BBC Proms: Liu, Philharmonia, Rouvali review - fine-tuned Tchaikovsky epic

Sounds perfectly finessed in a colourful cornucopia

share this article

Santtu-Matias Rouvali on drum set, Tim Gibbs on bass and Bruce Liu in Joplin's Maple Leaf Rag
All images by Chris Christodoulou

Pianist Bruce Liu wasn’t the only star soloist last night, though he certainly had the most notes to play. Attention was riveted by at least five Philharmonia members and their maverick principal conductor Santtu-Matias Rouvali as percussionist in a joyful Prom.

First off the mark was Antoine Siguré, probably the most compelling orchestral timpanist I’ve ever encountered. Mexican composer Gabriela Ortiz, daughter of two of Los Folkloristica’s founding members, gifted him solo rollickings which gave her Antrópolis the nature of a concerto, punctuated by snatches of music from Mexico City’s antros or dance halls: a nothing-really-doing bar that eventually showcased the brass, a perfect if slightly over-extended curtain-raiser.

Rouvali, a rather more uneven London orchestral chief than any of his equals, launched Tchaikovsky’s Second Piano Concerto with an approach to the opening Allegro brillante which felt too self-consciously light. This is an imperially-framed celebration of a work which seems to reflect the scale of Brahms’s two titans in the genre (the German's second had yet to be completed at the time). If you love the material which Tchaikovsky so generously and originally extends, then you’re in for a fantastical journey; I adore it. At first, Bruce Liu rather snatched at the big-boned writing, too. But soon everything settled. The second vast cadenza found Liu in Lisztian transcendental mode, clear and impressive, while the delicacies in between the grandeur were crowned by Samuel Coles’ exquisite flute solos. Bruce LiuI hope no-one ever returns to Tchaikovsky pupil Ziloti’s truncated version. Who would want to miss every incarnation of the glorious second-movement melody first unfolded by violinist (the ever-creative Philharmonia co-leader Zsolt-Tihamér Visontay, pictured above with Liu) and cellist (Steffan Morris)? The piano comes second, in every way, but makes the return of the long tune the most moving.

The finale is a romp, here crisp and well-defined, Liu’s biggest assets. I didn’t think much of his solo Tchaikovsky disc for Deutsche Grammophon, but the partnership with orchestra and conductor here was well matched. Expecting an encore of one of The Seasons pieces on that CD, I realised there was to be Santtu involvement as a drum kit was brought forward. Rouvali and principal double bass Tim Gibbs teamed up with Liu in a nimble version of Joplin’s Maple Leaf Rag which will go down as one of the most fondly-remembered Proms extras of the year. Santtu-Matias RouvaliRouvali always favours a degree of instrumental abstraction in favour of vocalised characterisation in orchestral tone-poems, and the revelation of his Mussorgsky-Ravel Pictures at an Exhibition was the delicate perfection of Ravel’s most French moments in an orchestration which runs the gamut (as does the original – "how Russian is it?" seems a pointless question when the artist’s sketches on which the work is based travel to Paris, Limoges, Poland, Italy).

The latest among the ever-surpising adaptations to Royal Albert Hall acoustics came mostly from the beautifully projected wind playing, both soloistically and as an ensemble, starting with the most refined Promenade 2. Big, polished brass of course in the apocalyptic roars from the catacombs, and full percussion impact – big bell included, but once again Siguré’s artistry focused attention – in what we know as “The Great Gate of Kiev”. A vintage evening to another packed house.

If you love the material which Tchaikovsky so generously and originally extends, then you’re in for a fantastical journey; I adore it

rating

4

share this article

Support the future of arts journalism

Subscribe to theartsdesk.com

Thanks so much for choosing genuinely independent arts journalism theartsdesk’s mission has never been more important – in an age of relentless algorithmic recommendation, sponsored content and unreliable AI, the expertise and discernment of individual critics deeply embedded in their specialist areas is absolutely vital.

If you want more of that in your life, why not subscribe now?

If you do this before the 31st August, you’ll be able to keep at this “founders rate” for life: your subs will never increase! You can choose to subscribe annually for just £40 simply click here
or monthly for £5 per month simply click here.

Not ready to subscribe?

If you want to support with a little extra or aren’t ready to subscribe just yet, there’s also the option to give direct to our crowdfunder to support our imminent redesign and exciting expansion with new features and collaborations Simply contribute here: https://gofund.me/c3f6033d.

However you choose to be involved, you can proudly say that you are picking the right side in the battle for truth and humanity in the modern information landscape. And we will be very glad to have you on board!

more classical music

Eloquent thoughts on the wonder of 'Dichterliebe' and a new work inspired by it
Latest in a line of great Irish mezzos shows her versatility, and the strings swoon
A pair of much-loved cello concertos, plus percussion transcriptions and a great German song cycle
Two recitals in a thousand, other events good to excellent
Distinction and emotional impact from young musicians and an exuberant maestro
A brass hero blows through favourite pieces - and a bluesy newcomer
Baroque concertos, opera arias on solo horn and new music for contrabass flute
Subtle, introspective 'Harold in Italy' followed by over-punchy 'Symphonie fantastique'
Semi-staged version brings a heightened appreciation of the symphony's jostle of voices
Cellist/singer with friends and top quartet make welcome returns to the DICMF
Striking performances by a quartet with a strong sense of identity
Life-enhancing Danish piano music and a trio of epic symphonies