Sāvitri, Lauderdale House review - death and life in a Highgate garden

Hampstead Garden Opera works a little miracle with Holst's mystical music-drama

share this article

The cast of 'Sāvitri' take a bow, with the orchestra to the left
All images by Laurent Compagnon

In seach of Orpheus, and following a route from the Hades of (thankfully) masked beings on the underground to Archway, then up to a windy, grassy plateau just below Highgate village, this wandering critic encountered another myth about the power of life over death. Holst fashioned his Sāvitri, the only successful early (1907-8) fruit of the Sanskrit-translating composer’s quest to compose an Indian opera, as a short, bittersweet shoot from the riches of the epic Mahabhrata, remarkably concise (under half an hour) for its pre-war time.

The composer thought it would be best performed in the open air – quite a challenge for a music-drama which begins and ends with an unaccompanied solo voice – and Hampstead Garden Opera have shown unique initiative in making it the first out-of-lockdown experience of its kind.

Each live encounter of the new era manages to add some fresh dimension to all that we’ve been deprived of. In this case, for me (though not for Boyd Tonkin reviewing Opera Holland Park's second offering here) it was a chorus of eight female voices, emerging from the depths of Lauderdale House beyond the lawn on which we were so thoughtfully placed in chalked squares. The 12-piece orchestra conducted by Thomas Payne sat just behind an open door, and minutes after a heavy sudden shower and a rainbow above Waterlow Park’s great copper beech, Death, also from within the house, struck up his claim for Sāvitri’s husband Satyavān in the handsome physical and vocal personage of Dan D’Souza (pictured below). Dan D'Souza as Death in SavitriThe simple narrative could be clearly followed as the three fine young operatic voices in the cast I heard – as well as D’Souza, soprano Lizzie Holmes as Sāvitri and tenor Jack Roberts as her doomed woodsman husband – made themselves heard, valiantly unamplified, against the wind in the trees, the orchestra slightliy less so (though it was as well that the double-bass, for which Holst writes with special eloquencey, happened to be nearest the door).

Director Julia Mintzer didn’t add much to the essence with a single dancer (Laura Calcagno, fine in what was asked of her), the one emergence of the heavenly maidens or the significance of the writings on the central mirror (in which at least one could see the clouds massing behind us). It also seemed odd to alter the denouement, Sāvitri’s radiant outwitting of Death by asking him the boon of Life, which for her can mean only Satyavān (Roberts, pictured below with Holmes) restored to her, by having our heroine walk into death’s domain rather than away with her husband in the opposite direction. Sāvitri become Alcestis, perhaps. Scene from SavitriNo matter; the essence of Holst’s inspiration – adapting the English folksong style alongside the occasional Indian mode, a climax still in thrall to the Wagnerism he thought he had left behind – still shone through, with properly operatic singing matched to plausible acting. It’s a pity the excellent vocal ensemble couldn’t have taken up Holst’s suggestion that they perform the bracing “Hymn of the Traveller” from his slightly later third group of choral settings from the Rig Veda as a prelude - true, that would have meant engaging a harpist - but under the circumstances no-one should have left unhappy with what we did get. And sheer gratitude for enterprise in our still-beleaguered country, where soaring infection rates have ruled out visits to bigger musical experiences elsewhere in Europe, overwhelms any slight quibbles. Magical setting, sublime music.

Holst thought his Indian-inspired mini-opera would be best performed in the open air

rating

4

explore topics

share this article

Support the future of arts journalism

Subscribe to theartsdesk.com

Thanks so much for choosing genuinely independent arts journalism theartsdesk’s mission has never been more important – in an age of relentless algorithmic recommendation, sponsored content and unreliable AI, the expertise and discernment of individual critics deeply embedded in their specialist areas is absolutely vital.

If you want more of that in your life, why not subscribe now?

If you do this before the 31st August, you’ll be able to keep at this “founders rate” for life: your subs will never increase! You can choose to subscribe annually for just £40 simply click here
or monthly for £5 per month simply click here.

Not ready to subscribe?

If you want to support with a little extra or aren’t ready to subscribe just yet, there’s also the option to give direct to our crowdfunder to support our imminent redesign and exciting expansion with new features and collaborations Simply contribute here: https://gofund.me/c3f6033d.

However you choose to be involved, you can proudly say that you are picking the right side in the battle for truth and humanity in the modern information landscape. And we will be very glad to have you on board!

more opera

Quality take on Verdi and a pure comedy re-imagining of Léhar
Turbocharged orchestra, sometimes too much so, various approaches from the singers
Richard Jones tries hard with Bellini's vehicle for lyric madness; Lisette Oropesa dazzles
Paula Murrihy is a majestic Persian king, though the orchestra is more flouncy than fiery
William Kentridge's vision subtly blends his political experiences with mythology
Fine music-making illuminates Debussy's sinister blend of realism and romance
In concert, Mozart's farewell opera burns bright
Not a huge number of laughs, but plenty of vocal charm from tenor and soprano
Niamh O'Sullivan is the perfect Knight of the Rose in classy revival
40th anniversary event overcomes disruption with exquisite music-making