magisterial partnership triumphantly encompasses two Brahms concertos in one concert

Most pianists never truly master one of Brahms’s two piano concertos, those colossal symphonies for soloist and orchestra, let alone both. To present the two in one concert, then, seems foolhardy – and apparently was when András Schiff went for the marathon at the Edinburgh Festival during the Brian McMaster era. No-one expected anything but true majesty, though, when Elisabeth Leonskaja asked to do the same. The Scottish Chamber Orchestra duly obliged, taking up her suggestion of Okko Kamu, a Finnish master I haven’t seen for decades, as conductor.

Uchida, LSO, Haitink, Barbican Hall

UCHIDA, LSO, HAITINK, BARBICAN HALL Master musicians in just-so Debussy, Mozart and Brahms

Master musicians in just-so Debussy, Mozart and Brahms

You know what to expect from a standard programme of masterpieces like this, led by two great performers in careful control of their repertoire, and those expectations are never going to be disappointed. You’re not going to hear the kind of new-sound Brahms side by side with the more recent end of the German musical tradition – Zimmermann, say, or Henze; that’s the provenance of a fresh thinker like Vladimir Jurowski.

Ashton Mixed Bill, Royal Ballet

ASHTON MIXED BILL, ROYAL BALLET Symphonic Variations is the highlight among fine works by supreme British choreographer

Symphonic Variations is the highlight among fine works by supreme British choreographer

This morning, those who follow ballet on both sides of the Atlantic might be feeling a bit like the male soloists at the beginning of Ashton’s Scènes de Ballet: turning their heads sharply, almost pantomimically, from side to side. Over there, in New York, Wendy Whelan, the prima ballerina retiring after a 30-year career with City Ballet, made her farewell in a programme heavy on modern masters Wheeldon and Ratmansky, including a world première.

Prom 69: Cleveland Orchestra, Welser-Möst

Gleaming music-making, trimmed like topiary, from a reticent conductor and a superb American orchestra

Is there something about the start of a new cultural season, or indeed the Proms, that make classical music’s conductors rush to jump ship? Consider this. Last Friday, two days before his pair of Prom concerts with his American outfit, the Cleveland Orchestra, Franz Welser-Möst, so diffident on the outside, resigned from his important European post as the Vienna State Opera’s music director with immediate effect. Irreconcilable artistic differences were cited.