King Lear, Northern Broadsides, Touring

KING LEAR, NORTHERN BROADSIDES, TOURING Jonathan Miller's vivid new production puts Lear in a Yorkshire accent

Jonathan Miller's vivid new production puts Lear in a Yorkshire accent

Jonathan Miller’s new King Lear is rustic to its core, spoken in broad Northern accents, and the whole production could be packed onto a travelling theatre’s wagon and taken around Britain pulled by a couple of shire horses.

Death of a Salesman, Noël Coward Theatre

DEATH OF A SALESMAN, NOËL COWARD THEATRE Stunning performances make Miller's masterpiece burn

Stunning performances make Miller's masterpiece burn

We’ve not been short of memorable London productions of Arthur Miller’s best known works. Ivo van Hove’s triple Olivier award-winning A View from the Bridge, which transferred to the Wyndham’s Theatre from the Young Vic earlier this year, and the Old Vic’s The Crucible, directed last year by Yaël Farber, were two exceptional productions. And now we have the seminal play of the 20th century. The RSC’s Death of a Salesman arrives from its short run at Stratford garlanded with plaudits, but it’s even better in this West End transfer.

Carmen, Welsh National Opera

CARMEN, WNO Bizet's crowd-pleasing masterpiece sadly creaks in this lazy, by-the-numbers revival

Bizet's crowd-pleasing masterpiece sadly creaks in this lazy, by-the-numbers revival

Popularity is all very well, but it can be a poisoned chalice. Braving the umpteenth revival of Carmen at WNO (original directors Patrice Caurier and Moshe Leiser, revival director Caroline Chaney), I began to experience that sense of weariness that sometimes afflicts the dutiful end of the repertoire: Bizet’s masterpiece along with the relentless Butterflies and Toscas, the Figaros and Barbers. That feeling that the work and its myriad devotees will somehow get us through in the absence of anything resembling artistic necessity.

Prom 59: Elektra, BBC Symphony Orchestra, Bychkov

PROM 59: ELEKTRA, BBC SYMPHONY ORCHESTRA, BYCHKOV Second Strauss horror-opera of the Proms weekend fails to hit home

Second Strauss horror-opera of the Proms weekend fails to hit home

How much familial dysfunction and lust - whether for sexual gratification or revenge - can one take in a single weekend? Salome and Elektra back-to back may on paper seem like a feast of divine decadence but no sooner had one become accustomed to the sickly sweet air of the former when the putrefaction of the latter (I always think that Strauss’ orchestra is in the final stages of decay with Elektra) filled one’s nostrils - and ears.

Prom 28: D'Orazio, Clayton, BBCSO, Oramo

A great Stravinskyan king and queen surpass mood music for electric violin and strings

All kinds of narratives were at play in this Prom from the BBC Symphony Orchestra and its Principal Conductor Sakari Oramo - and perhaps the truly adventurous programmer might have double-deployed Rory Kinnear, dispassionately chronicling Stravinsky’s Oedipus rex, and taken us beyond the Overture and into the melodramas of Beethoven’s Incidental Music to Egmont.

Idomeneus, Gate Theatre

IDOMENEUS, GATE THEATRE Greek tragedy makes too much of the mechanics of story-telling

Greek tragedy makes too much of the mechanics of story-telling

Let's say Greek tragedies exist in a multiverse where the same stories play out simultaneously in thousands of ways. And let's say we're given free rein to argue over those stories, debate their morals and characters and disagree fundamentally over the story arc itself. This is what the German playwright Roland Schimmelpfennig explores in his take on the Greek general Idomeneus, who led the Cretan armies to Troy and also inspired a Mozart opera (Idomeneo). His 70-minute play embraces the possibilities of story-telling rather more than the story itself. 

Power, London Philharmonic Orchestra, Jurowski, Royal Festival Hall

MACMILLAN WORLD PREMIERE, ROYAL FESTIVAL HALL The power of his electrifying Viola Concerto is defused in Jurowski's low-wattage Mahler

The power of an electrifying new viola concerto is defused in low-wattage Mahler

Baleful prophecies were rife before the concert. Was Vladimir Jurowski right to let Mahler’s only total tragedy among his symphonies, the Sixth, share the programme with anything else, least of all a new viola concerto in which the solo instrument’s naturally pale cast of thought seemed likely to be indulged by James MacMillan – another composer not afraid of rhetorical angst?

Peter Grimes, LPO, Jurowski, Royal Festival Hall

PETER GRIMES, LPO, JUROWSKI, ROYAL FESTIVAL HALL Tenor, conductor and orchestra sear in Britten's seminal masterpiece

Tenor, conductor and orchestra sear in Britten's seminal masterpiece

For Londoners unable to travel up to Aldeburgh – or, now, to Leeds for the revival of Phyllida Lloyd’s Opera North production – this was the only chance in Britten centenary year to be blitzed by his seminal masterpiece. After the phenomenal success of the Proms’ Wagner semi-stagings, even the craft and sure-footedness of Daniel Slater’s direction here was never going to be a substitute for Grimes in the opera house (or on the beach), serving only to show that this is a supreme music drama least happily separated from the theatre.

Elektra, Royal Opera

ELEKTRA, ROYAL OPERA Revival hits the horrid heart of the matter in Richard Strauss's poleaxing masterpiece

Revival hits the horrid heart of the matter in Richard Strauss's poleaxing masterpiece

“Strike again,” cries Elektra as her brother stabs their mother to death. It’s third strike lucky for this Covent Garden production of Richard Strauss and Hugo von Hofmannsthal’s singular mythic horror. In previous manifestations of designer-director Charles Edwards’ rather over-freighted but ever improving staging, conductors Semyon Bychkov and Mark Elder, as well as top-less soprano Lisa Gasteen and the more nuanced but sometimes underpowered Susan Bullock, missed the heart of the matter.