theartsdesk in Stockholm: the Birgit Nilsson Prize unites two great Wagnerian sopranos

THE ARTS DESK IN STOCKHOLM The Birgit Nilsson Prize unites two great Wagnerian sopranos

Nina Stemme does honour to her compatriot, who would have been 100 this year

Why are great Wagnerian singers the most down-to-earth and collegial in the world of opera? Perhaps you have to be to master and sustain the biggest roles in the business, ones which can't be performed in isolation, and a strong constitution helps, too. Birgit Nilsson, the farmer's daughter born in rural Sweden 100 years ago, had all those qualities and many more.

Hallé, Gardner, Bridgewater Hall, Manchester review – drama and humanity

★★★★ EDWARD GARDNER AND THE HALLE Powerful results in Strauss and Janáček

Happy return and powerful results in Strauss and Janáček

Edward Gardner was back amongst friends when he opened the Hallé’s Thursday series concerts. This was the place where he made his mark, as the Manchester orchestra’s first ever assistant conductor (and Youth Orchestra music director), and he’s been a welcome visitor ever since.

Salome, English National Opera review - a not so terrible stillness

★★ SALOME, ENGLISH NATIONAL OPERA Inertia kills strong stage pictures and decent singing

Inertia kills strong stage pictures, decent singing and a bejewelled orchestra

Sibling incest among the symbolic clutter of the Royal Opera Ring on Wednesday, last night necrophilia and a bit more incest – mother and daughter this time, courtesy of the director's imagination – in a stone-cold ENO Salome. Adena Jacobs' credentials were promising, not least her time at Sydney's cutting-edge Belvoir Theatre.

Ariadne auf Naxos, Opera Holland Park - stylish staging, world-class singing

★★★★★ ARIADNE AUF NAXOS, OPERA HOLLAND PARK Stylish staging, world-class singing

Strauss and Hofmannsthal's 'mystery of transformation' applied to two women in love

"When the new god approaches, we surrender, struck dumb". Especially if, for the singer of those words, popular entertainer Zerbinetta, the “new god” takes the shape of same-sex love.

Ariadne auf Naxos, Longborough Festival review - appetising energy and wit

★★★★★ ARIADNE AUF NAXOS, LONGBOROUGH FESTIVAL Strauss's chamber masterpiece brilliantly staged, finely played and sung

Strauss's chamber masterpiece brilliantly staged, finely played and sung

Much as I love Strauss’s Ariadne in its final form, I have a sneaking nostalgia for the original version (attached to Hofmannsthal’s adaptation of Molière’s Le bourgeois gentilhomme), which had Zerbinetta and her companions popping up after the final love duet and gently letting out some of its gas.

Capriccio, Garsington Opera review - a classy evening with words and music

★★★★ CAPRICCIO, GARSINGTON OPERA A classy evening with words and music

Stardust from soprano Miah Persson and fine company in Strauss's conversation-piece

Like the comedies of Mozart – the genius the artistic milieu depicted in Capriccio seems to be waiting for, if its original 1770s setting is observed – the more conversational operas of Richard Strauss depend far more than one often realises on conducting that sets a stylish, buoyant pace. Without it, and even more more rehearsal time than Garsington allows, musical heaven remains just out of reach.

Der Rosenkavalier, Glyndebourne - detailed acting, great singing

★★★★ DER ROSENKAVALIER, GLYNDEBOURNE Detailed acting, great singing

More austere drama, but richer voices, in this revival of Richard Jones's tour de force

If Hugo von Hofmannsthal's libretto for Richard Strauss in their joint "comedy for music" is the apogee of elaborately referenced dialogue and stage directions in opera, Richard Jones's realisation - for all that it throws out much of the original rulebook - may well be the most rigorously detailed production on the operatic stage today.

The Rosenkavalier film, OAE, Paterson, QEH review - silent-era muddle expertly accompanied

★★★★ THE ROSENKAVALIER FILM, OAE, PATERSON, QEH Silent-era muddle expertly accompanied

Superb salon-orchestra playing redeems Strauss's lazy work on a meandering silent film

Let's face it, Robert "Cabinet of Dr Caligari" Wiene's 1926 film loosely based on Strauss and Hofmannsthal's 1911 "comedy for music" is a mostly inartistic ramble. Historically, though, it proves fascinating.