Prom 18: Andsnes, Mahnke, Skelton, BBCSO, Gardner review – all passion spent

★★★★★ PROM 18: BBCSO, GARDNER  A special eloquence for Mahler’s song of farewell

Hall, singers, conductor and musicians lend special eloquence to Mahler’s song of farewell

It’s a curiosity of music that a performance can occasionally be better – more persuasive and impressive – than the work itself. Even Britten’s most devoted advocates would find it hard to rank the Piano Concerto among his masterpieces. In his account at the BBC Proms last night, however, Leif Ove Andsnes carved out a niche for the piece as a confident yet quizzical response to the genre, standing diffidently to one side.

Chetham's Symphony Orchestra, Chetham's Chorus, Threlfall, Bridgewater Hall, Manchester - a thrilling triumph

★★★ MAHLER'S EIGHTH, BRIDGEWATER HALL Awesome highspot of Chetham School’s 50th anniversary

Truly awesome Mahler is the highspot of Chetham’s 50th anniversary year

As end-of-term concerts go, Mahler’s Eighth Symphony is a biggie. In fact it’s hard to imagine any place of secondary education where they would even contemplate it.

Cate Haste: Passionate Spirit - The Life of Alma Mahler review - a racy life pacily narrated

★★★ CATE HASTE: PASSIONATE SPIRIT The racy life of Alma Mahler pacily related

The creative Viennese soclalite who obsessively nurtured masterpieces by others

Charismatic, full of vital elan to the end, inconsistent, fitfully creative, a casually anti-semitic Conservative Catholic married to two of the greatest Jewish artists, Alma Mahler/Gropius/Werfel née Schindler can never be subject to a boring biography. A child of her fin de siècle time, torn between the need to be free and the will to inspire great figures, she was all too often gauged by the men who loved and tried to dominate her.

Williams, BBC Philharmonic, Wigglesworth, Bridgewater Hall Manchester review - vision before gloom

Mahler songs are the welcome foil to a grim Shostakovich symphony

The BBC Philharmonic have given memorable accounts of Shostakovich’s Symphony No 4 in Manchester before – notably conducted by Günther Herbig in 2010 and by John Storgårds in 2014 – but surely none as harrowingly grim as under Mark Wigglesworth this time.

Orchestra dell'Accademia Nazionale di Santa Cecilia, Pappano, Barbican review – joy in despair

★★★★★ ORCHESTRA DELL'ACCADEMIA NAZIONALE DI SANTA CECILIA, PAPPANO Joy in despair

Flavour and grandeur in Mahler's earth-shaking Sixth

As one half of British politics convulsed into a deeper spasm of suicidal fury, it came almost as a relief to hear a great Anglo-Italian conductor lead an impassioned Roman orchestra in a massive, terrifying symphony once described by a (German) maestro as the first example of musical nihilism. Ah, but that’s the paradox of Mahler’s Sixth. His so-called “Tragic” symphony – though he disavowed that label for the epic, 85-minute work he premiered in 1906 – might amount to an overpowering expression of grief, rage, and despair at the cruelty of fate.

LSO, Rattle, Barbican review - inner magic eventually joins outward mastery

★★★★ LSO, RATTLE, BARBICAN Mahler's Adagietto sounds fresh in a never less than impressive Fifth Symphony

Mahler's Adagietto sounds fresh in a never less than impressive Fifth Symphony

Nearly 17 years ago, Simon Rattle inaugurated his era at the helm of the Berlin Philharmonic with Mahler's Fifth Symphony.

Soltani, LPO, Gardner, RFH review – disciplined and dynamic accounts

★★★ SOLTANI, LPO, GARDNER, RFH  Discipline and dynamism in Elgar and Mahler

Elegant Elgar, keenly focussed but sometimes lacking nuance

No successor has yet been named to Vladimir Jurowski as Principal Conductor of the London Philharmonic, so it is interesting to note that Edward Gardner is making several appearances with the orchestra this season. The two conductors are similar in their dynamic approach and brisk, efficient tempos.