France, LPO, Gardner, RFH review - the sound of other worlds

★★★★ FRANCE, LPO, GARDNER, RFH From a snowbound classic to Mahler's folk-tale heaven

From a snowbound contemporary classic to Mahler's folk-tale heaven

Even in the 21st century, it may not take that long for an outlandish literary experiment to jump genres and become an established musical classic. In 2008, I enthusiastically reviewed a strange, poetic, almost Beckett-like novella by the writer and music critic Paul Griffiths.

His let me tell you reconfigures the 483 words that the hapless Ophelia speaks in Hamlet into a haunting, melancholy first-person testament of love, sorrow and (in Griffiths’s version, if not Shakespeare’s) dogged survival. 

BBC Proms: Royal Concertgebouw Orchestra, Mäkelä review - defiantly introverted Mahler 5 gives food for thought

★★★ BBC PROMS, ROYAL CONCERTGEBOUW, MAKELA Defiantly introverted Mahler 5 

Chief Conductor in Waiting has supple, nuanced chemistry with a great orchestra

Klaus Mäkelä teased out all the fragility and the sense of impending mortality in Mahler’s Fifth Symphony, revealing a vision that was as intricate as it was quietly luminous. Famously Mahler almost died from an intestinal haemorrhage in the year that he started composing the work, and the Royal Concertgebouw Orchestra’s sensitive, nuanced performance conveyed his heightened awareness of a world that could suddenly disappear without warning.

Mahler 8, LPO, Gardner, RFH review - lights on high

★★★★ MAHLER 8, LPO, GARDNER, RFH Lights on high

Perfect pacing allows climaxes to make their mark - and the visuals aren’t bad, either

Transcendence is everywhere in Mahler’s most ambitious symphony, from the flaming opening hymn to the upper reaches in the epic setting of Goethe’s Faust finale. You’d think no visuals could match the auditory phantasmagoria, just as dance, music and design flunked the essence of Paradiso in the Royal Ballet’s The Dante Project. Mahler does compose a kind of concert opera in Part Two, though; sound, movement and image accorded well.

MacMillan St John Passion, Boylan, National Symphony Orchestra & Chorus, Hill, NCH Dublin review - flares around a fine Christ

★★★★ MACMILLAN ST JOHN PASSION, BOYLAN, NSO, NCH DUBLIN Flares around a fine Christ

Young Irish baritone pulls focus in blazing performance of a 21st century classic

Never make your mind up too soon about any large-scale work by a genius. Back in 2010, I had my doubts about James MacMillan’s first Passion, hearing in the impact of Colin Davis’s Barbican performance a halfway house between the composer's shattering best and his more contrived side.

Simón Bolívar Symphony Orchestra, Dudamel, Barbican review - an epic journey from gossamer-like intimacy to apocalyptic rage

★★★★★ SIMON BOLIVAR SYMPHONY ORCHESTRA, DUDAMEL, BARBICAN An orchestra on top form in Mahler's Third Symphony despite swirling controversies

An orchestra on top form in Mahler's Third Symphony despite swirling controversies

Gustavo Dudamel and the Simón Bolívar Symphony Orchestra of Venezuela took the Barbican by storm last night with a thrilling account of Mahler’s Third Symphony, his great exploration of the cosmic order, ascending from raw paganism to sublime transcendence. It's technically the longest symphony ever composed, and here it swept the audience through an epic journey that tilted between passages of gossamer-like intimacy and outbursts of apocalyptic rage.

Kavakos, Philharmonia, Blomstedt, RFH review - a supreme valediction forbidding mourning

★★★★ KAVAKOS, PHILHARMONIA, BLOMSTEDT, RFH Nonagenarian's Mahler 9 astounds

Nonagenarian conductor provides the flow, his players the passion, in Mahler's Ninth

From a privileged position in the Festival Hall stalls, I could see 97-year old Herbert Blomstedt’s near-immobile back as he sat on a piano stool with the score in front of him, but also his supremely expressive right arm and hand, every finger brought into play, the left hand occasionally visible to me as he raised it at moments of high emotion. The Philharmonia simply burned for him, every phrase and dynamic brought into focus to heighten an already assured vision.

Prom 62, Mahler's Sixth Symphony, Bavarian RSO, Rattle review - sound over momentum

★★★ PROM 62, MAHLER 6, BAVARIAN RSO, RATTLE Sound over momentum

Near-perfect playing, but something missing in the overall drama

Mahler’s Sixth is one of those apocalyptic megaliths that shouldn’t be approached too often by audiences or conductors. It’s been a constant in Simon Rattle’s treasury since 1989, when he first recorded it with his City of Birmingham Symphony Orchestra (they performed it together at the Proms in 1995) to now, when the second of the Bavarian Radio Symphony Orchestra concerts followed a recording. Sophisticated, yes, but where was the feral intensity?

Prom 30, National Youth Orchestra, NYO Inspire, Bloch, Jackson review - sheer youthful joy, passion and precision

PROM 30, NYO, NYO INSPIRE, BLOCH, JACKSON Sheer youthful joy, passion & precision

Quirky Mahler, tempestuous Wagner, two Proms premieres and a mind-blowing encore

Let’s begin at the end. Can the Paris Olympics' closing ceremony offer anything as classy or joyous as 260 musicians aged 13 to 18 singing the French carol-plus-farandole finale of Bizet’s L'Arlésienne music?* This encore also made Proms history as a unique riposte to the Simón Bolivar Youth Orchestra’s instrument-twirling Bernstein “Mambo”. And what a sequel to a Mahler One brimming with energy, masterfully negotiated by conductor Alexandre Bloch.