Lucy Crowe, Anna Tilbrook, Wigmore Hall review - the eternal and ephemeral feminine

★★★★ LUCY CROWE, ANNA TILBROOK, WIGMORE HALL The eternal and ephemeral feminine

Strong women command texts and songs about them mostly by men

When you have 21 women to present in song, but only a couple among the 14 poets and none to represent them out of the 15 composers idolising or giving them a voice, you need two strong defenders of their sex at the helm. Lucy Crowe and Anna Tilbrook are no shrinking violets – the soprano no longer a light lyric, the pianist supportive only in the best sense, full of flexible power and forceful middle-to-lower-range sonorities for the voice to coast above.

Matthias Goerne, Seong-Jin Cho, Wigmore Hall review - slow and slower Strauss

A disappointingly one-geared Lieder recital

Matthias Goerne has an exceptional ability to sustain evenness and legato through a vocal line. His breath control and his tone production are things to be marvelled at. He is able to function at impossibly slow tempi, and to make an audience hold its collective breath in admiration. The problem comes when he performs a recital programme which sets out to prove that point. Again and again. All evening.

Gerhardt, RPO, Payare, RFH review - personality muted by faceless conducting

Cellist-knight can't completely rescue an evening more about sound than expression

Former Royal Philharmonic Orchestra principal conductor Charles Dutoit has been exposed, to little surprise from musicians, as something of a roué whose apparent refusal to take "no" for an answer has rubbed up against the new #MeToo world. So his place in last night's concert was taken by Venezuelan Rafael Payare, not yet 40.

Ariadne auf Naxos, Scottish Opera review - superb singing in slick new production

★★★★ ARIADNE AUF NAXOS, SCOTTISH OPERA Superb singing in slick new production

Sophisticated Richard Strauss hybrid sung in English and German

"The Show must go on". So say the posters dotted around Glasgow and Edinburgh for Scottish Opera's production of Richard Strauss's Ariadne auf Naxos. Except on Thursday, it didn’t. A fire at a nearby Glasgow nightclub which ravaged several city centre buildings caused the Theatre Royal to become so filled with smoke that the opening night’s performance had to be cancelled.

Louise Alder, James Baillieu, Wigmore Hall review - sensual heat thaws a winter's evening

★★★★ LOUISE ALDER, JAMES BAILLIEU, WIGMORE HALL Sensual heat thaws a winter's evening

Superb young lyric soprano's voice only grows in breadth and beauty

Rapture, ecstasy, ardour, and a few cheeky fumbles in the bushes – Louise Alder and James Baillieu’s Wigmore recital promised “Chants d’amour” and delivered amply, giving us love in all its bewildering, technicolour variety.

Salome, Royal Opera review – lurid staging still packs a punch

★★★ SALOME, ROYAL OPERA Lurid staging still packs a punch

Compelling production returns, but with a patchy cast

David McVicar may seem too gentle a soul for the lurid drama of Strauss's Salome, but his production, here returning to Covent Garden for a third revival, packs a punch. He gives us plenty of sex and violence – or at least nudity and blood – but finds the real drama in the personal interactions, the increasingly dysfunctional relationships that eventually doom all involved.

Soltani, West-Eastern Divan Orchestra, Barenboim, RFH review - passionate pilgrimages

★★★★ SOLTANI, WEST-EASTERN DIVAN ORCHESTRA, BARENBOIM, RFH Habemus Quixote: young cellist owns Strauss's and Cervantes' old knight

Habemus Quixote: young cellist owns Strauss's and Cervantes' old knight

A legendary name and the chance to change the face of a cruel condition set the stakes high for what Prince Charles, in his programme preface for this Southbank spectacular, told us was called the Stop MS Jacqueline du Pré Tribute Concert.

Anne Schwanewilms, Charles Spencer, Wigmore Hall review - going deep in Schubert

ANNE SCHWANEWILMS, CHARLES SPENCER A Lieder masterclass at Wigmore Hall

The great soprano and her regular pianist give a masterclass in Lieder

They say that Wigmore Hall audiences know their Lieder singers, but last night's far from packed house dispelled that illusion; the hall has been full for much lesser artists than German soprano Anne Schwanewilms. No matter; she gave her usual masterclass, ineffably poised between tone-colour, phrasing and word-pointing.

Pogostkina, BBCSO, Oramo, Barbican review - human emotions in Sibelius's heaven

★★★★★ POGOSTKINA, BBCSO, ORAMO, BARBICAN Death transcended, and a blaze of light and love in a great symphony

Death transcended, and a blaze of light and love in a great symphony

It was on the strength of a single concert including a startling Sibelius Luonnotar and Third Symphony, thankfully reported here, that Sakari Oramo was appointed Chief Conductor of the BBC Symphony Orchestra. We had to wait a while for more major Sibelius from them, revelling in the meanwhile in the team’s superlative Nielsen cycle.