Best of 2014: Opera

BEST OF 2014: OPERA A vintage year as our reviewers struggle to narrow it down to a Top 10

A vintage year as our reviewers struggle to narrow it down to a Top 10

When everything works – conducting, singing, production, costumes, sets, lighting, choreography where relevant – then there’s nothing like the art of opera. But how often does that happen? In my experience, very seldom, but not this year. It's been of such a vintage that I couldn’t possibly choose the best out of six fully-staged productions – three of them from our only native director of genius, Richard Jones, who as one of his favourite singers, Susan Bullock, put it to me, deserves every gong going – and one concert performance.

La Bohème, English National Opera

LA BOHÈME, ENGLISH NATIONAL OPERA Star-voiced lovers move and soar, but revived Jonathan Miller production does little

Star-voiced lovers move and soar, but revived Jonathan Miller production does little

ENO may not always have matched the Royal Opera in the Great Puccini Voices stakes. But it's served up many of the classiest Mimìs, with Valerie Masterson, Mary Plazas and Elizabeth Llewellyn as top seamstresses. Californian former beauty queen Angel Blue, an acclaimed Musetta in the previous revival, now joins them.

The Girl of the Golden West, English National Opera

THE GIRL OF THE GOLDEN WEST, ENGLISH NATIONAL OPERA, Susan Bullock's Minnie gets her gun, and her man, in Puccini's wackiest melodrama

Susan Bullock's Minnie gets her gun, and her man, in Puccini's wackiest melodrama

So now it’s Minnie Get Your Gun from the director who brought us the gobsmackingly inventive Young Vic Annie (as in sharpshooter Oakley, not Little Orphan). Richard Jones’s subversive but still very human take on Irving Berlin discombobulated its American support and never made Broadway; but there’s little here that would rock the steadily progressive Met (home of La fanciulla del West’s 1910 premiere, with Enrico Caruso as “Dick Johnson” aka quickly repentant bandit Ramerrez).

theartsdesk Q&A: Tenor Michael Fabiano

MICHAEL FABIANO Now singing Donizetti's Poliuto at Glyndebourne, the American tenor gave an in-depth interview to theartsdesk last year

American singer on the brink of superstardom talks Verdi, competition and inspiration

You can usually trust the buzz around rehearsals. From Glyndebourne, five weeks into preparation for La traviata, which opens tomorrow, one of the team working on Tom Cairns’ new production declared in an e-mail conversation that newcomer soprano Venera Gimadieva was possibly the most definitive Violetta yet. And when I was havering over whether to interview American tenor Michael Fabiano, not by then having watched a wealth of stupendous videos on his website, the response was “you absolutely must”.

Lorin Maazel (1930-2014) on Puccini's Golden Girl

RIP LORIN MAAZEL The conductor, who has died aged 84, enthusing about Puccini's 'Golden Girl'

The conductor, who has died aged 84, enthusing in 1991 about a masterpiece

I met one of the 20th century’s most impressive, if not always sympathetic, conductors twice, on both occasions to talk Puccini before La Scala recordings of La fanciulla del West (The Girl of the Golden West) and Manon Lescaut.

Tosca, Longborough Festival

Puccini in a Gloucestershire barn impresses despite first night tremors

For Longborough to open their new season with Tosca after last summer’s triumphant Wagner is to invoke Joseph Kerman’s famous diatribe against Puccini’s “shabby little shocker” in his fifties book Opera as Drama. Kerman used Wagner’s theories to pick holes in Puccini’s at times flagrant theatricality: which only goes to show what an untheoretical thing opera can be.

Manon Lescaut, Royal Opera

MANON LESCAUT, ROYAL OPERA Peerless singers and conductor sapped by monster production

Vibrant, peerless singers and conductor sapped by invertebrate monster production

Puccini’s racy first masterpiece, like its successor La bohème, should feel like an opera of two halves – the first full of youthful exuberance, the second darker and ultimately tragic. The contrast here, alas, was between vivacious performers and a sombre, sometimes confused updating by Jonathan Kent which too often dwarfed or zapped their better efforts.

theartsdesk Q&A: Soprano Kristine Opolais

KRISTINE OPOLAIS The Royal Opera's sensational Manon Lescaut talks about new roles, ones she won't sing any more, and looks versus voice

The Royal Opera's Manon Lescaut talks about new roles, ones she won't sing any more, and looks versus voice

The best that you can usually expect from an interview is that it takes off from stock beginnings in spontaneous and unexpected directions. This one was rather exciting from the start: the end of a day in the life of a new role, Puccini's good-time girl Manon Lescaut, for lyric-dramatic soprano Kristine Opolais.

Kiri at 70

KIRI AT 70 The great New Zealand soprano embraces septuagenarian status in Covent Garden style

The great New Zealand soprano embraces septuagenarian status in Covent Garden style

Even more deserving of the sobriquet “the beautiful voice” than Renée Fleming, the natural successor who virtually copyrighted it, Kiri te Kanawa was one of the great sopranos of the 20th century. With those big, candid brown eyes and bone structure she’s still a beauty, as the images of her cameo role in the Royal Opera’s La Fille du régiment underline. The voice now – well, as I wrote in my review of Monday’s opening, it’s what you’d expect of a 70 year old with form.

Manon Lescaut, Welsh National Opera

MANON LESCAUT, WNO Puccini charmer rehoused in an airport lounge, saved by the conductor

Puccini charmer rehoused in an airport lounge, saved by the conductor

As before, WNO have a theme for their new opera season: this time it’s Fallen Women, a topic that might well attract the attention of the Equal Opportunities Commission. Surely men have the right to fall as well; we await, in June, The Fall of the House of Usher, a much fairer piece than Puccini’s Manon Lescaut, which opened the company’s winter season in a new production by the Polish director Mariusz Treliński. In Debussy’s Usher brother and sister both fall, and the house falls on top of them.