Stile Antico, The Cardinall's Musick, Wigmore Hall online review – lightening our darkness

★★★★★ STILE ANTICO, THE CARDINALL'S MUSICK, WIGMORE HALL Lightening our darkness

The rapt beauty of a Renaissance Christmas pierces the gloom

Suitably enough, this year’s musical Christmas arrived at the Wigmore not in a dazzle of joyful light and bedecked with winter greenery, but with a lonely band of singers facing the gloom of an unlit, empty hall as fear and confusion multiplied outside. In both of yesterday’s concerts, the closing events of the venue’s defiant and courageous autumn season, a cappella choral music from the Renaissance ushered in a festival more austere than ecstatic. It proved deeply beautiful in its sombre way, but quite free of tinsel jollity.

How Lonely Sits The City, Dunedin Consort online review - almost as good as being in the concert hall

★★★★ HOW LONELY SITS THE CITY, DUNEDIN CONSORT Almost as good as being there

A pertinent and thoughtful recital meditates on isolation

It’s hard to remember that distant time back in March before we were all digital experts, when the idea of watching a live-streamed performance was still novel and intriguing. Fast-forward eight months and serious screen-based fatigue has set in.

Britain’s Lost Masterpieces, Episode Three, BBC Four review – more than a bit of Botticelli

★★★ BRITAIN'S LOST MASTERPIECES, BBC FOUR A hidden Renaissance gem in Cardiff Art Gallery

A hidden Renaissance gem in Cardiff Art Gallery

Once again the whodunit becomes the whoforgedit in the newest installment of the Britain’s Lost Masterpieces series. Host and art historian Bendor Grosvenor introduces us to what is one of the most beautiful he’s ever seen: a Madonna and Child believed to have been done by Sandro Botticelli, one of the members of “painting’s Premier League”.

Leonardo da Vinci: A Life in Drawing, The Queen's Gallery review - peerless drawings, rarely seen

Drawing was the language of thought for the greatest of Renaissance artists

It is a commonplace to describe Leonardo as an enigma whose genius, and perhaps even something of his character, is revealed through his works. But as his works survive only in incomplete and fragmented form, it is drawing, the practice common to all his various endeavours, that brings coherence and perhaps even a comprehensive view of a lifetime’s labours.

Los Angeles Master Chorale, Gershon, Sellars, Barbican review – embodiments of remorse

★★★★ LOS ANGELES MASTER CHORALE, GERSHON, SELLARS Embodiments of remorse

Grandeur, and fussiness, in Peter Sellars' staging of a choral masterwork

By some strange alignment of the stars, Peter Sellars’s staged version of Orlando di Lasso’s Lagrime di San Pietro (Tears of St Peter) arrived at the Barbican Hall just as – next door in the theatre – Pam Tanowitz’s directed her dance interpretation of TS Eliot’s Four Quartets.

Mantegna and Bellini, National Gallery review - curated for curators

★★★ MANTEGNA AND BELLINI, NATIONAL GALLERY Intriguing tale undone by loose ends

An intriguing tale undone by loose ends

Pitched as “a tale of two artists”, the National Gallery’s big autumn show promises a history woven in shades of friendship and rivalry, marriage and family, privilege and hard graft. Andrea Mantegna and Giovanni Bellini were brothers-in-law, Mantegna’s marriage to Nicolosia Bellini in 1453 a strategic match that brought fresh blood to Venice’s greatest artistic dynasty.

Charles I: King and Collector, Royal Academy review - a well executed display of taste

★★★★★ CHARLES I KING AND COLLECTOR, ROYAL ACADEMY the king's old masters sumptuously reunited

Collection of the king's Old Masters is sumptuously brought back together

Titian! Mantegna!  Rubens! Dürer! Veronese! Van Dyck! Raphael! Velazquez! About 140 works which were once part of Charles I’s 2,000-strong collection are reunited in a sumptuous collaboration between the Royal Academy and the Royal Collection. It is a marvellous selection covering the 15th to the 17th centuries, the Northern and Southern Renaissance and the baroque.

Breaking the Rules, LSO St Luke's review – music and murder with Gesualdo

★★★★ BREAKING THE RULES, LSO ST LUKE'S Music and murder with Gesualdo

Clare Norburn's concert drama receives a welcome London premiere

The “concert drama” is on the up, offering audiences a mingled-genre means to experience music and its context simultaneously. The author and singer Clare Norburn has an absolute peach of a story to tell in the "imagined testimony of Carlo Gesualdo, composer and murderer," the legendary musician who knifed to death his wife and her lover upon catching them in flagrante.

From Life, Royal Academy review - perplexingly aimless

★★ FROM LIFE, ROYAL ACADEMY A lacklustre account of a defining practice in western art

A lacklustre account of a defining practice in western art

Dedicated to a foundation stone of western artistic training, this exhibition attempts a celebratory note as the Royal Academy approaches its 250th anniversary. But if the printed guide handed to visitors offers a detailed overview of working from life, the exhibition itself is a far flimsier construction that never really establishes the purpose of a practice that it simultaneously wants us to believe is thriving today.

Monochrome, National Gallery review - colourless but not dreary

★★★ MONOCHROME, NATIONAL GALLERY Colourless but not dreary

An arcane subject brought to life in an ambitious survey

Might a painting ever achieve the veracity of a sculpture, a "real" object in space that we can walk around and view from every angle? Could the documentary quality of an engraving ever be equalled by a painting? And how could painting respond to photography – drawing with light – an invention that in the 19th century prompted a thorough reconsideration of painting’s purpose.