Ellie Roberts' Album of the Year 2025: Lady Gaga - Mayhem

All-consuming pop perfection

share this article

'A perfectly effortless feel and a strong sense of character'

2025 was another year of flaunting for the ever impressive beast that is female-led pop domination. The now iconic line up of legends and future greats, and their growing class of inspired apprentices, have punctuated the year with defiance and celebration in the form of fantastic pop songs. The prevalence across festival stages, TikTok trends, and radio are telling of the power that this entity basks in but doesn’t take away from the deserved success of most of it. 

Lady Gaga’s Mayhem took the crown for me this year, it’s an all round well planned and polished album with a perfectly effortless feel and a strong sense of character, and sometimes that’s exactly what you need music to be. The other most enjoyable and meaningful release of the year for me was the record-breaking The Life of a Showgirl by Taylor Swift, another thoughtful and expertly crafted album that will go down in history, despite the excitable criticism that inevitably came with it by those strangely praying for her downfall.  

In a year when punk and rock were limited in their new music offering, Gaga’s injection of quirky, theatrical rebellion into what would otherwise be considered a Dance Pop album filled the void for me. The perfectly catchy “How Bad Do U Want Me” lured me in with the suggestion that Mayhem might be a return to roots for Gaga, now bragging so many strings to her bow that a throwback pop album could only be worth making if it was perfect, and it is.

“Garden of Eden” and “Killah” are amongst some of my favourite ever Lady Gaga songs, the high energy electropop tracks are complimented by the coolest confidence, but they’re just two examples of the self-assured spirit that makes this album such a great listen, you can just feel that she cares about it, but with zero desperation. It would be nothing new to highlight the impressive vocals that Gaga is capable of, but the assertive nature of her voice is as comforting in Mayhem as it is impressive. The ballads tick every box they should, with just enough weird energy scattered through them to know who you’re listening to.  I couldn’t turn it off, and I think it will go down as one of her most representative albums, in the very best way. 

Three More Essential Albums of 2025

Taylor Swift - The Life of a Showgirl

Turnstile - Never Enough

Motion City Soundtrack - The Same Old Wasted Wonderful World

Musical Experiences of the Year

2025 was the year I finally made the trip to California to experience Vans Warped Tour for the first time, and it delivered on every level. Highlights were the longest and happiest crowd-surf of my life during A Day To Remember’s energetic set, and the sun setting over the sea of skaters, checkerboard logos, and elder emos with burnt shoulders as Sublime provided a moment of laid-back escapism. I was also lucky to witness the great return of Oasis in their hometown a couple of weeks before, July was a memorable month for live music.  

Track of the Year

Taylor Swift “The Fate of Ophelia”

The ballads tick every box they should, with just enough weird energy scattered through them to know who you’re listening to

rating

5

share this article

Support the future of arts journalism

Subscribe to theartsdesk.com

Thanks so much for choosing genuinely independent arts journalism theartsdesk’s mission has never been more important – in an age of relentless algorithmic recommendation, sponsored content and unreliable AI, the expertise and discernment of individual critics deeply embedded in their specialist areas is absolutely vital.

If you want more of that in your life, why not subscribe now?

If you do this before the 31st August, you’ll be able to keep at this “founders rate” for life: your subs will never increase! You can choose to subscribe annually for just £40 simply click here
or monthly for £5 per month simply click here.

Not ready to subscribe?

If you want to support with a little extra or aren’t ready to subscribe just yet, there’s also the option to give direct to our crowdfunder to support our imminent redesign and exciting expansion with new features and collaborations Simply contribute here: https://gofund.me/c3f6033d.

However you choose to be involved, you can proudly say that you are picking the right side in the battle for truth and humanity in the modern information landscape. And we will be very glad to have you on board!

more new music

Surrealism, social observation and more muscular sound from the Leeds quartet
A powerful personal outpouring of joy and pain - with a great beat
The London quartet have taken to playing large venues with ease, as this career-spanning set showed
The Lebanese-French musician's father was behind a unique musical innovation
The Philadelphia punk rockers continue to impress
A partial account of how Brit-punk absorbed an aspect of reggae
The Fez Festival Of World Sacred Music and the Fes Gathering bring the world together
Bristol band aren't happy but offer up the occasional sing-along
A new album is unveiled and old tunes are played for the last time