Best of 2018: Classical CDs

BEST OF 2018: CLASSICAL CDS A Kazan Shostakovich, Messiaen's birds, Bernstein the pianist

From the year's favourites: a Kazan Shostakovich, Messiaen's birds, Bernstein the pianist

Record shops may be thin on the ground, but CDs are still very much with us. No sensible soul would ever rate listening to a recording over experiencing music live. But if, like me, time, money and geography limit one’s opportunities to nip out to concerts, a well-produced CD can plug the gap very nicely. I’m still a fan of the physical product over the download: removing shrink wrap and flicking through sleeve notes are one of life's minor pleasures, and several releases in this list score highly in terms of aesthetics as well as music making.

Lammermuir Festival 2018 review - a bigger buzz

East Lothian's award-winning festival continues to challenge, provoke and illuminate

There’s always been something of a buzz in the air at East Lothian’s Lammermuir Festival. It’s the feeling that it’s somehow a special privilege to discover its performances – whether they’re from international names or emerging artists, challenging, provocative and illuminating by turns – across the region’s exquisite and little-known churchs, halls, theatres and other venues.

Edinburgh Festival 2018 review: Aimard, SCO, Pintscher - psychedelic visions

★★★★★ EDINBURGH FESTIVAL 2018: AIMARD, SCO, PINTSCHER Psychedelic visions

Two dazzling Messiaen performances from the composer's piano protégé

There were two immediate casualties at Pierre-Laurent Aimard’s high-energy account of Messiaen’s monumental Des canyons aux étoiles… with the Scottish Chamber Orchestra at the Edinburgh International Festival.

Roger Scruton: Music as an Art review - how to listen?

★★ ROGER SCRUTON: MUSIC AS AN ART Odd and uncategorisable essays fail to enlighten

Odd and uncategorisable essays fail to enlighten

Hegel, Kant, David Hume, Nietzsche, Schopenhauer, Leibniz are all adduced, referred to, and paraphrased, and that’s just for starters. Add Rameau, Schubert, Beethoven, Benjamin Britten and the contemporary composer David Matthews (who is also a friend) into the mix for Professor Sir Roger Scruton’s odd and uncategorisable series of essays on music and – especially – listening to music. Underneath it all is a kind of call to arms about how to listen.

Proms 29 / 30, Swedish Chamber Orchestra, Dausgaard review - Bach Brandenburgs and beyond

Strong instrumental soloists provided some highlights in a long day

A complex Swedish product to unpack, this one. Someone in the BBC must have worked out that it could do with a detailed instruction manual to help people with the task: the programme booklet duly ran to a full 50 pages.