Best of 2023: Film

BEST OF 2023: FILM Theartsdesk's film critics cast their net wide

Kicking off the top choices of the year, theartsdesk's film critics cast their net wide

Numbers indicate if entries are listed in order of preference


Saskia Baron

Anatomy of a Fall

Broker

Fallen Leaves

Joyland

Killers of the Flower Moon

Otto Baxter: Not a F**ing Horror Story

Return to Seoul

St Omer

Scrapper

A Thousand and One

Powell and Pressburger: A Celtic storm brewing

The Archers stepped up their wartime campaign against materialism with the mystical Scottish romance 'I Know Where I'm Going!'

“Nothing is stronger than true love,” a young laird says to a headstrong young woman in Michael Powell and Emeric Pressburger’s I Know Where I’m Going! (1945), his voice heard above the sounds of wind and waves. She replies, “No, nothing.”

Powell and Pressburger: In Prospero's Room

★★★★★ POWELL AND PRESSBURGER: IN PROSPERO'S ROOM A magical day at Derek Jarman’s Dungeness cottage, dancing with the ghosts of Shakespeare, Powell and Pressburger

A magical day at Derek Jarman’s Dungeness cottage, dancing with the ghosts of Shakespeare, Powell and Pressburger

There’s a thread of bright magic running through British cinema, from Powell and Pressburger through Nic Roeg, Derek Jarman and Lynne Ramsay, and it’s wrapped around Jarman’s last home like fisherman’s rope.

May December review - a queasy take on sexual exploitation

★★ MAY DECEMBER Todd Haynes reunites with Julianne Moore in a stylish but cold melodrama

Todd Haynes reunites with Julianne Moore in a stylish but cold melodrama

There’s much to admire  here – May December features impressive performances from Julianne Moore and Natalie Portman, and director Todd Haynes shows his mastery of classic Sirkian style. But disappointingly, this comes across as a movie that aims to critique media exploitation of a scandal while indulging in its own manipulation.  

How to Have Sex review - compelling journey of a vulnerable teen

★★★★ HOW TO HAVE SEX Fine film-making, nuanced acting and a pitch-perfect script

This British debut delivers fine film-making, nuanced acting and a pitch-perfect script

Molly Manning Walker surprised herself by winning the Un Certain Regard section at Cannes this year with her rites-of-passage feature, How to Have Sex. Why the surprise? It’s a compelling debut.

Powell and Pressburger: Spy masters

POWELL AND PRESSBURGER: SPY MASTERS On the wartime spy films, and Alfred Hitchcock

Though less renowned, Powell and Pressburger’s wartime spy films put some of Alfred Hitchcock’s in the shade

Alfred Hitchcock and Michael Powell are, almost certainly, Britain’s greatest directors. Hitchcock was slightly older, and entered the film business earlier; in fact, Powell worked as a stills photographer on Hitchcock’s Champagne and Blackmail, in the late Twenties, shortly before making his own films.

Michael Powell interview - 'I had no idea that critics were so innocent'

In an interview Powell gave to City Limits in 1986, he discussed the furore over his misunderstood masterpiece 'Peeping Tom' and his wrangles with David O Selznick

Michael Powell fell in love with his celluloid mistress in 1921 when he was 16. It’s a love affair that he’s conducted for 65 years. At 81, he’s not stopped dreaming of getting behind the camera again. At Cannes this year he hinted at plans to make a silent horror film, but he’s reluctant to talk about it.

Asteroid City review - desert dreams

★★★ ASTEROID CITY Scarlett Johansson leads Wes Anderson's latest

Scarlett Johansson leads Wes Anderson's latest, a Fifties-set mixture of fetish and feeling

Multi-media meta-layers land fast in Wes Anderson’s 11th film, overriding reality. Here’s Bryan Cranston’s portentous Fifties TV host (pictured below) in black-and-white, boxed Academy ratio, documenting rehearsals for a televised play, whose fictive reality then becomes a widescreen colour train hurtling through the desert. The latter scene's exhilarating cinema still sweeps you up.