Pokémon Detective Pikachu review - a cute commercial

Pokémon meets the relatively real world, and hits its limits

share this article

Detective Pikachu (Ryan Reynolds) takes the case
Photos courtesy Warner Bros. Pictures

This is the Who Framed Roger Rabbit? of the Pokémon franchise, bringing the video game’s cute critters into a live-action, film noir world, as Pikachu (Ryan Reynolds) turns Holmes-hatted detective to help teenage human Tim (Justice Smith) find his apparently murdered dad.

Their quest takes them through Ryme City, a utopia where Pokémon and people exist in perfect harmony, thanks to the beneficence of corporate chief Howard Clifford (Bill Nighy, whose Blofeld-like cat makes you doubt his motives early). The ensuing fight against corporate corruption of Pokémon-human relations is helped by plucky young reporter Lucy (Kathryn Newton, pictured below with Smith). As corporate hard sell for Pokémon video games is this film’s sole purpose, the satire somewhat struggles.

Tim had father issues even before his legendary police detective dad careened off the road, in a prologue at the Pokémon Genetic Research Facility with the shadowy feel of a Seventies conspiracy thriller. Interrupted at a Pokémon hunt (slightly less brutal than it sounds) by news of the death, Tim travels to Ryme City, where world cultures intermingle as casually as people and Pokémon, yellow New York cabs jostling with red London buses. The city remains as essentially Japanese as the cameoing Ken Watanabe, and Pokémon itself.

Kathryn Newton, Justice Smith and friends in Pokemon Detective PikachuThe film lacks any of Roger Rabbit’s human-animation, inter-reality frisson. It takes place in a golden, soft-focus glow reminiscent of Spielberg in the 1980s, minus the magic; the comforting opposite of the noirs and conspiracy flicks it references. Smith and Newton have innocent charm as the young leads, in a resolutely pure kids’ film. Ryan Reynolds’ wiseacre chatter as he voices the Pokémon gumshoe stays high-voiced and harmless, diluting his Deadpool persona for juvenile consumption. Knowing references to sex and drugs are minor and mild, not relentlessly aimed over children’s heads at paying adults.

Then again, the nostalgic twenty- and thirtysomethings who fell in love with Pokémon in the Nineties, and the more recent addicts who walked the streets enslaved by Pokémon Go, are Pikachu’s real audience, just as happy in this bright, soft-edged play-world as current children entranced by the creatures’ cuteness.

Pikachu (Ryan Reynolds) in Pokemon Detective PikachuThose adults hard-wired by thousands of hours capering with Pokémon were in transports of delight at the screening I attended, suggesting this migration as close to the real world as the critters can get may revive this sputtering film franchise. But as the Pokémon battles become interminable, there’s no depth here for outsiders. Among the fantasy behemoths which have consumed cinema-going, only Marvel had the patience, and almost bottomless raw material, to build an emotionally affecting mythology. The behavioural data harvested by Pokémon Go is this likeable film’s secret soul.

There are two moments of captivating imagination. Pikachu’s interrogation of a Pokémon who communicates only in mime is almost worthy of the Marx Brothers. The sudden, sliding collapse of a whole hillside, and its reconfiguring as a row of giant turtles, has the vertiginous effect of Christopher Nolan’s Inception. Pikachu’s hologram flashbacks to imperishable, buried memories have also strayed in from some phantom, Philip K. Dick-scripted Pokémon film. Then it goes back to subliminally selling you games, and it all seems a bit offensive. 

The behavioural data harvested by Pokémon Go is this likeable film’s secret soul

rating

2

explore topics

share this article

Support the future of arts journalism

Subscribe to theartsdesk.com

Thanks so much for choosing genuinely independent arts journalism theartsdesk’s mission has never been more important – in an age of relentless algorithmic recommendation, sponsored content and unreliable AI, the expertise and discernment of individual critics deeply embedded in their specialist areas is absolutely vital.

If you want more of that in your life, why not subscribe now?

If you do this before the 31st August, you’ll be able to keep at this “founders rate” for life: your subs will never increase! You can choose to subscribe annually for just £40 simply click here
or monthly for £5 per month simply click here.

Not ready to subscribe?

If you want to support with a little extra or aren’t ready to subscribe just yet, there’s also the option to give direct to our crowdfunder to support our imminent redesign and exciting expansion with new features and collaborations Simply contribute here: https://gofund.me/c3f6033d.

However you choose to be involved, you can proudly say that you are picking the right side in the battle for truth and humanity in the modern information landscape. And we will be very glad to have you on board!

more film

Dip your toes into these Homeric movies before Christopher Nolan’s 'The Odyssey' ties us to its mast
A Bellocchio classic is retooled as a stifllng rich-brats' revenge story
A potential camera in every hand: SMart celebrates smartphone directors
Hitchcockian black comedy from Luis Buñuel’s Mexican period
Olivia Wilde's snappy comedy on the perennial subject of reviving a failing marriage
Kiss kiss, bang bang in a moving Middle East documentary
David Vann's acclaimed novella transposed to the screen with mixed results
The most important 'how-to video' you are ever likely to see
Satyajit Ray's poignant, thoughtful drama, set in 1960s Calcutta
Superman's party girl cousin earns her stripes underwhelmingly
Convoluted drama takes on Fab Four delusions, brotherly trauma and ultraviolence
Sophy Romvari's atmospheric first feature looks back at a tortured family dynamic